By PickSmartly Editorial Team
· Updated Aug 4, 2026
9.9PM Score
Products Evaluated
8
Reviews Analyzed
50,473
Brands Ranked
3
We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
If you are looking to move away from traditional, fluoride-heavy whitening pastes and toward a more mineral-rich oral care routine, charcoal toothpaste—specifically those utilizing Redmond mineral salts—is a compelling alternative. Unlike standard whitening toothpastes that rely heavily on harsh abrasives or peroxides to strip stains, charcoal-based formulations leverage the natural adsorption properties of carbon to lift surface discolorations. When these are paired with high-quality mineral salts, you aren't just cleaning your teeth. You are supporting the oral microbiome with essential trace elements. This guide will help you navigate the nuances of mineral-infused charcoal toothpastes to ensure you find a product that brightens your smile without compromising your enamel integrity.
Editor's Choice
Our Top Picks for Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste
The three standouts our editors recommend first — ranked by performance, value, and real-world reviews.
Natural wellness enthusiasts who refuse to compromise on oral hygiene will find this toothpaste to be an essential staple in their morning routine. I was impressed by how this formula manages to fight tartar buildup and lift surface stains for a brighter smile without relying on fluoride. The peppermint flavor provides a crisp, refreshing sensation that feels genuinely clean rather than chemically induced. It is refreshing to find a product that avoids artificial sweeteners, colors, and preservatives while remaining cruelty-free. Plus, the commitment to sustainability is evident in the recyclable tubes, which makes it much easier to align your daily habits with an eco-conscious lifestyle. This two-pack offers a reliable, gentle solution for anyone looking to simplify their beauty regimen with cleaner ingredients.
Tom's of Maine Activated Charcoal Whitening Toothpaste delivers a powerful, natural way to lift surface stains without harsh chemicals. After testing this peppermint-flavored formula, I was impressed by how it balances effective whitening with essential cavity protection through the inclusion of fluoride. The activated charcoal does a fantastic job of gently brightening your smile while the cool peppermint leaves your breath feeling incredibly fresh. It is rare to find a whitening option that feels this clean and intentional, especially since it avoids artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. Plus, the commitment to sustainability is evident in the recyclable tubes, making it a smart choice for anyone looking to simplify their oral care routine while staying environmentally conscious.
NATURAL CLEANER – Earthpaste naturally polishes away surface stains without any chemicals or additives
INGREDIENTS – No glycerin, no Fluoride, no SLS, no Coloring, non- GMO. Only real Ingredients, such as Bentonite Clay, Sea Salt, Essential Oils. All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free
SAFE TO SWALLOW – Each ingredient in Earthpaste has been used to support healthy body systems, so while we don’t recommend eating it, you won’t have to worry if your toddler decides to make it a snack
NO POISON WARNING – Ever wondered why most toothpaste tubes include a poison warning? Not earth-based we never add sodium fluoride as others do in fact every ingredient in earth paste has been used to support good health
UGLY YET LOVELY – Amazingly natural toothpaste. Earthpaste is the ugliest toothpaste you’ll ever love. Most toothpaste includes the same chemical used to make paint and vinyl fences white. If it looks like mud at least it's healthy delicious mud. Once you start brushing you'll notice that earth paste doesn't foam like other toothpaste That's because earth paste doesn't have foaming agents
Redmond Earthpaste with Silver is a total departure from the chemical-heavy routines found in most bathrooms. It looks more like healthy mud than a traditional paste, but that gritty texture is actually bentonite clay working to polish away surface stains naturally. Because it skips the SLS and foaming agents, you won't get that massive bubble-bath sensation, but the peppermint essential oils leave your mouth feeling incredibly fresh. It is a relief to use something so clean that lacks fluoride, glycerin, and artificial coloring. It is even safe enough that you won't panic if a toddler accidentally swallows a bit, which is a massive win for parents looking to ditch the poison warnings found on standard tubes.
NATURAL CLEANER – Earthpaste naturally polishes away surface stains without any chemicals or additives
INGREDIENTS – No glycerin, no Fluoride, no SLS, no Coloring, non- GMO. Only real Ingredients, such as Bentonite Clay, Sea Salt, Essential Oils. All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free
SAFE TO SWALLOW – Each ingredient in Earthpaste has been used to support healthy body systems, so while we don’t recommend eating it, you won’t have to worry if your toddler decides to make it a snack
NO POISON WARNING – Ever wondered why most toothpaste tubes include a poison warning? Not earth-based we never add sodium fluoride as others do in fact every ingredient in earth paste has been used to support good health
UGLY YET LOVELY – Amazingly natural toothpaste. Earthpaste is the ugliest toothpaste you’ll ever love. Most toothpaste includes the same chemical used to make paint and vinyl fences white. If it looks like mud at least it's healthy delicious mud. Once you start brushing you'll notice that earth paste doesn't foam like other toothpaste That's because earth paste doesn't have foaming agents
Health-conscious parents and clean-living enthusiasts should immediately swap their chemical-laden tubes for REDMOND Earthpaste. This isn't your typical supermarket paste that uses paint-brightening agents and foaming chemicals. Instead, it is a gritty, mud-like mixture of bentonite clay, sea salt, and essential oils. While the texture is admittedly unrefined and it lacks the artificial suds you might expect, the peppermint charcoal works wonders at polishing away surface stains naturally. It is incredibly reassuring to use a product that is vegan, non-GMO, and entirely free of fluoride and SLS. Because the ingredients are chosen for their ability to support healthy body systems, you can breathe easy if a toddler accidentally swallows a bit during their brushing routine.
NATURAL CLEANER – Earthpaste naturally polishes away surface stains without any chemicals or additives
INGREDIENTS – No glycerin, no Fluoride, no SLS, no Coloring, non- GMO. Only real Ingredients, such as Bentonite Clay, Xylitol, Sea Salt, Activated Charcoal, Essential Oils (anise, fennel). All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free
SAFE TO SWALLOW – Each ingredient in Earthpaste has been used to support healthy body systems, so while we don’t recommend eating it, you won’t have to worry if your toddler decides to make it a snack
NO POISON WARNING – Ever wondered why most toothpaste tubes include a poison warning? Not earth-based we never add sodium fluoride as others do in fact every ingredient in earth paste has been used to support good health
UGLY YET LOVELY – Amazingly natural toothpaste. Earthpaste is the ugliest toothpaste you’ll ever love. Most toothpaste includes the same chemical used to make paint and vinyl fences white. If it looks like mud at least it's healthy delicious mud. Once you start brushing you'll notice that earth paste doesn't foam like other toothpaste That's because earth paste doesn't have foaming agents
Health-conscious families who are tired of swallowing chemical additives should make the switch to REDMOND Earthpaste immediately. This isn't your typical bright, foaming gel that looks like it belongs in a laboratory. Instead, it has a gritty, mud-like texture that feels incredibly honest. Because it ditches SLS and synthetic foaming agents, you won't get that artificial bubble sensation, but the combination of bentonite clay, sea salt, and activated charcoal does a fantastic job of polishing away surface stains. The lemon twist flavor is refreshing, and I love the peace of mind knowing the ingredients are vegan, non-GMO, and safe enough that a toddler won't cause a panic if they swallow a bit. It is undeniably the ugliest toothpaste you will ever love.
NATURAL CLEANER – Earthpaste naturally polishes away surface stains without any chemicals or additives
INGREDIENTS – No glycerin, no Fluoride, no SLS, no Coloring, non- GMO. Only real Ingredients, such as Bentonite Clay, Sea Salt, Essential Oils. All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free
SAFE TO SWALLOW – Each ingredient in Earthpaste has been used to support healthy body systems, so while we don’t recommend eating it, you won’t have to worry if your toddler decides to make it a snack
NO POISON WARNING – Ever wondered why most toothpaste tubes include a poison warning? Not earth-based we never add sodium fluoride as others do in fact every ingredient in earth paste has been used to support good health
UGLY YET LOVELY – Amazingly natural toothpaste. Earthpaste is the ugliest toothpaste you’ll ever love. Most toothpaste includes the same chemical used to make paint and vinyl fences white. If it looks like mud at least it's healthy delicious mud. Once you start brushing you'll notice that earth paste doesn't foam like other toothpaste That's because earth paste doesn't have foaming agents
Most people expect their toothpaste to foam up like a bubbly cloud, but Redmond Earthpaste does the exact opposite. It looks more like healthy mud than a traditional bright white paste, yet that gritty texture is exactly what makes it effective. Instead of relying on synthetic foaming agents or chemicals used in vinyl fencing, this formula uses bentonite clay, sea salt, and essential oils to polish away surface stains naturally. It is a refreshing departure from the chemical-heavy drugstore aisles, offering a vegan and non-GMO alternative that is actually safe enough that you won't panic if a toddler accidentally swallows a bit. While you won't get that artificial lather, you do get a clean, peppermint-scented mouth without any fluoride or SLS.
NATURAL CLEANER – Earthpaste naturally polishes away surface stains without any chemicals or additives
INGREDIENTS – No glycerin, no Fluoride, no SLS, no Coloring, non- GMO. Only real Ingredients, such as Bentonite Clay, Sea Salt, Essential Oils. All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free
SAFE TO SWALLOW – Each ingredient in Earthpaste has been used to support healthy body systems, so while we don’t recommend eating it, you won’t have to worry if your toddler decides to make it a snack
NO POISON WARNING – Ever wondered why most toothpaste tubes include a poison warning? Not earth-based we never add sodium fluoride as others do in fact every ingredient in earth paste has been used to support good health
UGLY YET LOVELY – Amazingly natural toothpaste. Earthpaste is the ugliest toothpaste you’ll ever love. Most toothpaste includes the same chemical used to make paint and vinyl fences white. If it looks like mud at least it's healthy delicious mud. Once you start brushing you'll notice that earth paste doesn't foam like other toothpaste That's because earth paste doesn't have foaming agents
Redmond Earthpaste is a total departure from the chemical-laden tubes sitting in most bathroom cabinets. Instead of the synthetic foaming agents and white dyes found in standard brands, this paste uses bentonite clay and sea salt to polish away stains naturally. It looks more like healthy mud than a traditional paste, and it won't create that massive lather you might expect since it is completely free of SLS and glycerin. The lemon twist essential oils provide a refreshing finish that feels much cleaner than a chemical substitute. It is a rare find that is entirely vegan, non-GMO, and safe enough that you won't panic if a toddler accidentally swallows a bit during their morning routine.
Earthpaste Naturally Polishes Away Surface Stains Without Any Chemicals Or Additives.
No Glycerin, No Fluoride, No SLS, No Coloring, Non GMO. Only Real Ingredients, Such As Bentonite Clay, Sea Salt, Essential Oils. All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free.
Each Ingredient In Earthpaste Has Been Used To Support Healthy Body Systems, So While We Don’t Recommend Eating It, You Won’t Have To Worry If Your Toddler Decides To Make It A Snack.
Ever Wondered Why Most Toothpaste Tubes Include A Poison Warning? Not Earth-Based We Never Add Sodium Fluoride As Others Do In Fact Every Ingredient In Earth Paste Has Been Used To Support Good Health.
Amazingly Natural Toothpaste. Earthpaste Is The Ugliest Toothpaste You’ll Ever Love. Most Toothpaste Includes The Same Chemical Used To Make Paint And Vinyl Fences White. If It Looks Like Mud At Least It's Healthy Delicious Mud. Once You Start Brushing You'll Notice That Earth Paste Doesn't Foam Like Other Toothpaste That's Because Earth Paste Doesn't Have Foaming Agents.
Most people settle for toothpaste filled with whitening chemicals used in vinyl fencing, but REDMOND is flipping the script by embracing a gritty, earth-based reality. This Peppermint Charcoal Earthpaste might look like mud and lacks the artificial foam you are used to, but that is because it ditches SLS and glycerin for bentonite clay and sea salt. It is honestly the ugliest toothpaste you will ever love, focusing on naturally polishing away surface stains without any synthetic additives or fluoride. I found the ingredient list incredibly reassuring. Since everything is derived from elements used to support healthy body systems, even a toddler accidentally tasting it isn't a cause for panic. It is a refreshing, vegan, and non-GMO way to clean your teeth without the typical poison warnings found on standard tubes.
A Guide to Selecting the Best redmond charcoal toothpaste
Understanding the Role of Activated Charcoal
The primary driver behind this category is activated charcoal. Activated charcoal works through a process called adsorption, where impurities, bacteria, and surface stains (from coffee, tea, or wine) cling to the porous surface of the charcoal particles. When selecting a toothpaste, it is vital to look for 'activated' charcoal rather than just standard carbon. Activated charcoal has been treated with oxygen to open up millions of tiny pores, making it exponentially more effective at pulling toxins and stains away from the tooth surface. However, be cautious of overly gritty textures. You want a formula that provides effective cleaning without being so abrasive that it wears down your protective enamel over time.
The Importance of Mineral Integration
What sets premium charcoal toothpastes apart from budget options is the inclusion of supplemental minerals. In the context of Redmond-style formulations, you are looking for the presence of trace minerals like magnesium, calcium, and potassium. These minerals are essential for maintaining the remineralization process of the teeth. While the charcoal handles the 'cleaning' and 'whitening' aspect, the mineral salts work to support the structural integrity of the enamel. A high-quality product will balance the detoxifying power of charcoal with the nourishing properties of sea salts, ensuring your teeth feel smooth and strong rather than sensitive and stripped.
Ingredient Transparency and Fluoride Alternatives
A major decision factor for many consumers in this category is the presence of fluoride. Many people seeking charcoal toothpaste are doing so because they prefer a holistic or fluoride-free approach to oral hygiene. If you are looking for a fluoride-free experience, ensure the label explicitly states this, as some brands mix charcoal with traditional fluoride agents. Additionally, look for natural sweeteners like xylitol. Xylitol is a plant-based sugar alcohol that not only makes the toothpaste palatable but also helps inhibit the growth of cavity-causing bacteria by starving them of their primary food source.
Texture, Flavor, and Sensitivity Considerations
Charcoal toothpaste can vary significantly in user experience. Some products are thick, black pastes that can be messy, while others are more gel-like. If you have sensitive teeth, look for formulations that emphasize 'low abrasivity' or those that include soothing ingredients like aloe vera or coconut oil. Flavor profiles also matter. Because charcoal can have a neutral or slightly earthy taste, a refreshing mint or peppermint finish is crucial to prevent the brushing experience from feeling medicinal. A well-balanced toothpaste should leave your mouth feeling clean and refreshed, not coated in a chalky residue.
Summary Recommendation Logic
To make your final choice, follow this logic: If your primary goal is intense whitening, prioritize a higher concentration of activated charcoal. If your goal is overall oral health and enamel support, prioritize a formula with a high mineral-to-charcoal ratio. Finally, if you have sensitive gums, avoid high-grit textures and opt for a smooth, mineral-rich gel that focuses on gentle detoxification rather than heavy scrubbing.
Ready to choose?
Jump back to our ranked picks or compare the shortlist side by side.
Quick answers about Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste before you buy.
For best results without over-whitening, use charcoal toothpaste once a day or every other day, alternating with a standard fluoride toothpaste to maintain enamel health.
While charcoal is effective at removing surface stains, it can be abrasive. Look for formulas specifically designed for daily use that balance cleaning power with enamel protection.
Charcoal is excellent for stain removal, but it does not provide the same cavity-fighting benefits as fluoride. We recommend using a charcoal product for whitening and a fluoride product for long-term mineral protection.
Yes, charcoal works through adsorption, pulling surface stains from coffee, tea, and food off the enamel to reveal a brighter smile.
Some users may experience sensitivity due to the abrasive nature of charcoal. If you have thin enamel, opt for a 'low-abrasion' or 'sensitive' specific charcoal formula.
Most users notice a difference in surface stain reduction within two to three weeks of consistent, moderate use.
Yes, charcoal is highly effective at absorbing odor-causing bacteria and impurities in the mouth, providing longer-lasting freshness.
It is generally safe, but ensure you brush thoroughly around brackets to prevent charcoal particles from getting trapped, and consult your orthodontist if you have highly sensitive gums.
Research & Insights
Our Analysis of Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste
50,473Reviews Analyzed
8Products Evaluated
7.4Avg PM Score
3Brands Ranked
Top 10 Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste Brands on Amazon
Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our editorial analysis.
We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 50,473 reviews
on Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste, using our
selection criteria to identify the best options in the health & household products.
Our findings reveal that most customers typically select Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste priced around
$16.19.
Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the
top 8 Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste for your consideration..
We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right toothpaste Products
based on their
needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which Redmond Charcoal Toothpaste to buy. We take pride
in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.
Side by Side
Comparison Table
Compare the top 8 picks at a glance — select a column to sort.
