Best Mineral Oil Free Eye Makeup in 2026

Daisy
Last Updated: Feb 6, 2026

At a Glance: Our Top Picks for Mineral Oil Free Eye Makeup

Pupa Milano Made To Last Waterproof Eyeshadow - Long Wear, Pigmented Cream Shadow Stick - Smudge Proof, Easy Blending Formula - Satin, Pearl, and Metallic Shades - 030 Chocolate - 0.049 oz
#TOP1
Pupa Milano Made To Last Waterproof Eyeshadow -
9.3
PM SCORE
Pupa Milano Vamp! Wet And Dry Baked Eyeshadow - Brilliant And Highly Pigmented Colors - Light And Creamy Makeup Formula - Professional Quality Shimmer Powder Eye Shadows - 103 Rose Gold - 0.035 Oz
#TOP2
Pupa Milano Vamp! Wet And Dry Baked Eyeshadow
9.2
PM SCORE
Pupa Milano Vamp! Wet And Dry Baked Eyeshadow - Brilliant, Highly Pigmented Colors - Light And Creamy Makeup Formula - Professional Quality Shimmer Powder Eye Shadows - 100 Champagne Gold - 0.035 Oz
#TOP3
Pupa Milano Vamp! Wet And Dry Baked Eyeshadow
9.1
PM SCORE

* PickSmartly editors independently research, review, and endorse the top products through comprehensive data analysis. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through our product links.

Summary of the Best Mineral Oil Free Eye Makeup of 2026

Market Overview
Mineral Oil Free Eye Makeup Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 666 Items
  • PM Avg. Rating: 6.1 / 10
13 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $21.93
  • Lowest Price: $12.43
  • Avg. Price: $15.90

Pupa Milano Made To Last Waterproof Eyeshadow - Long Wear, Pigmented Cream Shadow Stick - Smudge Proof, Easy Blending Formula - Satin, Pearl, And Metallic Shades - 030 Chocolate - 0.049 Oz

PUPA
I0111918
0.60 X 0.60 X 5.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

YOUR DREAMIEST SHADOW LOOK. This luminous, bright, shade comes in convenient stick form, for effortlessly gliding and blending color onto your lid. Made To Last shadows are water and humidity resistant, to outlast anything the day throws your way.

THE PERFECT POP OF COLOR. Highly pigmented on skin, this shadow stick delivers intense shimmer and shine with a sweep of product. Creamy, lightweight, and fully waterproof, Made To Last blesses your lids with a cake free, smudge-proof shadow look.

NO BRUSHES NECESSARY. This crayon-style shadow stick makes detailed shadow strokes AND blended looks easy. Made To Last even arrives with a convenient sharpener tool, to ensure that your shadow stick is always prepped to precisely apply product.

PIGMENTS FOR EVERY SHADOW STYLE. Made To Last shadows come in a variety of trendy pigments with 4 shimmery finishes: Satin, Pearly, Extra Pearly, and Metallic. And, all formulas are Opthamologist tested and Paraben Free for your eye and skin health.

MAKEUP AND SKINCARE FROM ITALY. Pupa Milano delivers a range top quality, Italian-made makeup and skincare products. We're constantly innovating and evolving to make sure you have each and every beauty product you need to express your best self.

Pupa Milano Vamp! Wet And Dry Baked Eyeshadow - Brilliant And Highly Pigmented Colors - Light And Creamy Makeup Formula - Professional Quality Shimmer Powder Eye Shadows - 103 Rose Gold - 0.035 Oz

PUPA
PU040245A103
0.80 X 1.90 X 1.90 Inches
0.04 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
AmTm Cosmetics 9.88

Features

SILKY TEXTURE GLIDES ONTO SKIN. Our beautifully crafted formula feature a luxurious, velvety texture that glides effortlessly onto skin, without tugging or pulling. Experience a light and comfortable finish with our ultra finely milled eyeshadows.

POTENT PIGMENTS COVER SKIN WITH EASE. Our incredibly pigmented pressed powder eyeshadows deliver intense color payoff with minimal effort, making it easy to create glamorous looks. Add a pop of color or create a neutral smokey eye look in seconds.

BEAUTIFULLY BLENDABLE FORMULA. Featuring a wonderfully blendable formula, our shadows allow you to create seamless gradients without any tedious blending techniques. Create colorful, shimmering makeup looks that enhance your best features and face.

LONG WEARING, WET OR DRY. Our unique formula is designed for buildable intensity and all day wear. Apply wet or dry, depending on desired vibrance, and enjoy your iridescent eyelids all day long. Use with an eyeshadow base or apply directly on skin.

OPHTHALMOLOGIST TESTED AND LOW ALLERGY RISK. Carefully tested by eye experts, so you can enjoy your beauty routine without any worries, even those with sensitive skin. Our products are low allergy risk and Paraben free for your health and safety.

Pupa Milano Vamp! Wet And Dry Baked Eyeshadow - Brilliant, Highly Pigmented Colors - Light And Creamy Makeup Formula - Professional Quality Shimmer Powder Eye Shadows - 100 Champagne Gold - 0.035 Oz

PUPA
PU040245A100
0.80 X 1.90 X 1.90 Inches
0.04 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

LONG WEARING, WET OR DRY. Our unique formula is designed for buildable intensity and all day wear. Apply wet or dry, depending on desired vibrance, and enjoy your iridescent eyelids all day long. Use with an eyeshadow base or apply directly on skin.

SILKY TEXTURE GLIDES ONTO SKIN. Our beautifully crafted formula feature a luxurious, velvety texture that glides effortlessly onto skin, without tugging or pulling. Experience a light and comfortable finish with our ultra finely milled eyeshadows.

POTENT PIGMENTS COVER SKIN WITH EASE. Our incredibly pigmented pressed powder eyeshadows deliver intense color payoff with minimal effort, making it easy to create glamorous looks. Add a pop of color or create a neutral smokey eye look in seconds.

BEAUTIFULLY BLENDABLE FORMULA. Featuring a wonderfully blendable formula, our shadows allow you to create seamless gradients without any tedious blending techniques. Create colorful, shimmering makeup looks that enhance your best features and face.

OPHTHALMOLOGIST TESTED AND LOW ALLERGY RISK. Carefully tested by eye experts, so you can enjoy your beauty routine without any worries, even those with sensitive skin. Our products are low allergy risk and Paraben free for your health and safety.

Pupa Milano Made To Last Waterproof Eyeshadow - Long Wear, Pigmented Cream Shadow Stick - Smudge Proof, Easy Blending Formula - Satin, Pearl, And Metallic Shades - 010 Shocking Violet - 0.049 Oz

PUPA
8011607228812
0.60 X 0.60 X 5.00 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

YOUR DREAMIEST SHADOW LOOK. This luminous, bright, shade comes in convenient stick form, for effortlessly gliding and blending color onto your lid. Made To Last shadows are water and humidity resistant, to outlast anything the day throws your way.

THE PERFECT POP OF COLOR. Highly pigmented on skin, this shadow stick delivers intense shimmer and shine with a sweep of product. Creamy, lightweight, and fully waterproof, Made To Last blesses your lids with a cake free, smudge-proof shadow look.

NO BRUSHES NECESSARY. This crayon-style shadow stick makes detailed shadow strokes AND blended looks easy. Made To Last even arrives with a convenient sharpener tool, to ensure that your shadow stick is always prepped to precisely apply product.

PIGMENTS FOR EVERY SHADOW STYLE. Made To Last shadows come in a variety of trendy pigments with 4 shimmery finishes: Satin, Pearly, Extra Pearly, and Metallic. And, all formulas are Opthamologist tested and Paraben Free for your eye and skin health.

MAKEUP AND SKINCARE FROM ITALY. Pupa Milano delivers a range top quality, Italian-made makeup and skincare products. We're constantly innovating and evolving to make sure you have each and every beauty product you need to express your best self.

Pupa Milano Made To Last Waterproof Eyeshadow - Long Wear, Pigmented Cream Shadow Stick - Smudge Proof, Easy Blending Formula - Satin, Pearl, And Metallic Shades - 006 Bronze Brown - 0.049 Oz

PUPA
8011607228775
0.60 X 0.60 X 5.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

YOUR DREAMIEST SHADOW LOOK. This luminous, bright, shade comes in convenient stick form, for effortlessly gliding and blending color onto your lid. Made To Last shadows are water and humidity resistant, to outlast anything the day throws your way.

THE PERFECT POP OF COLOR. Highly pigmented on skin, this shadow stick delivers intense shimmer and shine with a sweep of product. Creamy, lightweight, and fully waterproof, Made To Last blesses your lids with a cake free, smudge-proof shadow look.

NO BRUSHES NECESSARY. This crayon-style shadow stick makes detailed shadow strokes AND blended looks easy. Made To Last even arrives with a convenient sharpener tool, to ensure that your shadow stick is always prepped to precisely apply product.

PIGMENTS FOR EVERY SHADOW STYLE. Made To Last shadows come in a variety of trendy pigments with 4 shimmery finishes: Satin, Pearly, Extra Pearly, and Metallic. And, all formulas are Opthamologist tested and Paraben Free for your eye and skin health.

MAKEUP AND SKINCARE FROM ITALY. Pupa Milano delivers a range top quality, Italian-made makeup and skincare products. We're constantly innovating and evolving to make sure you have each and every beauty product you need to express your best self.

Pupa Milano Vamp! Compact Duo Eyeshadow - Adjustable Coverage And Great Blendability - High Concentration Of Pigments - Extra Fine And Texture - 006 Brown Vanilla - 0.078 Oz

PUPA
I0111747
0.60 X 2.90 X 2.00 Inches
0.10 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

COSMETICS APPROVED BY THE EYE EXPERTS. Our eyeshadow is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of any parabens, so you can feel good about the product you're putting onto your skin.

SOFT LIKE SILK. The silky formula of our eyeshadow applies easily, thanks to its creamy texture that ensures the product blends seamlessly without clinging to any dry patches. The smooth, lightweight texture glides on and adheres for long wear.

HIGH PIGMENTATION PAYOFF. This highly pigmented formula provides maximum coverage and has a soft, blendable texture that lasts all day and night. Our eyeshadow features concentrated pigmentation that provides instant payoff and lasts all day.

CHANNELING VITALITY VIA SENSORIAL EXPERIENCES. Colors, textures and sensorial emotions are continuously evolving thanks to scientific research, state of the art technology and innovation. PUPA Milano is makeup and skin care with top quality appeal.

PUPA Milano - MADE IN ITALY. PUPA Milano is all about creativity, design, trends and "Made in Italy" beauty. Discover our complete range of luxury makeup, skin care, beauty kits, and sun care products. Perfect for any occasion, big or small.

Pupa Milano Vamp! Matt Compact Eyeshadow - Extreme Matte Finish - Silky Velvet Formula Applies Easily - Creamy Texture Ensure Powders Blend Seamlessly - Lasts All Day - 040 Warm Nude - 0.088 Oz

PUPA
I0111786
0.80 X 1.90 X 1.90 Inches
0.04 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

COSMETICS APPROVED BY THE EYE EXPERTS. Our eyeshadow is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of any parabens, so you can feel good about the product you're putting onto your skin.

SOFT LIKE SILK. The silky formula of our eyeshadow applies easily, thanks to its creamy texture that ensures the product blends seamlessly without clinging to any dry patches. The smooth, lightweight texture glides on and adheres for long wear.

HIGH PIGMENTATION PAYOFF. This highly pigmented formula provides maximum coverage and has a soft, blendable texture that lasts all day and night. Our eyeshadow features concentrated pigmentation that provides instant payoff and lasts all day.

CHANNELING VITALITY VIA SENSORIAL EXPERIENCES. Colors, textures and sensorial emotions are continuously evolving thanks to scientific research, state of the art technology and innovation. PUPA Milano is makeup and skin care with top quality appeal.

PUPA Milano - MADE IN ITALY. PUPA Milano is all about creativity, design, trends and "Made in Italy" beauty. Discover our complete range of luxury makeup, skin care, beauty kits, and sun care products. Perfect for any occasion, big or small.

Pupa Milano Pupart S Make-Up Palette - Silky Concealers And Blush - Compact Eyeshadows - Shiny Gloss, Matte Lip Creams - Makeup For Eyes, Lips, Face - Make Different Looks - 002 Stay Strong - 0.32 Oz

PUPA
8011607351930
1.20 X 8.40 X 3.70 Inches
0.11 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
StyleRule 9.41

Features

ALL-IN-ONE KIT IS SUPER CONVENIENT; Our bundles contain all the elements you need to create beautiful, pigmented eyes, lips and face; They're great for travel and on-the-go;

EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO CREATE AMAZING LOOKS; Our amazing all-in-one kits are perfect for creating an incredible variety of looks with just one palette; They're also a space-saving travel solution to doing your makeup on the go!

INTENSE COLOR THAT MAKES AN IMPACT; PUPA Milano lip products are formulated with a high concentration of Stay Strong pigments that provides pure color and superior, show-stopping coverage for every occasion;

APPLY PURE PIGMENT TO THE EYES; The intense color glides onto the eyelids to offer stunning payoff; The unparalleled pigmentation makes the difference in any eye look;

SET SKIN ON THE GO; This convenient compact can travel with you on the go for touch-ups to maintain your flawless face; The lightweight makeup smooths over the skin beautifully;

Pupa Milano Vamp! Extreme Cream Powder Eyeshadow - Ultra-Creamy Texture - Adheres Beautifully To The Eyelids - Intense Metallic Finish - Rich In Pigment - Paraben-Free - 002 Extreme Copper - 0.088 Oz

PUPA
I0111790
0.70 X 1.90 X 1.90 Inches
0.04 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

COSMETICS APPROVED BY THE EYE EXPERTS. Our eyeshadow is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of any parabens, so you can feel good about the product you're putting onto your skin.

SOFT LIKE SILK. The silky formula of our eyeshadow applies easily, thanks to its creamy texture that ensures the product blends seamlessly without clinging to any dry patches. The smooth, lightweight texture glides on and adheres for long wear.

HIGH PIGMENTATION PAYOFF. This highly pigmented formula provides maximum coverage and has a soft, blendable texture that lasts all day and night. Our eyeshadow features concentrated pigmentation that provides instant payoff and lasts all day.

CHANNELING VITALITY VIA SENSORIAL EXPERIENCES. Colors, textures and sensorial emotions are continuously evolving thanks to scientific research, state of the art technology and innovation. PUPA Milano is makeup and skin care with top quality appeal.

PUPA Milano - MADE IN ITALY. PUPA Milano is all about creativity, design, trends and "Made in Italy" beauty. Discover our complete range of luxury makeup, skin care, beauty kits, and sun care products. Perfect for any occasion, big or small.

Pupa Milano Natural Side Compact Eyeshadow - Silky, Blendable And Nude Single Shadow For Eyes - Satin-Effect - Provides Intense Neutral Pigments Of All Depths - 005 Gold Glimmer - 0.07 Oz

PUPA
I0111808
1.00 X 2.00 X 2.20 Inches
0.08 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

COSMETICS APPROVED BY THE EYE EXPERTS. Our eyeshadow is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of any parabens, so you can feel good about the product you're putting onto your skin.

SOFT LIKE SILK. The silky formula of our eyeshadow applies easily, thanks to its creamy texture that ensures the product blends seamlessly without clinging to any dry patches. The smooth, lightweight texture glides on and adheres for long wear.

HIGH PIGMENTATION PAYOFF. This highly pigmented formula provides maximum coverage and has a soft, blendable texture that lasts all day and night. Our eyeshadow features concentrated pigmentation that provides instant payoff and lasts all day.

CHANNELING VITALITY VIA SENSORIAL EXPERIENCES. Colors, textures and sensorial emotions are continuously evolving thanks to scientific research, state of the art technology and innovation. PUPA Milano is makeup and skin care with top quality appeal.

PUPA Milano - MADE IN ITALY. PUPA Milano is all about creativity, design, trends and "Made in Italy" beauty. Discover our complete range of luxury makeup, skin care, beauty kits, and sun care products. Perfect for any occasion, big or small.

Pupa Milano Natural Side Compact Eyeshadow - Silky, Blendable And Nude Single Shadow For Eyes - Satin-Effect - Provides Intense Neutral Pigments Of All Depths - 007 Copper Fever - 0.07 Oz

PUPA
I0111810
1.00 X 2.00 X 2.20 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

COSMETICS APPROVED BY THE EYE EXPERTS. Our eyeshadow is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of any parabens, so you can feel good about the product you're putting onto your skin.

SOFT LIKE SILK. The silky formula of our eyeshadow applies easily, thanks to its creamy texture that ensures the product blends seamlessly without clinging to any dry patches. The smooth, lightweight texture glides on and adheres for long wear.

HIGH PIGMENTATION PAYOFF. This highly pigmented formula provides maximum coverage and has a soft, blendable texture that lasts all day and night. Our eyeshadow features concentrated pigmentation that provides instant payoff and lasts all day.

CHANNELING VITALITY VIA SENSORIAL EXPERIENCES. Colors, textures and sensorial emotions are continuously evolving thanks to scientific research, state of the art technology and innovation. PUPA Milano is makeup and skin care with top quality appeal.

PUPA Milano - MADE IN ITALY. PUPA Milano is all about creativity, design, trends and "Made in Italy" beauty. Discover our complete range of luxury makeup, skin care, beauty kits, and sun care products. Perfect for any occasion, big or small.

Pupa Milano Zero Calorie Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette 001 Spicy Chocolate - 7-Shade Shadow Collection With Matte, Satin, And Metallic Colors - High Pigment Formula - Soft, Blendable Texture - 0.329 Oz

PUPA
8011607342365
3.00 X 3.00 X 5.00 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
StyleRule 9.40

Features

SEVEN SENSATIONAL SHADOWS. Create countless looks with this ultra-pigmented, 7-pan eyeshadow palette, filled with mattes, satins, and metallics. Each palette tells a different story, for designing neutral, smoky, or bright and bold eye designs.

INNOVATIVE, VELVETY-MATTE SHADES. Brush on smooth, easy-packing soft powder shadow in stunning satin and metallic pigments that blend seamlessly into skin. Dust on lids as a base, inner eye corners, or under the brow bone for dimension and shimmer.

PIGMENTS THAT POP. Elevate your eye looks with colorful, high-pigment shadows in bold and natural hues. Create makeup looks that last all day and night with super-strong shadow formulas, providing maximum coverage in a soft, malleable texture.

PARABEN FREE AND MADE WITH QUALITY INGREDIENTS. Feel good about the products you're putting on your eyes. Our professional quality shadow formulas are always dermatologist tested, and Paraben free for the health and safety of your skin.

MAKEUP AND SKINCARE FROM ITALY. Pupa Milano delivers a range of top quality, Italian-made makeup and skincare products. We're constantly innovating and evolving to make sure you have each and every beauty product you need to express your best self.

Pupa Milano Make Up Stories Eyeshadow Palette - Maximum Coverage - Pigmented 10-Pan Eyeshadow Palette - Filled With Mattes, Satins And Metallics - Create Countless Looks - 004 Cosmic Queen - 0.63 Oz

PUPA
8011607302680
0.60 X 5.60 X 3.60 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

COSMETICS APPROVED BY THE EYE EXPERTS. Our eyeshadow palette is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of any parabens, so you can feel good about the product you're putting onto your skin.

SOFT LIKE SILK. The silky formula of our eyeshadow applies easily, thanks to its creamy texture that ensures the product blends seamlessly without clinging to any dry patches. The smooth, lightweight texture glides on and adheres for long wear.

HIGH PIGMENTATION PAYOFF. This highly pigmented formula provides maximum coverage and has a soft, blendable texture that lasts all day and night. Our eyeshadow palette features concentrated pigmentation that provides instant payoff and lasts all day.

CHANNELING VITALITY VIA SENSORIAL EXPERIENCES. Colors, textures and sensorial emotions are continuously evolving thanks to scientific research, state of the art technology and innovation. PUPA Milano is makeup and skin care with top quality appeal.

PUPA Milano - MADE IN ITALY. PUPA Milano is all about creativity, design, trends and "Made in Italy" beauty. Discover our complete range of luxury makeup, skin care, beauty kits, and sun care products. Perfect for any occasion, big or small.

Top 10 eye makeup Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by PM.

Brand Count
Pupa 13

Top 10 eye makeup Brands Pie Chart


We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 666 reviews on eye makeup, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the makeup. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select eye makeup priced around $15.90, with top brands including l'oreal paris, l'oréal paris, essence cosmetics, sulily, prism makeup, nyx professional makeup, revlon, maybelline new york and dasique and bestland

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 13 eye makeup for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the makeup category. These include amazon.com, essence cosmetics, sulily, prism makeup, dasique official, makeupart, metiplou, globall us and rechoo beauty and bear paw goods .

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right eyeshadow Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which eye makeup to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.