Best Crayola Modeling Clays in 2026

Daisy
Last Updated: Jul 17, 2026

At a Glance: Our Top Picks for Crayola Modeling Clays

24 Boxes Fruit Slices Charms for Resin Polymer Clay Slime Making 3D Fimo Assorted Pieces Sticker Bulk for DIY Crafts Nail Art Lip Gloss Supplies Cellphone Decoration Accessories
#TOP1
24 Boxes Fruit Slices Charms For Resin Polymer
9.6
PM SCORE
TAINSKY Polymer Clay Cutters Set, 25 Shapes Clay Earring Cutters with 145 Earrings Accessories for Polymer Clay Jewelry Making
#TOP2
Tainsky Polymer Clay Cutters Set, 25 Shapes Clay
9.5
PM SCORE
BABORUI 118Pcs Polymer Clay Cutters kit, Set of 18 Clay Cutters Tools for Polymer Clay Jewelry, Plastic Clay Earring Cutters with Earring Cards, Earring Hooks for Polymer Clay Jewelry Making
#TOP3
Baborui 118Pcs Polymer Clay Cutters Kit, Set Of
9.4
PM SCORE

* PickSmartly editors independently research, review, and endorse the top products through comprehensive data analysis. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through our product links.

Summary of the Best Crayola Modeling Clays of 2026

Market Overview
Crayola Modeling Clays Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 1227 Items
  • PM Avg. Rating: 4.8 / 10
13 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $116.20
  • Lowest Price: $6.99
  • Avg. Price: $20.36

24 Boxes Fruit Slices Charms For Resin Polymer Clay Slime Making 3D Fimo Assorted Pieces Sticker Bulk For Diy Crafts Nail Art Lip Gloss Supplies Cellphone Decoration Accessories

DIYCICO
B001
0.26 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DIYCICO 9.36

Features

🍍 BRIGHT COLOR AND VARIOUS SHAPE –This mini fruit charms for resin comes in 24 different colors and shapes fruit Fimo slices: Strawberry, banana, apple, kiwi, watermelon, grape, avocado, orange, dragon fruit, lemon, pineapple, pomelo, cantaloupe, cucumber corn and so on, Diverse colors contain yellow, green, pink, rose red, colorful, etc. great for slime DIY crafts, nail decorations, resin jewelry making and lip gloss

🍉WIDE APPLICATION - These polymer clay fruit slices can be applied for 3d nail art charms, resin jewelry charms, lip gloss decorations,and slime making,you can also use them to decorate your cell phone's case, glasses, card, body art, etc. They are equally applied to create fun makeup looks for festivals, parties, fun events rave accents, dance recitals, cheer or costumes. etc.

🍇Fruit Nail Art Slices – This set of 3D Fimo polymer clay slices is made of soft clay, non-toxic and odor-free, lightweight, bright. Length: approx. 3 mm - 5 mm, best for nail art decoration and fit all fingernails, also ideal for face decoration, makeup addition or crafts supply

🍒PERFECT ART GIFT – Great for nail or resin art fan, nice for craft making beginner, you can enjoy the DIY fun with your family and friends together

🍒EASY TO CARRY – Each pattern of Fimo slices is stored with a clear plastic container, abundant amount of fruit slice enough to meet your needs, very convenient to use, store, easy to carry and no worry about losing

Tainsky Polymer Clay Cutters Set, 25 Shapes Clay Earring Cutters With 145 Earrings Accessories For Polymer Clay Jewelry Making

TAINSKY
25-1
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
TAINSKY 6.14

Features

【Polymer Clay Cutters Set】 Includes 25 pcs polymer clay earring cutters, 40 earring hooks and 40 gold jump rings, 50 earring backs, 15 earring cards and sealed bags, 1 plastic storage box. Sufficient quantities can easily meet your handmade needs and bring you the joy of DIY.

【Clear Cutting Design】 Polymer clay molds are designed for clay earring making, with 0.4mm(±0.1mm) cutting edge, providing a smoother and more comfortable cutting experience. We added a hand-held section to the top of the clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry, and the thickened edge protects your hands better during use.

【Unique&Durable Design】 Just assemble these individual polymer clay cutters for earrings of different sizes and unique shapes and let your imagination run wild to create the most eye-catching earrings.

【Food-Safe Material】 High-quality and durable food-safe materials are used in the earring cutters for polymer clay, which can be used not only for polymer clay, but also for ceramics, biscuits, fudge cakes and fruits, etc.

【Pro Tips&Care Instructions】 To prevent the clay from sticking inside, we recommend the method of dipping the clay cutters into cornstarch or using plastic wrap before use. Please hand wash clay cutters in warm soapy water or wipe with alcohol. Dishwasher and high heat may deform the shape.

Baborui 118Pcs Polymer Clay Cutters Kit, Set Of 18 Clay Cutters Tools For Polymer Clay Jewelry, Plastic Clay Earring Cutters With Earring Cards, Earring Hooks For Polymer Clay Jewelry Making

BABORUI
BABORUI-108
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
BABORUI 9.86

Features

【INFINITE ORIGINALITY】: Just assembling these separate different sizes and irregular shapes clay cutters, use imagination to make most eye-catching earrings! Such as rainbow, geometry, hollow out, flowers and other popular designs~

【POLYMER CLAY CUTTERS SET】: Including 18pcs plastic polymer clay cutters for earrings, 20pcs earring hooks and 30pcs jump rings in gold and silver colors, 30pcs earring backs, 10pcs earring cards and self-sealing bags. It's a perfect choice to wear or sell your creations!

【MATERIAL】: BABORUI clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry are made of food grade pp plastic, strong smooth widened base is more stressed and durable, thickened edge will better protect your hands during use.

【EASY TO USE】: Getting the seamless sharp cutting edges of no worries! Even if you are a beginner, also can create a perfect polymer clay earring jewelry artwork with clear cuts in a few seconds!

【WIDELY APPLICATIONS】: The plastic clay earrings cutters is not only suitable for jewelry, you can package them as gifts for your family and friends on Christmas, valentine's day, birthdays, mother's day, etc. But also for polymer clay, ceramics, metal clay, cookie , fondant, vegetables, etc.

【BRAND GUARANTEE】: BABOBUI is committed to enjoying a good handmade time with you. If you have any dissatisfaction or any questions please contact us, we will solve the problem for you, and offer 90 days money back guarantee.

Puocaon Celeste Moth Clay Cutters - 4 Shapes Polymer Clay Cutters For Earrings, Moth Moon Shape Clay Cutters For Polymer Clay Jewelry Making, Mystical Moth Clay Cutter Supplies Clay Earring Cutters

PUOCAON
TY3D0005_2
1.20 X 0.80 X 0.60 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Puocaon Direct 5.27

Features

[Moth Shape Polymer Clay Cutters]: Puocaon moth shapes polymer clay cutters set for earrings making. These clay earring cutters set include 3 hollow moth shape cutters and 1 small moon shape cutter.

[Ingenious Shapes Clay Cutters ]: Celeste moth polymer clay cutters are designed for handmade earrings making. The hollow design make you a infinite creation space, you can use this cutters making wonderful accessories.

[3D Printed Durable Clay Earring Cutters]: Our clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry are made of resin material. It's more durable than traditional metal cutters. It won't get rust, easy for storage.

[High Quality Clay tools]: Puocaon polymer clay cutters cutting out clear shape. These clay cutters shapes are perfect for polymer clay lovers. Even you are new to polymer clay, you can make gorgeous earrings with this cutter.

[Kindly Reminder]: Wash the polymer clay cutters with warm soapy water or wipe it with alcohol, which is more convenient for storage and next use. We recommend use cornstarch before use clay cutters to prevent the clay from sticking inside.

Jartian Leaf Shape Cutters Set, 10 Pcs Clay Earring Cutters For Jewelry Making Supplies, Polymer Clay Tools With Earring Clip And Earring Hook

JARTIAN
MTMJ-02
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
JARTIAN 4.81

Features

【Polymer Clay Cutter Set】Our DIY polymer clay earring maker kit can easily meet your handmade needs, including 10 leaf shape polymer clay earring cutters, 40 earring hooks and 40 gold jump rings, 50 earring backs,1 plastic storage box.

【Easy to Use】 The earring cutters for polymer clay will be a marvelous helper for DIY making polymer clay earrings.Even if you are a beginner, also can create a perfect polymer clay earring jewelry artwork with clear cuts in a few seconds.

【Unique Design】Our cutting edge is 0.4mm wide, thin and durable, with sharp edges, our clay earring cutters are 3D printed from food-grade eco-friendly material PLA.

【Wide Applications】Our polymer clay molds for is not only suitable for clay earrings but also suitable for sculpture, making paper flowers, cake, sugar, craft polymer decorating, candles. Besides, you could create unique art as an amazing gift for your family and friends on Christmas, valentine's day, birthdays, mother's day.

【Instructions For Use】Apply flour to polymer clay or polymer clay kit first to avoid sticking to the clay shape cutters, then shake the clay earring molds back and forth after pressing to perfectly cut polymer clay earring jewelry artwork.

#TOP6

Fimo Effect 57G (2Oz) Polymer Modelling Moulding Oven Bake Clay - Full Range Of All 36 Colours In Clear Storage Tub

FIMO
8020P
8.82 X 6.61 X 5.98 inches
5.73 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Monster-Stationery 9.81

Features

Complete set of all 36 FIMO Effect 57g Colours in Handy Clear Plastic Tub

The 2 oz Blocks are segmented into 8 easy to use portions

Oven Hardened Modelling Clay for both amateurs and professionals

Made in Germany

All 36 Colours, including; Pearl Rose, Pearl Lilac, Pearl Light Silver, Pearl Black, Nightglow, Glitter White, Glitter Gold, Glitter Red, Glitter Blue, Glitter Purple, Glitter Silver, Translucent, Transparent Yellow, Transparent Red, Transparent Purple, Transparent Blue, Transparent Green, Granite, Mother of pearl, Metallic Gold, Metallic Copper, Metallic Ruby Red, Metallic Silver, Pastel Vanilla, Pastel Peach, Pastel Rose, Pastel Lilac, Pastel Aqua, Pastel Mint, Rose Quartz & Blue Ice Quartz

Polymer Clay Molds Polymer Clay Molds For Jewelry Making Polymer Clay Molds For Polymer Clay Earrings Decoration(Flowers)

HEYTECH
CLAY MOLDS- FLOWERS
0.39 X 0.39 X 0.39 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Heytech DIRECT 9.87

Features

Unique design: These polymer clay molds feature the Flowers , allowing for personalized and unique jewelry creations.Not just jewelry, but also ornaments, chocolates, etc.

Versatility: These polymer clay molds can be used for making various types of jewelry, such as polymer clay earrings, pendants, and beads, enhancing the creative possibilities.

Easy to use: Made with high-quality materials, these polymer clay molds are easy to use and clean, while providing clear and detailed impressions.

Cost-effective: These polymer clay molds are a cost-effective solution for jewelry making, as they allow for multiple uses and the creation of unique and customized designs without the need for expensive equipment or tools.

After-sales service, if you have any questions after receiving the goods, you can contact us and we will solve them for you within 24 hours.

U.s. Art Supply Professional High Gloss Pouring Paint Art Topcoat & Clay Varnish, 8 Ounce Bottle - Clear Permanent Protective Finish For Pouring Masters Paint Artwork, Polymer & Air Dry Clay Sculpture

U.S. ART SUPPLY
USA UHG08-8Z
2.00 X 2.00 X 6.50 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
TCP Global Corp 9.96

Features

8 Ounce Bottle of U.S. Art Supply Professional High Gloss Pouring Paint Art Topcoat & Clay Varnish. Acrylic paint medium.

A glossy clear permanent protective finish for use on finished pouring paint artwork, paintings, dry acrylic paint, and on polymer and air-dry clay pieces and sculptures.

It dries clear and is non-yellowing and water-resistant when dry. Add an ultra-glossy finish to your artwork while protecting it from UV damage.

Apply the glossy varnish as a finish directly on completely dry water-based acrylic paint, pouring paint, clay, and artwork. At least two coats of varnish are recommended.

Non-toxic and conforms to ASTM D4236.

Puocaon Cow Spot Clay Cutters - 7 Pcs Cow Shapes Clay Earring Cutters, Farm Shape Clay Cutters For Jewelry Making, Animal Clay Cutters For Polymer Clay Jewelry Earrings Making Basic Clay Cutters Set

PUOCAON
TY3D009_4
1.00 X 1.00 X 1.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Puocaon Direct 5.96

Features

Cow Spot Clay Cutters for Earrings: Farm shapes clay earring cutters, you will get cow shape and cow spot clay cutters for polymer clay earrings making. 7 pcs clay cutters packed in a small plastic box, convenient for storage.

Easy to Use: Classic farm clay cutters set, with a cow spot clay cutter, makes the earring making process more convenient. Change the color of the spot and body shape, you will get cute cow shape earrings.

3D Print Clay Cutters: Our clay cutters are 3D printed and made of premium resin material, tough and durable, 0.4mm cutting edge help cutting clear and sharp cow shapes clay pieces.

Gifts for Polymer Clay Artists: It's a cute design clay cutters set. Wish you have a good time with these farm clay cutters. You can also wrapped this clay cutters set as a gift for your friends and family.

Kindly Reminder: We recommend use cornstarch before use clay cutters to prevent the clay from sticking inside. Wash the polymer clay cutters with warm soapy water or wipe it with alcohol, which is more convenient for storage and next use.

Keoker Clay Cutters For Polymer Clay Jewelry, Cactus Polymer Clay Cutters For Earrings Jewelry Making, 10 Shapes Potted Plant Clay Earrings Cutters, Clay Cutters (Potted Plant Clay Cutters)

KEOKER
1
4.92 X 0.67 X 6.77 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Keoker_Store 9.88

Features

【Keoker Potted Plant Clay Cutters 】5 shapes cactus polymer clay earring cutters, 5 shapes plant pots clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry.

【 Clear Cutting Design 】Keoker polymer clay cutters for earrings are made by 3D printer, with 0.4mm(±0.1mm) cutting edge, providing a smoother and more comfortable cutting experience.

【 Clay earrings supplies 】 Just assemble these individual earring cutters for polymer clay of different sizes and unique shapes and create the most eye-catching earrings.

【 Correct Size 】Keoker polymer clay cutters are around 0.75 inch to 1.2 inches length. The size of the most popular small clay earrings and studs for American women. Note that the product color is pink or white and the packaging is randomly shipped.

【 Care Instructions 】 To prevent the clay from sticking inside, we recommend use cornstarch before use. Please hand wash polymer clay cutter in warm soapy water or wipe with alcohol. Dishwasher and high heat may deform the shape. Note that the product color is pink or white and the packaging is randomly shipped.

100G Polymer Clay Slices Fake Sprinkles Resin Sprinkles Fake Candy Sprinkles Clay Sprinkles Nail Art Slices Polymer Sprinkles For Nail Art Diy Crafts Cake Dessert Phone Case

VANJETO
CLAY SLICES-0422
0.28 X 0.28 X 0.04 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Weibety 4.77

Features

MATERIAL: Made of polymer clay, these polymer clay slices are lightweight and reliable, not easy to fade, wear or tear, smooth and comfortable to touch.

WIDELY USED: DIY craft projects decoration, ornaments, phone case, nail, camera, scrap booking, mirrors, jewelry, bracelets, hair accessories, necklaces, hairpins, clothing, shoes, hats, handbags, belts, wallets, home decor miniatures fairy garden accessories.

PARTY DECOR: Suit to scrapbook, cake dessert simulation food, picture frame, stationery boxes, fit for party and home decorations well etc.

EASY TO CARRY – Each pattern of clay slices is stored with clear plastic container, very convenient to use, store, easy to carry and no worry about losing.

PERFECT ART GIFT: Good for nail or resin art fan, nice for craft making beginner, you can enjoy the DIY fun with your family and friends together.

116Pcs Polymer Clay Cutters, 25 Shapes Clay Earring Cutters With Earring Hooks, Polymer Clay Jewelry Earring Cutters For Clay Jewelry Making Blue

GENERIC
1
7.87 X 4.33 X 1.57 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Symophathy 0.00

Features

116PCS POLYMER CLAY MOLDS KIT: Clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry come with 25 shapes, plastic clay cutters with 8 circle shape cutters and 91 earrings accessories.

INFINITE ORIGINALITY: Just assembling these separate different sizes and irregular shapes clay cutters, use imagination to make most eye-catching earrings! Such as rainbow, geometry, hollow out, flowers and other popular designs

MATERIAL: Our clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry are made of food grade pp plastic, strong smooth widened base is more stressed and durable, thickened edge will better protect your hands during use.

EASY TO USE: Getting the seamless sharp cutting edges of no worries! Even if you are a beginner, also can create a perfect polymer clay earring jewelry artwork with clear cuts in a few seconds!

EASY TO USE: Getting the seamless sharp cutting edges of no worries! Even if you are a beginner, also can create a perfect polymer clay earring jewelry artwork with clear cuts in a few seconds!

Keoker Polymer Clay Cutters, Summer Clay Cutters, Polymer Clay Cutters For Earrings Jewelry Making, 12 Shapes Flower Clay Earrings Cutters

KEOKER
001
5.91 X 0.39 X 5.91 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Keoker_Store 9.88

Features

【 Keoker Beach Clay Cutters 】12 shapes polymer clay earring cutters, make your summer clay cutters for polymer clay jewelry. Include:Ocean clay cutters, beach Clay Cutters, Dragonfly Clay Cutters, Summer Clay Earrings Cutters, Survito Clay Cutters.

【 Clear Cutting Design 】Ocean polymer clay cutters for earrings are made by 3D printer, with 0.4mm(±0.1mm) cutting edge, providing a smoother and more comfortable cutting experience.

【 Clay earrings supplies 】 Just assemble these individual earring cutters for polymer clay of different sizes and unique shapes and create the most eye-catching earrings.

【 Correct Size 】Keoker polymer clay cutters are around 0.75 inch to 1.2 inches length. The size of the most popular small clay earrings and studs for American women. Note that the product color is pink or white and the packaging is randomly shipped.

【 Care Instructions 】 To prevent the clay from sticking inside, we recommend use cornstarch before use. Please hand wash polymer clay cutter in warm soapy water or wipe with alcohol. Dishwasher and high heat may deform the shape. Note that the product color is pink or white and the packaging is randomly shipped.

Top 10 modeling clays Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by PM.

Brand Count
Keoker 2
Puocaon 2
Baborui 1
Diycico 1
Fimo 1
Generic 1
Heytech 1
Jartian 1
Tainsky 1
U.s. Art Supply 1

Top 10 modeling clays Brands Pie Chart


We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 1,227 reviews on modeling clays, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the arts & crafts. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select modeling clays priced around $20.36, with top brands including essenson, artsity, aestd-st, cra-z-art, ciaraq, das, pepy, ifergoo and crayola and sargent art

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 13 modeling clays for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the arts & crafts category. These include essenson direct, addyfs, aestd-st, amazon.com, ciara2016u, the pencil barn, ifergoo, cyajm and seronline and leichten .

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right clays Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which modeling clays to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.