Best Spicer Seals in 2026

Daisy
Last Updated: Feb 13, 2026

At a Glance: Our Top Picks for Spicer Seals

LifeGuard Pond Liner 20 ft. x 25 ft. 45 Mil EPDM Rubber and Underlayment Combo - CLGUG20X25
#TOP1
Lifeguard Pond Liner 20 Ft. X 25 Ft.
9.7
PM SCORE
LifeGuard Pond Liner 5 ft. x 10 ft. 45 Mil EPDM Rubber and Underlayment Combo - CLGUG05X10
#TOP2
Lifeguard Pond Liner 5 Ft. X 10 Ft.
9.7
PM SCORE
LifeGuard Pond Liner 8 ft. x 10 ft. 45 Mil EPDM Rubber - LG8X10-45
#TOP3
Lifeguard Pond Liner 8 Ft. X 10 Ft.
9.7
PM SCORE

* PickSmartly editors independently research, review, and endorse the top products through comprehensive data analysis. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through our product links.

Summary of the Best Spicer Seals of 2026

Market Overview
Spicer Seals Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 2185 Items
  • PM Avg. Rating: 8.9 / 10
17 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $1,708.00
  • Lowest Price: $42.00
  • Avg. Price: $644.39
#TOP1

Lifeguard Pond Liner 20 Ft. X 25 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber And Underlayment Combo - Clgug20X25

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
CLGUG20X25
300.00 X 240.00 X 45.00 Inches
164.00 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with UnderGuard Underlayment has a Limited Lifetime Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc. THIS ITEM SHIPS VIA FREIGHT TRUCK: Lift-gate service is NOT included. Carriers require accurate contact information, (including a working phone number), to schedule a delivery appointments.

#TOP2

Lifeguard Pond Liner 5 Ft. X 10 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber And Underlayment Combo - Clgug05X10

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
CLGUG05X10
120.00 X 60.00 X 45.00 Inches
16.40 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with UnderGuard Underlayment has a Limited Lifetime Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

Lifeguard Pond Liner 8 Ft. X 10 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg8X10-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG08X10-45
120.00 X 96.00 X 0.04 inches
10.88 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP4

Lifeguard Pond Liner 5 Ft. X 40 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg05X40-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG05X40-45
480.00 X 60.00 X 45.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP5

Lifeguard Pond Liner 8 Ft. X 10 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber And Underlayment Combo - Clgug08X10

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
CLGUG08X10
120.00 X 96.00 X 45.00 Inches
26.20 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with UnderGuard Underlayment has a Limited Lifetime Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP6

Lifeguard Pond Liner 15 Ft. X 20 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber And Underlayment Combo - Clgug15X20

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
CLGUG15X20
240.00 X 180.00 X 45.00 Inches
97.00 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with UnderGuard Underlayment has a Limited Lifetime Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP7

Lifeguard Pond Liner 10 Ft. X 35 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber And Underlayment Combo - Clgug10X35

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
CLGUG10X35
420.00 X 120.00 X 45.00 Inches
114.80 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with UnderGuard Underlayment has a Limited Lifetime Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP8

Lifeguard Pond Liner 20 Ft. X 20 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg20X20-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG20X20-45
240.00 X 240.00 X 0.04 Inches
54.40 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Spreetail 9.94

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP9

Lifeguard Pond Liner Anjon Lifeguard 20 Ft. X 25 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Pond Liner

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG20X25-45
300.00 X 240.00 X 45.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

Lifeguard Pond Liner 5 Ft. X 5 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg05X05-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG05X05-45
60.00 X 60.00 X 45.00 Inches
7.50 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Graystone Creations 7.00

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

Lifeguard Pond Liner 15 Ft. X 15 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg15X15-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG15X15-45
180.00 X 180.00 X 45.00 Inches
30.84 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

Lifeguard Pond Liner 15 Ft. X 20 Ft. 60 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg15X20-60

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG15X20-60
240.00 X 180.00 X 60.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

60-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Professional grade strength and durability for heavy duty applications when placing heavy boulders, expected wildlife use, and high-profile builds. For use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc

#TOP13

Lifeguard Pond Liner 25 Ft. X 35 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg25X35-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG25X35-45
420.00 X 300.00 X 45.00 Inches
262.50 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc. THIS ITEM SHIPS VIA FREIGHT TRUCK: Lift-gate service is NOT included. Carriers require accurate contact information, (including a working phone number), to schedule a delivery appointments.

Lifeguard Pond Liner 25 Ft. X 40 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg25X40-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG25X40-45
480.00 X 300.00 X 45.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc. THIS ITEM SHIPS VIA FREIGHT TRUCK: Lift-gate service is NOT included. Carriers require accurate contact information, (including a working phone number), to schedule a delivery appointments.

#TOP15
Best For Koi

Lifeguard Pond Liner 30 Ft. X 35 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg30X35-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG30X35-45
420.00 X 360.00 X 45.00 Inches
315.00 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc. THIS ITEM SHIPS VIA FREIGHT TRUCK: Lift-gate service is NOT included. Carriers require accurate contact information, (including a working phone number), to schedule a delivery appointments.

#TOP16

Lifeguard Pond Liner Anjon 30 Ft. X 30 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Pond Liner

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG30X30-45
360.00 X 360.00 X 45.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc. THIS ITEM SHIPS VIA FREIGHT TRUCK: Lift-gate service is NOT included. Carriers require accurate contact information, (including a working phone number), to schedule a delivery appointments.

#TOP17

Lifeguard Pond Liner 40 Ft. X 35 Ft. 45 Mil Epdm Rubber - Lg40X35-45

LIFEGUARD POND LINER
LG40X35-45
420.00 X 480.00 X 45.00 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazing Pond Supplies 9.71

Features

45-Mil EPDM Rubber Pond liner with 25-Year Warranty

Durable, puncture resistant, extremely versatile for use in waterfall features, pond kits, water gardens, retention basins, koi ponds, aquaponics, lakes, stream liners, and fish hatcheries.

Does not contain plasticizers, which become brittle and cause cracks or splits.

Easy to install, lays flat, very pliable for easy shaping and feature fitments

Certified Fish & Wildlife Safe by Guardian Systems Inc. THIS ITEM SHIPS VIA FREIGHT TRUCK: Lift-gate service is NOT included. Carriers require accurate contact information, (including a working phone number), to schedule a delivery appointments.

Top 10 seals Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by PM.

Brand Count
Lifeguard Pond Liner 17

Top 10 seals Brands Pie Chart


We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 2,185 reviews on seals, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the categories. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select seals priced around $644.39, with top brands including and

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 17 seals for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the categories category. These include and .

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right seals Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which seals to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.