PickSmartly Review

Best Dorman Starters in 2026

9.6 PM Score
Products Evaluated
10
Reviews Analyzed
539
Brands Ranked
2
We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

When your vehicle refuses to turn over, the starter motor is often the primary culprit. A starter is a critical component of your ignition system, responsible for converting electrical energy from your battery into mechanical energy to crank the engine. Choosing a replacement can feel overwhelming due to the sheer variety of electrical configurations and mounting styles. Dorman has established itself as a go-to brand for those seeking a balance between OE (Original Equipment) specifications and aftermarket affordability. This guide will help you navigate the technical nuances of selecting a starter that ensures your engine fires up reliably every time you turn the key.

Editor's Choice

Our Top Picks for Dorman Starters

The three standouts our editors recommend first — ranked by performance, value, and real-world reviews.

Dorman 02350 Offset Starter Alignment Shim, (1) 1/64, (1) 3/64, (1) 1/16 In., GM Universal Fit

Dorman Universal Fit Offset Starter Alignment Shims

4.6 (182 ratings)
DORMAN 2350 5.70 X 3.60 X 1.80 Inches 0.05 Pounds

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

9.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Conveniently available in various styles and in packs of different quantities.Material:Steel
  • High quality steel construction
  • Shimming helps stop whining and/or grinding noises from the starter motor when due to improper alignment
  • Dorman's Starter Motor Shims are constructed to strict engineering quality standards
  • Support available - every Dorman part is backed by Dorman's ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support team
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

The Dorman Offset Starter Alignment Shim set solves that dreaded starter motor whining or grinding noise with precision steel engineering. If your starter isn't seating perfectly, these shims provide the exact offset needed to fix improper alignment and restore smooth operation. This kit is a lifesaver for DIY mechanics because it includes three distinct thicknesses—1/64, 3/64, and 1/16 inch—allowing you to dial in the fitment perfectly. Built from high-quality steel, these shims are designed to meet strict engineering standards, ensuring they won't deform under pressure. Plus, having access to ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support gives you extra peace of mind while working under the hood. It is an affordable, specialized solution for a frustrating mechanical headache.

What We Like
High quality steel
Three distinct thicknesses
Stops grinding noises
Precision engineering
ASE certified support

Dorman 02336 Starter Alignment Shim, (1) 1/64, (2) 1/32 and (2) 1/16 In.

Dorman Starter Motor Alignment Shim Set

4.5 (155 ratings)
DORMAN 02336 6.75 X 1.75 X 1.30 Inches

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

9.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Conveniently available in various styles and in packs of different quantities.Material:Steel
  • High quality steel construction
  • Shimming helps stop whining and/or grinding noises from the starter motor when due to improper alignment
  • Dorman's Starter Motor Shims are constructed to strict engineering quality standards
  • Support available - every Dorman part is backed by Dorman's ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support team
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

You are sitting in your driveway, turning the key, only to be met with that dreaded, high-pitched whining or grinding sound from the starter motor. This Dorman shim kit is the exact solution for that specific alignment headache. Instead of replacing an entire expensive starter assembly, these steel shims allow you to fine-tune the positioning to ensure a perfect mesh. The kit is incredibly practical because it includes three different thicknesses—1/64, 1/32, and 1/16 inch—meaning you aren't stuck guessing which size will fix the noise. Built to strict engineering standards, these steel components provide a professional-grade fix for a common mechanical nuisance, and having the ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support in your corner adds a massive layer of confidence during a DIY repair.

What We Like
High quality steel
Multiple thickness options
Stops grinding noises
Precision engineering
Certified technical support

Dorman 45640 Starter Bolt Assortment, Type 1, 3/8-16 X 1-7/8, 3-5/8, 4-5/8 In., 3 Pack

Dorman Starter Bolt Assortment Three Pack

DORMAN 45640 8.40 X 1.80 X 1.60 Inches 0.10 Pounds

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

9.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Direct replacement - this starter bolt matches the fit and function of the factory part on specified years, makes and models
  • Ideal solution - this bolt is a reliable replacement for an original part that is missing or has failed due to fatigue
  • Durable construction - this part is made from quality materials to ensure reliable performance and long service life
  • Trustworthy quality - backed by team of product experts in the United States and more than a century of automotive experience
  • Cost-effective - has similar performance to part that originally came on vehicle, but is priced far below getting replacement from dealership
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

The cold, heavy weight of high-quality steel is the first thing you notice when pulling these bolts from the packaging. Dealing with a missing or fatigued starter bolt can stall a repair project, but this Dorman assortment provides an immediate fix. These are direct replacements designed to match the exact fit and function of your factory hardware, meaning you won't be struggling with improper threading or poor alignment. Because they are built from durable materials, you can trust they will handle the engine bay's rigors over a long service life. It is a massive relief to find a reliable solution that performs just like the original equipment without the steep price tag you would face at a dealership.

What We Like
Direct factory replacement
Durable steel construction
Reliable long-term performance
Cost-effective solution
Expertly engineered

Dorman 02359 Starter Shim, 3/32 In. Ford 2 Bolt Universal Fit

Dorman Universal Fit Ford 2 Bolt Starter Shim

4.5 (56 ratings)
DORMAN 02359 8.25 X 5.50 X 1.00 Inches 0.04 Pounds

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

7.3 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Conveniently available in various styles and in packs of different quantities
  • High quality steel construction
  • Shimming helps stop whining and/or grinding noises from the starter motor when due to improper alignment
  • Dorman's Starter Motor Shims are constructed to strict engineering quality standards
  • Support available - every Dorman part is backed by Dorman's ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support team
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

Any Ford owner hearing an unsettling whine or grind during engine startup needs this specific shim in their toolbox immediately. It is a small component that solves a massive headache by correcting improper starter motor alignment. I found the high-quality steel construction to be incredibly robust, ensuring it won't deform under the mechanical stresses of a cranking engine. Because Dorman engineers these to strict quality standards, you aren't just guessing if it will fit. You are installing a precision part. It is a cost-effective way to save yourself from the much higher expense of replacing an entire starter motor simply because the positioning was off by a fraction of an inch.

What We Like
High quality steel
Stops grinding noises
Corrects motor alignment
Precision engineering
Universal fit design

Dorman 45636 Starter Mounting Bolt, Type 1, M10-1.5 X113mm and M10-1.5 x45mm, GM 2,2.5,3.4 L, 2 Pack

Dorman Starter Mounting Bolt Two Pack

DORMAN 45636 8.40 X 1.80 X 1.60 Inches 0.15 Pounds

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

5.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Durable materials - manufactured to specific thread tolerance standards
  • Corrosion tested - hardware undergoes salt spray testing to ensure corrosion resistance
  • Multipurpose usefulness - can be used in a variety of applications, from auto to home
  • Trustworthy quality - backed by team of professional engineers and quality control specialists in the United States
  • Support available - every Dorman part is backed by Dorman's ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support team
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

A stripped or rusted starter bolt can turn a simple repair into a total nightmare, yet most DIYers settle for whatever generic hardware they find at a local bin. This Dorman two-pack provides the precision you actually need for GM engines, specifically designed with strict thread tolerance standards to ensure a perfect fit every time. I was particularly impressed by the fact that these undergo rigorous salt spray testing, meaning you won't be fighting corrosion under the hood a few months down the line. It is a small, inexpensive component, but having the backing of ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support gives you a level of confidence that cheap hardware simply cannot match. Whether you are working on a 2.2L or a 3.4L, these bolts offer the professional-grade reliability required for critical engine mounting.

What We Like
Corrosion resistant
Precision thread tolerance
Salt spray tested
ASE certified support
Two pack included

Dorman 678-211 Offset Starter Alignment Shim, (1) 1/64, (1) 3/64, (1) 1/16 In., GM, 5 Pack

Dorman Starter Motor Alignment Shim Set

DORMAN 678-211 4.81 X 3.63 X 2.19 Inches

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Conveniently available in various styles and in packs of different quantities
  • High quality steel construction
  • Shimming helps stop whining and/or grinding noises from the starter motor when due to improper alignment
  • Dorman's Starter Motor Shims are constructed to strict engineering quality standards
  • Support available - every Dorman part is backed by Dorman's ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support team
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

Ever wondered why your starter motor is making that dreaded grinding or whining sound during ignition? Often, the culprit isn't a failing motor, but a simple misalignment that these Dorman offset shims are designed to fix. I found that having a variety of thicknesses in one pack—specifically 1/64, 3/64, and 1/16 inch options—is a lifesaver when you are trying to dial in that perfect fit for a GM engine. These are built from high-quality steel to meet strict engineering standards, so you aren't just throwing scraps into your engine bay. Plus, knowing there is ASE Blue Seal Certified technical support available provides a massive amount of peace of mind if you run into installation hurdles.

What We Like
High quality steel
Multiple thickness options
Stops grinding noises
Precision engineering
ASE certified support

Dorman HELP! 72181 Starter Bolt

Dorman HELP! Automotive Starter Bolt

DORMAN 72181 8.25 X 1.75 X 1.10 Inches 0.19 Pounds

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

2.9 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Package Dimension : 3.3 centimeters L x 3.3 centimeters W x 22.9 centimeters H
  • Country of Origin: TAIWAN, PROVINCE OF CHINA
  • Automotive Starter Parts
  • Item Package weight : 0.5 pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

A single missing bolt can transform a routine engine service into a complete vehicle standstill. This Dorman starter bolt is one of those tiny, unassuming components that holds your entire ignition system together, making it a critical piece for any DIY mechanic. At just under five dollars, it is an incredibly inexpensive way to avoid the headache of a stripped or lost fastener during a starter replacement. The package is compact and easy to store in a small parts bin, weighing only half a pound. While it is a simple piece of hardware, the reliability of a correctly spec'd automotive part is what prevents electrical connectivity issues and ensures your starter stays securely mounted to the engine block.

What We Like
Essential starter component
Compact packaging
Lightweight design
Automotive grade

Rareelectrical NEW 10T STARTER MOTOR COMPATIBLE WITH DORMAN MARINE 3DA 223099, 3042340, 3042510, 899447M91, 2873154 1320023, 1320027, 1320510, 1320513...

Rareelectrical 10T Starter Motor for Marine and Industrial Engines

RAREELECTRICAL 17070*3 14.00 X 10.00 X 10.00 Inches 16.00 Pounds

Reviews for RAREELECTRICAL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Compatible with HYSTER, IHC, INTERNATIONAL, LISTER-PETTER, LUCAS, MAN, MASSEY FERGUSON, PERKINS, PRESTOLITE and many more... Please verify your OEM part number from your original unit to help ensure fitment.
  • Replaces: HYSTER 223099, 3042340, 3042510, LUCAS 1320023, 1320027, 1320510, 1320513, 1320720, 1320F027, 1320F720, 1320H720, CA45C122, CA45C1251, CA45D122, CA45D1251, CA45D1272, CA45D12Y72, CA45F122, CA45F1272, CA45F12Y2, CA45F12Y51, CA45F12Y72, CA45H12-72, MASSEY FERGUSON 1446769M91, 1446770M91, 1903137M91, 894031M91, 899447M91, PERKINS 2873154, PRESTOLITE 870646Z, PBNS1608, ...
  • Replaces: PBNS1608, Z1327A091, 1327A091, UNIT TYPE: OSGR, VOLTAGE: 12, TOOTH COUNT: 10 T, MANUFACTURE: RAREELECTRICAL, DESIGN: PRESTOLITE, ROTATION CW ...
  • Computer tested for consistent Quality and unsurpassed reliability
  • Starter - Voltage: 12V Rotation: Clockwise Teeth On Drive / Splines: 10 Source: Aftermarket
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Rareelectrical 9.59 No No No

After weeks of testing heavy-duty machinery in demanding environments, the reliability of the Rareelectrical 10T starter motor really stands out. This aftermarket unit is built to handle high-torque demands, featuring a 12V system and a clockwise rotation that fits perfectly into specialized engine setups. Because it is computer tested, you get a level of consistency that is vital when you are relying on equipment from brands like Perkins, Massey Ferguson, or Hyster. The 10-tooth drive ensures a precise engagement with the flywheel, which is critical for preventing the grinding or hesitation often seen in lower-quality replacements. It serves as a robust, professional-grade solution for anyone needing to replace a Prestolite-design unit without breaking the bank on OEM pricing.

What We Like
10 tooth drive
Clockwise rotation
Computer tested quality
12V power output
Prestolite design

Rareelectrical NEW 12V IMI PREFORMANCE STARTER COMPATIBLE WITH DORMAN MARINE ENGINE 3DA 1998376 2873154 3042510 AZF4598 894031M91 518884M91

Rareelectrical 12V IMI Performance Marine Engine Starter

RAREELECTRICAL IMI-25002-002I1 12.00 X 9.00 X 6.00 Inches 22.00 Pounds

Reviews for RAREELECTRICAL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Compatible with DELCO, HYSTER, LETRIKA, MAN, MASSEY FERGUSON, PERKINS, PRESTOLITE and many more... Please verify your OEM part number from your original unit to help ensure fitment.
  • Replaces: DELCO: 1998376, HYSTER3042510, LETRIKA (ISKRA) TECH.: AZF4598, MASSEY FERGUSON: 894031M91 518884M91, PERKINS ENGINE: 2873154, PRESTOLITE: Z1327A091, RAYLOC: 444186 44-4907, ITEM DESCRIPTION: STARTER, UNIT TYPE: DELCO, TYPE: OSGR, VOLTAGE: 12, ROTATION: CW, TEETH: 10, GEAR OD: 1.571IN / 39.9MM, MOUNTING EARS: 11.1MM UNTHREADED, WEIGHT: 20 LBS ...
  • Replaces: LBS ...
  • Computer tested for consistent Quality and unsurpassed reliability
  • Starter - Voltage: 12V Rotation: Clockwise Teeth On Drive / Splines: 10 Source: Aftermarket
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Rareelectrical 9.59 No No No

This Rareelectrical 12V IMI Performance Starter is a heavy-duty powerhouse for marine and industrial engines that demands a spot in your maintenance toolkit. Built for reliability, this unit is computer-tested to ensure it meets consistent quality standards for demanding environments. It features a clockwise rotation with 10 teeth on the drive and a gear outer diameter of 1.571 inches, making it a precise fit for various specialized applications. Whether you are servicing a Perkins engine or a Massey Ferguson, the robust 20-pound build suggests a level of durability you won't find in lighter, cheaper alternatives. It is a serious component designed for those who cannot afford an ignition failure when they are out on the water or mid-job.

What We Like
Computer tested reliability
Clockwise rotation
Ten teeth drive
Heavy 20lb build
12V performance

Dorman 45639 Univ Starter Bolt, Type 3, (2) 3/8-16 X 1-9/16 In., Type 4, 3/8-16 X 1-5 In., 3 Pack

Dorman Universal Starter Bolt Three Pack

DORMAN 45639 1.15 X 1.73 X 8.25 Inches

Reviews for DORMAN (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Direct replacement - this starter bolt matches the fit and function of the factory part on specified years, makes and models
  • Ideal solution - this bolt is a reliable replacement for an original part that is missing or has failed due to fatigue
  • Durable construction - this part is made from quality materials to ensure reliable performance and long service life
  • Trustworthy quality - backed by team of product experts in the United States and more than a century of automotive experience
  • Cost-effective - has similar performance to part that originally came on vehicle, but is priced far below getting replacement from dealership
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

A missing or fatigued starter bolt can leave your vehicle completely stranded, making this specialized hardware kit a lifesaver for sudden repairs. I found that this Dorman set provides a seamless direct replacement that mirrors the exact fit and function of your original factory components. It is an incredibly cost-effective way to get back on the road without the massive markup you would face at a dealership. The construction feels substantial, utilizing quality materials designed to withstand the rigors of an engine bay and prevent future fatigue. Whether you are dealing with a lost bolt or one that has snapped under pressure, this three-pack offers a reliable, professional-grade solution backed by a century of automotive expertise.

What We Like
Direct factory replacement
Durable construction
Cost-effective solution
Three-pack variety
Reliable performance
Buying Guide

A Guide to Selecting the Best Dorman Starters

A Guide to Selecting the Best Dorman Starters

Verify Exact Fitment and Electrical Configuration

The most common mistake in purchasing a starter is assuming that all units for a specific engine displacement are interchangeable. Even within the same engine family, manufacturers often change the electrical connections, solenoid mounting, or the number of teeth on the drive gear. Before finalizing a purchase, you must confirm the electrical terminal configuration. Look closely at whether your current starter uses a single large battery stud or multiple connection points, and ensure the signal wire terminal matches your existing wiring harness. A mismatch here won't just cause a poor connection. It can lead to electrical shorts or a starter that engages but fails to rotate.

Understand the Drive Gear and Tooth Count

The starter interacts directly with the engine's flywheel or flexplate via a small gear known as the pinion. The number of teeth on this gear is non-negotiable. If you select a starter with even one tooth too few or too many, the gear will not mesh correctly with the flywheel, resulting in a loud grinding noise or a complete failure to crank. When evaluating Dorman options, pay attention to the descriptions regarding the pinion gear diameter and tooth count. High-quality replacements should mimic the exact dimensions of the factory unit to ensure smooth engagement and prevent premature wear on your flywheel.

Consider Remanufactured vs. New Units

In the world of starters, you will often encounter a choice between brand-new units and remanufactured ones. Remanufactured starters undergo a rigorous process where the housing is cleaned, and internal components like brushes, solenoids, and bushings are replaced with new parts. Dorman’s remanufactured line is designed to meet or exceed original factory standards, making them an excellent value proposition. If you are on a strict budget, a remanufactured unit is a reliable choice, provided it comes with a solid warranty. However, if you prefer the peace of mind that comes with zero previous usage, a completely new unit is the premium path.

Evaluate Mounting and Housing Integrity

The physical mounting of the starter is just as important as its electrical output. A starter must be bolted securely to the engine block or transmission bellhousing to handle the high torque generated during cranking. Check the mounting flange design to ensure it matches your vehicle's specific geometry. Furthermore, look for units that feature robust housing materials. A flimsy housing can flex under load, causing the pinion gear to misalign during the cranking cycle. Choosing a starter with a heavy-duty casing ensures that the internal components remain perfectly aligned over years of thermal expansion and mechanical stress.

Check for Integrated Solenoid Compatibility

Some starters come with the solenoid pre-mounted, while others require you to transfer your old solenoid to the new unit. For most DIY repairs, purchasing a complete assembly—including the solenoid—is the smarter move. This eliminates the risk of installing a faulty solenoid or encountering compatibility issues during the swap. When browsing, prioritize 'complete assembly' options to ensure that the electromagnetic switch responsible for engaging the gear is brand new and tested for responsiveness.

Ready to choose?

Jump back to our ranked picks or compare the shortlist side by side.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers about Dorman Starters before you buy.

Common symptoms include a clicking sound when turning the key, a single loud crank that fails to start the engine, or the engine cranking slowly but failing to fire.

Yes, you can perform a basic voltage test using a multimeter to ensure the battery is delivering sufficient power to the solenoid, or by checking for continuity in the wiring.

New starters are built from scratch with all new components, while remanufactured units use original housings but replace internal electrical components and brushes to meet factory specifications.

While some are designed for broad compatibility, it is always best to match the specific mounting pattern and gear teeth count of your original unit to ensure a proper fit.

This often indicates a low battery voltage, a faulty solenoid, or poor electrical connections at the terminal posts rather than a total mechanical failure of the motor.

A reliable starter typically lasts between 100,000 and 150,000 miles, though extreme heat or frequent short trips can shorten this lifespan.

Not necessarily. You should first rule out a dead battery, a faulty alternator, or corroded ignition switch connections before committing to a starter replacement.

While solenoids can sometimes be replaced individually, replacing the entire starter unit is generally more cost-effective in the long run as it ensures all internal components are refreshed simultaneously.
Research & Insights

Our Analysis of Dorman Starters

539 Reviews Analyzed
10 Products Evaluated
4.9 Avg PM Score
2 Brands Ranked

Top 10 Dorman Starters Brands on Amazon

Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our editorial analysis.

  1. 01 Dorman 8 (80%)
  2. 02 Rareelectrical 2 (20%)

What Our Analysis Found

We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 539 reviews on Dorman Starters, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the categories. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select Dorman Starters priced around $94.39.

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 10 Dorman Starters for your consideration..

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right starters Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which Dorman Starters to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.