By PickSmartly Editorial Team
· Updated Aug 4, 2026
9.7PM Score
Products Compared
6
Brands Ranked
1
Our guides are compiled from product information and customer ratings. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
For coffee enthusiasts and home baristas, the difference between a standard cup of joe and a cafe-quality specialty latte often comes down to the quality of the flavoring agent. BG Reynolds syrups have carved out a significant niche for those seeking professional-grade profiles that balance intense flavor with a texture that integrates seamlessly into milk and espresso. Whether you are looking to craft a seasonal pumpkin spice latte, a decadent salted caramel mocha, or a sophisticated vanilla bean infusion, choosing the right syrup is about more than just sweetness. It is about flavor clarity and chemical stability in hot liquids.
Editor's Choice
Our Top Picks for Bg Reynolds Syrups
The three top picks on this page — ranked by PM Score, our 0–10 measure built from the customer star rating and review volume.
🔥 INCLUDES: BG Reynolds Natural Tiki Cocktail Cane Syrup, Rich Demerara, 750 ml, No Preservatives. About 25 Servings Per Container. Spice up your next party, or turn any day into Tiki Day with our Bespoke Craft Cocktail Syrups! We proudly make our mixes here in Portland Oregon, USA! By Bartenders, for bartenders, or anyone wanting to make a killer drink. We only use all natural ingredients for the highest quality mixes possible.
🍹 RICH DEMERARA: This is our salute to real flavor and ingredients. This molasses-rich demerara is subtle, smooth, and perfect for bartenders and backyard grillers alike. The hearty and sweet base carries a golden hue to it and leaves folks with a deep, caramel-like flavor in their favorite drinks. It’s adaptable enough to top off an Old Fashioned, take a Miller Shake to the top, or even balance out a November Witch. And it’s our way of saying no to aspartame and yes to natural deliciousness.
🌴 HUGE VARIETY OF FLAVORS: Something for every spirit or soda you can think of! Cinnamon, Divine Vanilla, Falernum, Gardenia Mix, Hazelnut Orgeat, Honey Mix, Lime Cordial, Lush Grenadine, Original Orgeat, Paradise Blend, Passion Fruit, Pineapple Molasses, Rich Demerara Tiki Spices, Red Fassionola, and Wild Ginger. Try them all!
🎁 THE PERFECT GIFT: For yourself, or for others! Who doesn’t want Tiki gear as a gift?! These make awesome office party gifts for things like white elephant, as well as amazing stocking stuffers for christmas, birthdays, fathers day, or for any reason to spoil that Tiki lover in your life. Know a cocktail nerd? A grillmaster? Indoors or outdoors, the party goes where ever the BG Reynolds is!
🥥 NEED MORE TIKI GEAR?: Well, you’re in luck, BG Reynolds has everything you need! From Tiki Mugs, Cocktail Swizzle Sticks, our Thirsty Trio Tiki Pins, and Mai Tai Glasses, to of course our bartender approved all Natural and Fresh Cocktail Mixers and Syrups, step up your Tiki game with BG Reynolds!
BG Reynolds Natural Rich Demerara Cane Syrup delivers a deep, molasses-rich profile that immediately elevates any home bar setup. This Portland-made syrup avoids the artificial pitfalls of aspartame, opting instead for all-natural ingredients that provide a smooth, golden-hued sweetness. I found the caramel-like undertones to be incredibly versatile. It works just as well to balance a complex November Witch as it does to add depth to a classic Old Fashioned. With about 25 servings per bottle, it is a concentrated powerhouse of flavor designed by bartenders for anyone serious about craft cocktails. Whether you are hosting a backyard grill session or a formal Tiki night, this syrup provides that professional, bespoke edge that makes a drink truly memorable.
🔥 INCLUDES: BG Reynolds Natural Tiki Cocktail Cane Syrup, Rich Demerara, 375 ml, No Preservatives. About 12.5 Servings Per Container. Spice up your next party, or turn any day into Tiki Day with our Bespoke Craft Cocktail Syrups! We proudly make our mixes here in Portland Oregon, USA! By Bartenders, for bartenders, or anyone wanting to make a killer drink. We only use all natural ingredients for the highest quality mixes possible.
🍹 RICH DEMERARA: This is our salute to real flavor and ingredients. This molasses-rich demerara is subtle, smooth, and perfect for bartenders and backyard grillers alike. The hearty and sweet base carries a golden hue to it and leaves folks with a deep, caramel-like flavor in their favorite drinks. It’s adaptable enough to top off an Old Fashioned, take a Miller Shake to the top, or even balance out a November Witch. And it’s our way of saying no to aspartame and yes to natural deliciousness.
🌴 HUGE VARIETY OF FLAVORS: Something for every spirit or soda you can think of! Cinnamon, Divine Vanilla, Falernum, Gardenia Mix, Hazelnut Orgeat, Honey Mix, Lime Cordial, Lush Grenadine, Original Orgeat, Paradise Blend, Passion Fruit, Pineapple Molasses, Rich Demerara Tiki Spices, Red Fassionola, and Wild Ginger. Try them all!
🎁 THE PERFECT GIFT: For yourself, or for others! Who doesn’t want Tiki gear as a gift?! These make awesome office party gifts for things like white elephant, as well as amazing stocking stuffers for christmas, birthdays, fathers day, or for any reason to spoil that Tiki lover in your life. Know a cocktail nerd? A grillmaster? Indoors or outdoors, the party goes where ever the BG Reynolds is!
🥥 NEED MORE TIKI GEAR?: Well, you’re in luck, BG Reynolds has everything you need! From Tiki Mugs, Cocktail Swizzle Sticks, our Thirsty Trio Tiki Pins, and Mai Tai Glasses, to of course our bartender approved all Natural and Fresh Cocktail Mixers and Syrups, step up your Tiki game with BG Reynolds!
After weeks of experimenting with various cocktail bases, I finally found the secret to that authentic, deep caramel profile that elevates a standard drink into a professional-grade Tiki experience. This BG Reynolds Rich Demerara syrup is a game-changer for anyone serious about craft cocktails, offering a molasses-rich sweetness that avoids the artificial sting of aspartame. It has a beautiful golden hue and a smooth texture that integrates seamlessly into everything from a classic Old Fashioned to a complex November Witch. Because it is made in Portland with all-natural ingredients and no preservatives, you can taste the quality in every pour. With roughly twelve servings per bottle, it is an easy way to turn a regular evening into a backyard tropical getaway without needing a professional bar setup.
🔥 INCLUDES: BG Reynolds Natural Tiki Cocktail Cane Syrup, Falernum, 375 ml, No Preservatives. About 15 Servings Per Container. Spice up your next party, or turn any day into Tiki Day with our Bespoke Craft Cocktail Syrups! We proudly make our mixes here in Portland Oregon, USA! By Bartenders, for bartenders, or anyone wanting to make a killer drink. We only use all natural ingredients for the highest quality mixes possible.
🍹 FALERNUM: Blair worked relentlessly to make a Falernum with just the right combination of ginger, clove, almond, and fresh lime, and the rest of us think he kind of nailed it. But don’t take our word for it. Try this with your next Bermuda Rum Swizzle, Frosty Dawn, or Puka Punch cocktail. Try it with your next cola or tonic. Heck, try it over a bit of ice, just to see what Charles Dickens was obsessing about so much back in the 19th Century.
🌴 HUGE VARIETY OF FLAVORS: Something for every spirit or soda you can think of! Cinnamon, Divine Vanilla, Falernum, Gardenia Mix, Hazelnut Orgeat, Honey Mix, Lime Cordial, Lush Grenadine, Original Orgeat, Paradise Blend, Passion Fruit, Pineapple Molasses, Rich Demerara Tiki Spices, Red Fassionola, and Wild Ginger. Try them all!
🎁 THE PERFECT GIFT: For yourself, or for others! Who doesn’t want Tiki gear as a gift?! These make awesome office party gifts for things like white elephant, as well as amazing stocking stuffers for christmas, birthdays, fathers day, or for any reason to spoil that Tiki lover in your life. Know a cocktail nerd? A grillmaster? Indoors or outdoors, the party goes where ever the BG Reynolds is!
🥥 NEED MORE TIKI GEAR?: Well, you’re in luck, BG Reynolds has everything you need! From Tiki Mugs, Cocktail Swizzle Sticks, our Thirsty Trio Tiki Pins, and Mai Tai Glasses, to of course our bartender approved all Natural and Fresh Cocktail Mixers and Syrups, step up your Tiki game with BG Reynolds!
BG Reynolds Natural Falernum is a masterclass in spice, delivering a perfectly balanced profile of ginger, clove, almond, and fresh lime. This isn't your typical grocery store syrup. It's a bespoke craft mixer handmade by bartenders in Portland, Oregon, using only all-natural ingredients and no preservatives. I found it transforms a standard Bermuda Rum Swizzle or Puka Punch into something truly professional. It even works surprisingly well as a flavor booster for your daily cola or tonic. With about 15 servings per bottle, it’s a concentrated way to upgrade your home bar without needing a massive pantry of individual spices. Whether you are a dedicated cocktail nerd or just looking to spice up a weekend party, this syrup brings authentic tropical depth to every pour.
🔥 INCLUDES: BG Reynolds Natural Tiki Cocktail Cane Syrup, Cinnamon, 750 ml, No Preservatives. About 25 Servings Per Container. Spice up your next party, or turn any day into Tiki Day with our Bespoke Craft Cocktail Syrups! We proudly make our mixes here in Portland Oregon, USA! By Bartenders, for bartenders, or anyone wanting to make a killer drink. We only use all natural ingredients for the highest quality mixes possible.
🍹 CINNAMON: When Blair set out to craft a cinnamon mixer for the bartender and mixologist alike, he wanted a balanced yet powerful addition for whatever cocktail they were throwing together. He mashed up a natural mix of fruity Ceylon and spicy cassia, and this delicious Cinnamon was born. So regardless of if you’re experimenting with some bourbon, making a classic old-fashioned, or even an apple pie moonshine cocktail, we know this Cinnamon is what you need to take it up a notch.
🌴 HUGE VARIETY OF FLAVORS: Something for every spirit or soda you can think of! Cinnamon, Divine Vanilla, Falernum, Gardenia Mix, Hazelnut Orgeat, Honey Mix, Lime Cordial, Lush Grenadine, Original Orgeat, Paradise Blend, Passion Fruit, Pineapple Molasses, Rich Demerara Tiki Spices, Red Fassionola, and Wild Ginger. Try them all!
🎁 THE PERFECT GIFT: For yourself, or for others! Who doesn’t want Tiki gear as a gift?! These make awesome office party gifts for things like white elephant, as well as amazing stocking stuffers for christmas, birthdays, fathers day, or for any reason to spoil that Tiki lover in your life. Know a cocktail nerd? A grillmaster? Indoors or outdoors, the party goes where ever the BG Reynolds is!
🥥 NEED MORE TIKI GEAR?: Well, you’re in luck, BG Reynolds has everything you need! From Tiki Mugs, Cocktail Swizzle Sticks, our Thirsty Trio Tiki Pins, and Mai Tai Glasses, to of course our bartender approved all Natural and Fresh Cocktail Mixers and Syrups, step up your Tiki game with BG Reynolds!
You might wonder if a pre-made syrup can actually deliver that authentic, bar-quality depth, but this cinnamon blend is a total game-changer for home mixology. Instead of relying on a one-dimensional spice, the creators mashed together fruity Ceylon and spicy cassia to achieve a sophisticated, balanced profile. I found it works just as well in a heavy bourbon Old Fashioned as it does in a whimsical apple pie moonshine cocktail. Because it is crafted in Portland using all-natural ingredients and zero preservatives, you get a clean taste that doesn't overwhelm your spirit. With about 25 servings per bottle, it is a high-quality staple that turns a standard Tuesday into a full-blown Tiki night without the hassle of making infusions from scratch.
🔥 INCLUDES: BG Reynolds Natural Tiki Cocktail Cane Syrup, Lime Cordial, 375 ml, No Preservatives. About 12.5 Servings Per Container. Spice up your next party, or turn any day into Tiki Day with our Bespoke Craft Cocktail Syrups! We proudly make our mixes here in Portland Oregon, USA! By Bartenders, for bartenders, or anyone wanting to make a killer drink. We only use all natural ingredients for the highest quality mixes possible.
🍹 LIME CORDIAL: The classic gin and tonic goes back ages, but the classic cocktail is as iconic a summertime drink as there is. The next time you’re in the mood for one, add some of our Lime Cordial to the mix. Blair crafted it with a fresh, distinctive citrus undertone that’s picked up by a bit of molasses-hinted demerara sugar. It’s a perfect kick to that gin and tonic, but feel free to just add it to a bit of ice and soda water for a nice sweet addition to your summer evening.
🌴 HUGE VARIETY OF FLAVORS: Something for every spirit or soda you can think of! Cinnamon, Divine Vanilla, Falernum, Gardenia Mix, Hazelnut Orgeat, Honey Mix, Lime Cordial, Lush Grenadine, Original Orgeat, Paradise Blend, Passion Fruit, Pineapple Molasses, Rich Demerara Tiki Spices, Red Fassionola, and Wild Ginger. Try them all!
🎁 THE PERFECT GIFT: For yourself, or for others! Who doesn’t want Tiki gear as a gift?! These make awesome office party gifts for things like white elephant, as well as amazing stocking stuffers for christmas, birthdays, fathers day, or for any reason to spoil that Tiki lover in your life. Know a cocktail nerd? A grillmaster? Indoors or outdoors, the party goes where ever the BG Reynolds is!
🥥 NEED MORE TIKI GEAR?: Well, you’re in luck, BG Reynolds has everything you need! From Tiki Mugs, Cocktail Swizzle Sticks, our Thirsty Trio Tiki Pins, and Mai Tai Glasses, to of course our bartender approved all Natural and Fresh Cocktail Mixers and Syrups, step up your Tiki game with BG Reynolds!
You might wonder if a bottled syrup can actually replicate the complexity of a hand-pressed citrus mix, but this Lime Cordial is a total game-changer for home bars. Crafted by bartenders in Portland, Oregon, it avoids the artificial aftertaste of mass-produced mixers by relying on all-natural ingredients. The flavor profile is sophisticated, blending a bright, distinctive citrus undertone with a subtle hint of molasses-infused demerara sugar. It elevates a standard gin and tonic into something much more professional, though it is equally delicious just stirred into soda water for a refreshing afternoon treat. With about twelve servings per bottle, it is a concentrated, high-quality essential for anyone serious about mastering the art of the tropical cocktail.
INCLUDES: BG Reynolds Natural Tiki Cocktail Cane Syrup, Original Orgeat, 750 ml, No Preservatives. About 25 Servings Per Container. We proudly make our mixes here in Portland Oregon, USA! We use all natural ingredients for the highest quality mixes
ORIGINAL ORGEAT: We took some real almonds, cane sugar, and created an original orgeat syrup made for all walks of life. Crafted for either the bbq or cocktail party, This orgeat syrup is perfect in a Mai Tai, Scorpion, or Momisette
HUGE VARIETY OF FLAVORS: Divine Vanilla, Falernum, Gardenia Mix, Hazelnut Orgeat, Honey Mix, Lime Cordial, Lush Grenadine, Original Orgeat, Paradise Blend, Passion Fruit, Pineapple Molasses, Rich Demerara, Tiki Spices, Red Fassionola, and Wild Ginger
THE PERFECT GIFT: Who doesn’t want Tiki gear?! These make awesome office party gifts for white elephant, as well as amazing stocking stuffers for christmas, birthdays, fathers day, or for any reason to spoil that Tiki lover in your life.
NEED MORE TIKI GEAR?: Well, you’re in luck, BG Reynolds has everything you need! From Tiki Mugs, Cocktail Swizzle Sticks, our Thirsty Trio Tiki Pins, and Mai Tai Glasses, to our bartender approved all Natural and Fresh Cocktail Mixers and Syrups
You might wonder if a bottled syrup can actually replicate the nuanced depth of a house-made cocktail ingredient, but this Orgeat changes the math. Instead of relying on artificial flavorings, BG Reynolds uses real almonds and cane sugar to deliver that essential nutty profile required for a legitimate Mai Tai or Scorpion. It is refreshing to find a mixer crafted in Portland that avoids preservatives entirely, focusing instead on all-natural quality. Each 750 ml bottle yields about 25 servings, making it a practical addition to a home bar rather than just a novelty item. Whether you are hosting a backyard BBQ or a dedicated tiki night, the texture and authenticity of this syrup elevate your drinks from basic to professional grade.
When browsing through a collection of premium syrups, the first thing to consider is the concentration of the flavor. High-quality syrups should provide a distinct taste without leaving a cloying, artificial aftertaste. Some syrups are designed to be 'high-impact,' meaning a small pump provides a massive punch of flavor, which is ideal for iced drinks where dilution from ice melt is a factor. Others are designed for subtlety, intended to enhance the natural notes of your coffee beans rather than masking them. When selecting a flavor, consider the base note: fruity syrups tend to work better in iced teas or sparkling waters, while nutty, chocolate, or spice-based syrups are the gold standard for steamed milk beverages.
Compatibility with Milk and Espresso
A common mistake in home brewing is selecting a syrup that 'breaks' or curdles when introduced to acidic coffee or hot dairy. A superior syrup acts as an emulsifier of sorts, blending smoothly into the microfoam of a latte. If you frequently prepare lattes or cappuccinos, look for syrups that emphasize a smooth mouthfeel. Some syrups can feel thin and watery, which can make a latte feel disconnected. Conversely, premium syrups often have a slightly higher viscosity that contributes to the creamy texture of the beverage. If you are a fan of dairy alternatives like oat or almond milk, ensure the flavor profile you choose isn't so overpowering that it clashes with the natural nuttiness or grain flavors of the plant-based milk.
Versatility: Beyond the Coffee Cup
Don't limit your purchasing decisions strictly to coffee-centric flavors. A smart way to build a syrup collection is to look for multi-use profiles. A high-quality vanilla or caramel syrup can be used in pancakes, waffles, or even atop vanilla bean ice cream. If you are looking to expand your beverage repertoire to include mocktails or sodas, look for citrus or botanical-leaning flavors. When evaluating a brand, ask yourself: 'Can I use this in more than one way?' A versatile pantry is the hallmark of a sophisticated home barista.
Storage and Shelf Life Considerations
Because these syrups are concentrated sugar or sweetener solutions, they are generally shelf-stable, but how you store them affects the integrity of the flavor. Intense botanical flavors can fade if exposed to direct sunlight or extreme temperature fluctuations. Always opt for bottles with secure, airtight closures to prevent oxidation. If you find yourself using a specific flavor infrequently, ensure the bottle size is manageable so the product doesn't sit open for months, which can lead to flavor degradation or crystallization at the nozzle.
Summary Recommendation Logic
To make the best decision, follow this hierarchy: First, define your primary use case (Coffee, Tea, or Cocktails). Second, select a flavor profile that complements your preferred milk type. Third, prioritize viscosity and blendability to ensure a professional texture. For beginners, we recommend starting with a 'trio' approach: one classic sweet (Vanilla or Caramel), one spice (Hazelnut or Cinnamon), and one seasonal or unique profile to test the boundaries of your brewing kit.
Ready to choose?
Jump back to our ranked picks or compare the shortlist side by side.
Quick answers about Bg Reynolds Syrups before you buy.
Yes, these syrups are formulated with high-quality ingredients and consistent Brix levels, making them ideal for both high-volume bars and home mixology enthusiasts.
To preserve the flavor profile and prevent spoilage, always store your syrups in a cool, dark place or ideally within a refrigerated unit after opening.
Most BG Reynolds syrups focus on natural flavor extraction, but you should always check the specific ingredient label on your bottle for exact additive details.
Absolutely. While designed for cocktails, they work exceptionally well as flavor enhancers for sparkling water, iced teas, and artisanal sodas.
Once the seal is broken, most syrups remain optimal for several weeks to a few months when refrigerated, depending on the specific flavor profile.
Yes, they are designed to be potent. A small amount goes a long way, so we recommend starting with a standard bar spoon measurement to avoid overpowering your drink.
Many of the botanical and spiced varieties are excellent for elevating lattes and cold brews, though fruit-forward syrups are better suited for iced beverages.
The majority of the syrup line is vegan-friendly, but always verify the specific ingredient list for any cross-contamination or honey-based sweeteners.
Rankings & Insights
Our Bg Reynolds Syrups Rankings
6Products Compared
9.7Avg PM Score
1Brands Ranked
Top 10 Bg Reynolds Syrups Brands on Amazon
Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our rankings.
