Best Plain Traditional Yogurt in 2026

MADE WITH 100% ORGANIC GRASS-FED MILK. Stonyfield Organic Grassfed Greek Whole Milk Plain Yogurt is made with organic milk from grass-fed cows, simple ingredients and packed with 16g of protein per serving.

RICH, UNIQUE FLAVOR. Cows have been eating grass, well, since forever. Milk from cows who graze naturally on lush grass gives yogurt a rich and unique flavor.

THE PERFECT STAPLE. The perfect breakfast staple or afternoon snack for you or your littles. Enjoy as is or add your favorite toppings, like fruit, granola, chocolate chips and more!

With billions of probiotics per serving, Stonyfield Organic Whole Milk Probiotic Yogurt helps support immunity and digestive health when eaten regularly as part of a healthy lifestyle and diet

Cut fat and calories: Sub Stonyfield Plain Yogurt to make tasty dressings and desserts, creamy soups, moist baked goods and tender marinated meats. The perfect breakfast staple or afternoon snack for you and your little ones alike

This probiotic yogurt is made with simple, wholesome ingredients and live active cultures. Packaged in a 32-ounce container

One 32-ounce cup of Happy Belly Traditional Whole Milk Plain Yogurt

Each serving has 110 calories and 6g of protein per serving

Good source of calcium, 15% of your daily value

CREAM ON TOP: Our Cream On Top grass-fed yogurt is plain, unsweetened organic whole milk yogurt that is tastefully tart, incredibly smooth, and topped with a luxurious ‘creamline’ layer

Live and Active Cultures: Our no sugar added yogurt is the same high quality organic milk with a silky texture and live and active cultures; the grass fed full fat yogurt has a layer of cream that can be scooped off or stirred in

100% ORGANIC GRASS FED MILK: Maple Hill’s cows eat only 100% grass, year round as nature intended; no corn, no grain, just grazing on lush pastures - the result is the creamiest full fat grass-fed yogurt

Non Greek/Traditional

Non Greek/Traditional

No thickeners or stabilizers

No added milk solids.

Made with live acidophilus culture & unhomogenized whole milk.

KETO/PALEO: Use FULL-FAT milks and the probiotics consume the sugars/carbs to grow leaving you with a full-fat, low-carb paleo/keto diet treats, yogurt, kefir, snacks, protein shakes, smoothies, Greek yogurt (strain off whey)… All with the added benefit of Trillions of fresh probiotics! Flavor as you like with stevia, monk fruit, protein powder...

FRESHEST Probiotics Available: Grow BILLIONS and TRILLIONS of CFU of 11 fresh probiotics that start working overnight (probiotic pills can take weeks). Yogurt makers are too hot (can kill mesophilic probiotic cultures), Kefir is too cool for thermophilic probiotics to thrive. The Probiotic Maker targets the perfect temperature to get benefits of both yogurt (thermophilic) and kefir (mesophilic) probiotics.

Save Time: Only 1 minute prep and no dirty dishes! Simply add a starter packet (2 free included), slide on the maker and plug in overnight (from about 8 hours on up). Then cool, flavor, & enjoy!