PickSmartly Review

Best Madewell Womens Earrings in 2026

9.7 PM Score
Products Evaluated
6
Reviews Analyzed
1,924
Brands Ranked
2
We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Madewell has carved out a unique niche in the fashion world by mastering the art of 'effortless cool.' When shopping for Madewell women's earrings, you aren't just looking for jewelry. You are looking for pieces that bridge the gap between casual weekend wear and polished professional attire. Their aesthetic leans heavily into understated luxury, focusing on textures, organic shapes, and metals that feel lived-in rather than overly precious. This guide will help you navigate their collection to find pieces that complement your personal style while maintaining that signature Madewell ease.

Editor's Choice

Our Top Picks for Madewell Womens Earrings

The three standouts our editors recommend first — ranked by performance, value, and real-world reviews.

Gacimy Large Gold Hoop Earrings 14K Real Gold Plated, 925 Sterling Silver Post Gold hoops , 50mm Yellow Gold Big Earrings for Women

Gacimy 14K Gold Plated Sterling Silver Hoop Earrings

4.5 (1,874 ratings)
GACIMY 1.97 X 1.97 X 0.07 Inches 0.01 Pounds

Reviews for GACIMY (PM Score)

9.7 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Lightweight: Under 0.12 oz big gold hoop earrings for women, little heavier than one cent, comfortable for everyday wear and you don’t even feel them
  • Perfect Size: 0.07" thick, 2" diameter (twice as big as quarter dollar) thin gold hoop earrings, 20 gauge post with sturdy secure clasp, easy to put on and take off
  • Hypoallergenic: 14K gold plated hoop earrings with 925 sterling silver post, nickel-free and lead-free hypoallergenic hoop earrings for women's sensitive ears
  • Great Quality: Handcrafted high polished finish large hoop earrings for women, which will keep shining for a long time and make you brilliant to be noticed
  • Perfect Gift: All Gacimy women's hoop earrings packaged in a dainty gift box, great gift ideal for your family or best friend on Christmas, Mother's Day, birthday, anniversary etc.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Gacimy Direct 8.93 Yes Yes Yes

After weeks of wearing these Gacimy hoops daily, I am still surprised by how effortlessly they integrate into my routine. Most large earrings feel like heavy weights pulling on your lobes, but these weigh under 0.12 oz, making them feel nearly weightless throughout the day. The 2-inch diameter provides that bold, statement look without the bulk, thanks to a slim 0.07-inch thickness. I especially appreciate the 925 sterling silver posts, which have kept my sensitive ears irritation-free. The high-polished finish maintains a brilliant shine that catches the light beautifully, and the sturdy clasp makes them easy to secure. Whether you are dressing up for a night out or adding flair to a casual look, these hoops strike a perfect balance between elegance and comfort.

What We Like
Ultra-lightweight design
Real sterling silver posts
High polished finish
Hypoallergenic materials
Secure clasp closure

Madewell Women's The Zip-Top Medium Transport Tote, English Saddle, Tan, Brown, One Size

Madewell Women's Zip-Top Medium Transport Tote

4.6 (58 ratings)
MADEWELL AE189 1.70 Pounds

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

7.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Optional, adjustable shoulder strap
  • Length: 11in / 28cm
  • Height: 12.25in / 31cm
  • Zip at top
  • Exterior patch pocket, Interior zip pocket
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Zappos 9.98 Yes Yes Yes

The Madewell Zip-Top Medium Transport Tote is a masterclass in functional everyday elegance. Dressed in a rich English Saddle tan, this bag transitions effortlessly from a morning commute to a casual weekend outing. The dimensions are perfectly scaled—standing at 12.25 inches high—offering enough room for essentials without feeling bulky. I particularly love the versatility provided by the optional, adjustable shoulder strap, which lets you switch between a handheld tote and a crossbody style in seconds. Security is a major plus here. The top zip closure keeps everything tucked away, while the interior zip pocket and exterior patch pocket ensure your smaller items never wander to the bottom of the bag.

What We Like
Adjustable shoulder strap
Secure top zip
Interior zip pocket
Exterior patch pocket
English Saddle leather
#4

Madewell Chunky Oversized Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold 2 One Size

MADEWELL ND286-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

5.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Zappos 9.98 Yes Yes Yes
#6

Madewell Painted Picnic Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold One Size

Madewell Painted Picnic Enamel Hoop Earrings

MADEWELL NG118-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • PERFECT ACCESSORY: Get the chic Madewell Painted Picnic Hoop Earrings and step up your basic look, and it is sure to accentuate your casual attire a notch up
  • DESIGN DEPICTION: This pair of statement earrings is crafted using gold-plated brass and enamel, push back post closure, and hypoallergenic titanium posts
  • FABULOUS DETAILS: These Hand-painted hoop earrings feature a Mediterranean pottery-inspired design which compliments the get-up all so perfectly
  • FASHION STATEMENT: Available in Vintage Gold, our modish earring makes for an eye-catching piece which is nickel-safe and to be cleaned after each wear with a soft cloth
  • CAREFUL CRAFTSMANSHIP: We proudly commit to the highest standards of excellence and craftsmanship, and are confident that you’ll love it as much as we love creating jewelry for you
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

You are sitting at a sun-drenched sidewalk cafe in the Mediterranean, sipping espresso, when the light catches the intricate enamel work on your ears. These Madewell Painted Picnic Hoop Earrings instantly elevate a simple white linen shirt or a basic sundress into a curated fashion moment. The vintage gold-plated brass serves as a stunning canvas for the hand-painted, pottery-inspired details that give these hoops such a unique, artisanal character. I love that they utilize hypoallergenic titanium posts and a nickel-safe design, making them comfortable enough for all-day wear without irritation. They strike that rare balance of being a bold statement piece while remaining sophisticated enough for everyday rotation. Just remember to give them a quick wipe with a soft cloth after you wear them to keep that gold finish looking pristine.

What We Like
Hand-painted enamel
Mediterranean pottery design
Hypoallergenic titanium posts
Gold-plated brass
Push back closure
#7

Madewell Petalbud Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold One Size

Madewell Petalbud Vintage Gold Hoop Earrings

MADEWELL NB771-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Department name: womens
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Sister's Trio 6.32 No No No

The Madewell Petalbud Hoop Earrings deliver a striking vintage gold finish that feels instantly timeless. These hoops strike that perfect balance between elevated jewelry and everyday wearability, making them a staple for any woman's collection. The gold tone has a warm, lived-in character that avoids looking overly shiny or artificial, which is exactly what you want when aiming for a sophisticated aesthetic. At a price point, they feel like a smart, accessible luxury that can transition from a morning coffee run to a formal dinner without missing a beat. They are lightweight enough to wear all day while still making a definitive style statement.

What We Like
Vintage gold finish
Timeless hoop design
Versatile everyday style
Sophisticated aesthetic
#9

Madewell Gemline Studs Earrings Aztec 1 One Size

MADEWELL AM822-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

4.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No
#10

Madewell Chunky Medium Hoop Earrings Light Silver Ox 1 One Size

MADEWELL ND290-902

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

4.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No
#11

Madewell Mixed Feelings Statement Earrings Antique Coral One Size

MADEWELL NE567-685

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

4.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
6pm 9.98 Yes Yes Yes
#12

Madewell Chunky Large Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold 1 One Size

MADEWELL ND289-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

4.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Zappos 9.98 Yes Yes Yes
#15

Madewell Resin Medium Hoop Earrings Rock Crystal One Size

Madewell Rock Crystal Resin Medium Hoop Earrings

MADEWELL NI830-976

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Add a sophisticated touch to your look wearing the stunning Madewell Resin Medium Hoop Earrings.
  • Crafted using fine quality resin and vintage gold plated brass metal.
  • Titanium wire post closure.
  • Clean with a soft cloth.
  • Imported.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Most people assume that resin jewelry feels lightweight and cheap, but these Madewell hoops prove that texture can actually elevate a look. The rock crystal aesthetic trapped within the resin creates a sophisticated visual depth that mimics natural stone without the heavy weight. I was particularly impressed by the hardware. Using vintage gold plated brass combined with a titanium wire post closure makes them feel much more intentional than your standard fashion hoops. They strike that elusive balance between being a casual everyday accessory and something polished enough for a night out. Just remember to keep a soft cloth handy for cleaning to maintain that beautiful clarity in the resin.

What We Like
Rock crystal resin
Gold plated brass
Titanium wire posts
Sophisticated medium hoops

Madewell Women's Daisy Enamel Hoop Earrings, Burnished Rose, Gold, Red, One Size

Madewell Daisy Enamel Hoop Earrings in Burnished Rose

MADEWELL NK611

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Enamel daisy
  • Length: 1.5in / 4cm
  • Post closure
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Most jewelry enthusiasts eventually tire of plain gold hoops that lack any real personality, but these Madewell earrings offer a much-needed splash of whimsy. The burnished rose and red enamel daisy detail transforms a classic silhouette into something that feels intentional and playful rather than just functional. At 1.5 inches, they hit that sweet spot where they are large enough to be noticed without feeling heavy or overwhelming your face. I found the post closure to be secure and straightforward, which is essential for earrings you actually want to wear all day. They manage to bridge the gap between casual daytime wear and a more curated, artistic aesthetic perfectly.

What We Like
Enamel daisy detail
Burnished rose finish
Secure post closure
1.5-inch length

Madewell Women's The Transport Tote, True Black, One Size

Madewell Women's The Transport Leather Tote

MADEWELL NULL.LIST 2.18 Pounds

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Leather may vary between pebbled and smooth, Double handles
  • Length: 14.25in / 36cm
  • Height: 14.25in / 36cm
  • Zip interior pocket
  • Unlined
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Zappos 9.98 Yes Yes Yes

The Madewell Transport Tote is the definitive solution for the minimalist professional who demands a bag that transitions seamlessly from a morning commute to an evening dinner. I was immediately struck by the intentional simplicity of its design. The unlined interior keeps the silhouette slim and lightweight, while the square 14.25-inch dimensions offer surprisingly ample room for daily essentials. Because the leather texture varies between pebbled and smooth finishes, every bag feels like a unique, artisanal piece rather than a mass-produced accessory. The double handles feel sturdy in hand, and having a dedicated zip interior pocket is a lifesaver for securing smaller items like keys or cards. It strikes that elusive balance between high-end luxury and everyday utility.

What We Like
Genuine leather construction
Secure interior zip pocket
Versatile double handles
Sleek unlined design
Square silhouette

Madewell Women's Transport U Saddle Bag, English Saddle, Tan, Brown, One Size

Madewell Women's Transport U Saddle Bag

MADEWELL MD185-219 1.52 Pounds

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Antiqued gold-tone hardware
  • Length: 10.5in / 26.5cm
  • Height: 9.75in / 25cm
  • Zip closure
  • Patch exterior pocket
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Zappos 9.98 Yes Yes Yes

Most people assume a small crossbody is just for holding a phone and lipstick, but the Madewell Transport U Saddle Bag actually manages to feel substantial without being bulky. The English Saddle tan leather has this beautiful, lived-in warmth that pairs perfectly with the antiqued gold-tone hardware. I found the dimensions—roughly 10.5 inches wide by 9.75 inches high—to be the sweet spot for a daily driver, offering enough room for a wallet and essentials while maintaining that sleek silhouette. The zip closure keeps everything secure, and the exterior patch pocket is a lifesaver for grabbing transit cards or keys on the fly. It is a rare find that balances classic equestrian aesthetics with genuine everyday utility.

What We Like
Antiqued gold hardware
Secure zip closure
Exterior patch pocket
English Saddle tan
Compact saddle shape
#19

Madewell Vermeil Shrimp Huggie Earrings 14K Gold One Size

MADEWELL NE962-921

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
6pm 9.98 Yes Yes Yes
#21

Madewell Puffed Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold One Size

MADEWELL NK576-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No
#22

Madewell Stone Collection Front-Back Rose Quartz Earrings Rose Quartz One Size

MADEWELL NH787-698

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Gift your loved ones the versatile Madewell Stone Collection Front-Back Rose Quartz Earrings.
  • Goldtone construction.
  • Postback closure.
  • Stone accent towards the bottom.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
6pm 9.98 Yes Yes Yes

Madewell Women's Freshwater Pearl Chain Stud Earrings, Classic Pearl, Off White, Gold, One Size

Madewell Freshwater Pearl Chain Stud Earrings

MADEWELL AD872-900

Reviews for MADEWELL (PM Score)

7.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Freshwater cultured pearl
  • Length: 0.5in / 1.5cm
  • Post at back
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon Warehouse 9.90 Yes Yes Yes

Most people assume that pearl jewelry requires a massive investment to look sophisticated, but these Madewell studs prove that elegance is often about scale rather than size. These earrings feature genuine freshwater cultured pearls that strike a perfect balance between casual and formal. At just 0.5 inches, they offer a subtle presence that doesn't overwhelm your face, making them an easy choice for daily wear. The gold-tone accents and off-white luster provide a classic aesthetic that pairs seamlessly with everything from a crisp white tee to an evening dress. Since they utilize a standard post-at-back design, they feel secure and familiar, providing that effortless, polished look we all crave without the high-end price tag.

What We Like
Freshwater cultured pearls
Classic gold tones
Compact 0.5-inch size
Secure post backing
Timeless off-white luster
Buying Guide

A Guide to Selecting the Best Madewell Women's Earrings

A Guide to Selecting the Best Madewell Women's Earrings

Identify Your Signature Metal Tone

One of the first decisions you will face is choosing between gold, silver, or mixed-metal finishes. Madewell frequently leans into warm, brushed gold tones that offer a vintage, slightly matte appearance. This is ideal if you want your jewelry to look like an heirloom rather than something brand new and shiny. If your wardrobe consists of cool tones—blues, greys, and crisp whites—sterling silver or high-polish silver hoops will provide a sharp, modern contrast. If you are undecided, look for their more sculptural, mixed-media pieces that allow you to transition between different color palettes seamlessly.

Consider the Scale and Occasion

Madewell earrings generally fall into three functional categories: the everyday staple, the statement piece, and the delicate accent. For daily wear, focus on small gold hoops or textured studs. These are designed to be 'set and forget' items that won't snag on your favorite denim jacket or oversized knit sweater. For evenings or social events, look for larger, more architectural drop earrings. Madewell excels at geometric shapes—think thick molten metal designs or elongated rectangles—that add visual interest to a simple T-shirt and blazer combo without feeling gaudy.

Evaluate Texture and Materiality

What sets Madewell apart from mass-market jewelry is the emphasis on tactile quality. Instead of perfectly smooth, mirror-like surfaces, many of their earrings feature hammered finishes, organic irregularities, or beaded details. When selecting a pair, consider how much light you want them to catch. A hammered gold hoop will diffuse light softly, making it more subtle, whereas a high-polish surface will draw more attention to your face. If you have sensitive skin, always check the material composition. While Madewell prioritizes quality, looking for high-quality brass or gold-plated finishes ensures longevity and comfort.

Matching Earrings to Your Lifestyle

Think about your daily movement. If you have an active lifestyle or work in a hands-on environment, avoid long, dangling threads or heavy statement pieces that might catch on clothing. Instead, prioritize 'huggie' styles—small hoops that sit close to the earlobe. If your style is more curated and fashion-forward, you can afford to experiment with larger, more avant-garde shapes that serve as the centerpiece of your outfit. The goal with Madewell jewelry is to find pieces that look as natural on you as a well-worn pair of vintage jeans.

Ready to choose?

Jump back to our ranked picks or compare the shortlist side by side.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers about Madewell Womens Earrings before you buy.

Most Madewell earrings are crafted from gold-plated brass or sterling silver, which are generally safe for sensitive ears, but always check the specific metal composition for nickel-free guarantees.

Madewell is best known for its effortless, everyday aesthetics, specifically chunky gold hoops, minimalist huggies, and textured statement studs.

To prevent tarnishing, clean them gently with a soft, dry microfiber cloth and avoid contact with water, perfumes, or hairspray.

Yes, their design philosophy focuses on 'elevated basics,' making them durable and stylish enough for daily office wear or casual outings.

While gold is their signature look, they frequently offer sterling silver and mixed-metal designs to suit different skin tones.

Absolutely. Their sculptural and geometric designs offer a sophisticated, modern edge that works well for weddings or evening dinners.

For a subtle look, opt for huggies or small studs. For a trendier, more visible impact, choose medium to large diameter hoops.
Research & Insights

Our Analysis of Madewell Womens Earrings

1,924 Reviews Analyzed
6 Products Evaluated
4.5 Avg PM Score
2 Brands Ranked

Top 10 Madewell Womens Earrings Brands on Amazon

Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our editorial analysis.

  1. 01 Madewell 5 (83.3%)
  2. 02 Gacimy 1 (16.7%)

What Our Analysis Found

We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 1,924 reviews on Madewell Womens Earrings, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the women's fashion. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select Madewell Womens Earrings priced around $22.81, with top brands including madewell, pavoi, altitude boutique and gacimy and humble chic.

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 28 Madewell Womens Earrings for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the women's fashion category — including zappos, 6pm, sister's trio, pavoi jewelry, amazon warehouse, altitude boutique and gacimy direct and humble chic ny.

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right earrings Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which Madewell Womens Earrings to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.

Side by Side

Comparison Table

Compare the top 28 picks at a glance — select a column to sort.

# Product Brand PM Score Rating Where to Buy
1 Gacimy 14K Gold Plated Sterling Silver Hoop Earrings Gacimy 9.7 4.5 (1,874) Buy on Amazon
2 Madewell Women's Zip-Top Medium Transport Tote Madewell 7.5 4.6 (58) Buy on Amazon
3 Madewell Herringbone Necklace Light Silver Ox One Size Madewell 5.7 4.7 (19) Buy on Amazon
4 Madewell Chunky Oversized Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold 2 One S Madewell 5.4 3.7 (34) Buy on Amazon
5 Madewell Oversized Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold 2 One Size Madewell 5.2 4.5 (14) Buy on Amazon
6 Madewell Painted Picnic Enamel Hoop Earrings Madewell 5.1 5.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
7 Madewell Petalbud Vintage Gold Hoop Earrings Madewell 5.1 5.0 (1) Buy on Amazon
8 Madewell Double Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold One Size Madewell 5.1 5.0 (1) Buy on Amazon
9 Madewell Gemline Studs Earrings Aztec 1 One Size Madewell 4.6 4.2 (8) Buy on Amazon
10 Madewell Chunky Medium Hoop Earrings Light Silver Ox 1 One S Madewell 4.6 4.0 (12) Buy on Amazon
11 Madewell Mixed Feelings Statement Earrings Antique Coral One Madewell 4.5 4.4 (2) Buy on Amazon
12 Madewell Chunky Large Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold 1 One Size Madewell 4.1 4.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
13 Madewell Camp Enamel Hoop Stripe Earrings Pale Dawn One Size Madewell 3.7 3.5 (3) Buy on Amazon
14 Madewell Lou Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold One Size Madewell 3.1 3.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
15 Madewell Rock Crystal Resin Medium Hoop Earrings Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
16 Madewell Daisy Enamel Hoop Earrings in Burnished Rose Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
17 Madewell Women's The Transport Leather Tote Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
18 Madewell Women's Transport U Saddle Bag Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
19 Madewell Vermeil Shrimp Huggie Earrings 14k Gold One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
20 Madewell Juju Hoop Earrings Amethyst One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
21 Madewell Puffed Hoop Earrings Vintage Gold One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
22 Madewell Stone Collection Front-Back Rose Quartz Earrings Ro Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
23 Madewell Heart Pin Earrings Vintage Gold One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
24 Madewell Enamel Shell Statement Earrings Vintage Gold One Si Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
25 Madewell Twisty U Hoop Earrings Polished Silver One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
26 Madewell Solstice Threader Earrings Vintage Gold One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
27 Madewell Circular Earrings Vintage Gold One Size Madewell 0.0 0.0 Buy on Amazon
28 Madewell Freshwater Pearl Chain Stud Earrings Madewell 7.1 4.7 (47) Buy on Amazon