Best Making Believe in 2026

Last Updated: Sep 27, 2023

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Kids Western Rodeo Cowboy or Cowgirl Basic Costume Set - Vest, Brown Hat, Bandanna - Size 6-8
#TOP1
Kids Western Rodeo Cowboy Or Cowgirl Basic Costume
9.6
PM SCORE
Making Believe Girls Princess Gloves 3 Pack - Pink, Blue and White
#TOP2
Making Believe Girls Princess Gloves 3 Pack -
9.6
PM SCORE
Making Believe Girls Deluxe Bonnet (Girls 4-8 years, Blue Calico)
#TOP3
Making Believe Girls Deluxe Bonnet (Girls 4-8 Years,
9.5
PM SCORE

* PickSmartly editors independently research, review, and endorse the top products through comprehensive data analysis. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through our product links.

Summary of the best Making Believe of 2026

Market Overview
Making Believe Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 3,401 Items
  • PM Avg. Rating: 6.4 / 10
36 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $55.99
  • Lowest Price: $5.99
  • Avg. Price: $18.33
#TOP1

Kids Western Rodeo Cowboy Or Cowgirl Basic Costume Set - Vest, Brown Hat, Bandanna - Size 6-8

MAKING BELIEVE
VESTHATBANDANNA
0.46 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Dress up set includes a brown cow print western style vest, brown felt hat and classic red bandana

Great addition to a Halloween costume or dress up trunk for boys or girls

Kids will enjoy imaginative play as Western Cowboys or Cowgirls.

The perfect accessory for your western theme party, birthday, rodeo, school play and count fair

Brown cow print fabric has low pile plush texture with binding edge

#TOP2

Making Believe Girls Princess Gloves 3 Pack - Pink, Blue And White

MAKING BELIEVE
60127-60119
9.88 X 8.39 X 0.71 Inches
0.19 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Value set pairs of short, wrist-length gloves for girls (Gloves dimensions: Wrist circumference is approx. 6", length of gloves from wrist to middle finger is approx. 7.5", thumb length is approx. 3", pinky finger length is approx. 2")

Gloves measure approx. 6" long - recommended for girls age 2 and up (please measure before ordering)

Fun for pretend play, dress up, Halloween costumes and princess, fairy or tea parties

Soft lightweight nylon knit satin fabric

Perfect as a party favor for your guests at a theme party

#TOP3

Making Believe Girls Deluxe Bonnet (Girls 4-8 Years, Blue Calico)

MAKING BELIEVE
DELUXE BONNET4-8
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one women's size polyester calico deluxe style pioneer bonnet

Fun for parades, school plays, pioneer trek, peasant, medieval, colonial, renaissance, dress up and Halloween costumes

Choose from a variety of colors in solid colors or floral calico prints

Deluxe style pioneer bonnet has a fully lined hat brim, ties around the neck and elastic back for adjustable fit

This is not a replica costume (not made of heavy cotton fabric) - Please measure before you buy to ensure a proper fit.

#TOP4

Making Believe Kids Plush Rainbow Unicorn Headband And Tail Costume Accessory Set

MAKING BELIEVE
SAFARI EARS & TAIL
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

White and rainbow plush unicorn headband ears and tail set

Adjustable soft touch belt closure for the tail piece

Fun for halloween costumes or dress up

Headband is one size, recommended for children

Ideal for school plays

#TOP5

Making Believe Brown Furry Puppy Dog Headband And Tail

MAKING BELIEVE
SAFARI EARS & TAIL
9.60 X 8.00 X 2.00 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Costume set includes cute brown puppy dog headband with floppy ears and tail

Adjustable soft touch belt closure for the tailpiece

Headband is one size, recommended for children

Fun for Halloween costumes or dress up play

Recommended for children age 3+

Making Believe Adult Knit 48" Superhero Cape - Red

MAKING BELIEVE
6834510
11.00 X 9.00 X 1.40 Inches
0.75 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one knit 48" long cape

Making Believe brand stretch jersey knit 48" long cape

Ideal for Halloween costumes, plays, theatrical performances, special events

Many colors available, sold separately, NOTE THAT DUE TO SAFETY STANDARDS, THIS CAPE HAS A HOOK AND LOOK NECK CLOSURE, RATHER THAN A TIE

Cape length is approx. 48" and approx. neck circumference approx.16"

#TOP7

Deluxe Bonnet, Girls 8-14 Years, Pink Calico

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one women's size polyester calico deluxe style pioneer bonnet

Fun for parades, school plays, pioneer trek, peasant, medieval, colonial, renaissance, dress up and Halloween costumes

Choose from a variety of colors in solid colors or floral calico prints

Deluxe style pioneer bonnet has a fully lined hat brim, ties around the neck and elastic back for adjustable fit

This is not a replica costume (not made of heavy cotton fabric) - Please measure before you buy to ensure a proper fit

Women's Simple White 30" Long Peasant Apron

MAKING BELIEVE
45426-45570
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one white simple peasant style apron

Long apron with attached rather short ties is the perfect style for a Puritan or pilgrim costume - ideal for a knotted back, rather than a bow

Use this apron for the home entertainer or everyday gourmet chef or cook at home, work, restaurant server or hostess, pastry shop, barista, etc

Perfect costume accessory for Halloween, Mrs. Santa Claus, medieval, renaissance, peasant, pilgrim, pioneer, colonial and other time period or historical costumes

Classic design is simple, practical, affordable, comfortable, and easy care

#TOP9

Making Believe Men's Knickers, Renaissance Pants, Medieval Pants, Pirate Pants Mens | Mens Knickers, Renaissance Costumes - Teen's Size 14, Black

MAKING BELIEVE
45497-504
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one pair of knickers

Elastic waist and knees for an adjustable fit - measure to ensure proper fit

Great for theatrical performances, Halloween costumes, or plays

Versatile costume essential for pirate, renaissance, peasant, pilgrim, pioneer, medieval, or colonial

Made from 100% easy care

#TOP10

Making Believe Kids Aviator Dress Up Costume Hat And Scarf Set

MAKING BELIEVE
AVIATORCOSTUME
13.50 X 11.50 X 1.50 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one unisex avaiator costume

Faux leather brown aviator hat with fur lining for a comfortable fit

This classic aviator set is fun for pretend play, school plays, career days and Halloween costumes

The perfect finishing touch to your Pilot or Steampunk costume!

One size fits most children age 3 and up

Making Believe Gingerbread Apron, Christmas Apron, Christmas Aprons For Kids| Kitchen Apron, Cute Apron, Thanksgiving Aprons, Christmas Aprons For Kids With Pockets, Holiday Aprons, Kids Red Apron

MAKING BELIEVE
SG_B00A7EILP0_US
9.90 X 9.50 X 0.60 Inches
0.20 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one child size apron: The Gingerbread Man apron is made of 100% cotton, and has gingerbread boy and stars embroidered on the top and a large pocket in the center of the apron.

This adorable Christmas apron is made of good quality durable material and is nicely stitched. The gingerbread man apron has a cute gingerbread boy and stars embroidered on. Great for both boys and girls to wear.

Gingerbread Man apron dimensions: Length: 21.5", Width: 20", Neck strap: 19", Length of each apron string: 19". Please measure before ordering to ensure a proper fit.

This fun and festive apron can be used for a variety of occasions such as Christmas parties, baking cookies and other holiday goodies, helping out in the kitchen, dress up, and more.

Child size, recommended for age 3 to 8 years

#TOP12
Best For Lion

Sitting Lovable Lion Stuffed Animal - 15" | Stuffed Lion | Lion Plush | Stuffed Animal Lion | Plush Lion, Toy Lion Plush, Lion Plush Stuffed Animal, Stuffed Lion Plush, Lions Stuffed Animal

MAKING BELIEVE
00271
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Bring the beauty of the Savanna to your baby's nursery, create a stuffed lion jungle themed bedroom or playroom adding this adorable African lion stuffed animal

This gentle feline has come a long way from the lion toy, but no need to worry he promises not to bite! He is the perfect size for little hands to cuddle and snuggle. Kids will take him anywhere they go and together will have many safari adventures!

Our squishy, cozy majestic stuffed animal lion plush is the perfect cuddle buddy for your child, he is huggable and oh so charming. Plush animal lion will help ease your little one to sleep at night

This cute stuffed animal plush lion toy has super soft caramel fur. His high quality embroidered face makes him safe for children. He has a spunky fuzzy mane and tail with the sweetest smile. He is oh so snugly and ready for hugs!

This king of the lion stuff animals is the perfect gift for a toddler and children of all ages. His neutral color scheme works for girls or boys, he is an ideal baby shower gift, birthday, Christmas present or just because!

#TOP13

Girls Assorted Fashion Stripes Small Leg Warmers 5 Pack - Pink/Hot Pink/Lavender/Blue

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes Value Multi Pairs leg warmers for toddlers and girls

Set includes splashes of popular colors (Choose your style)

Made of 80% cotton, 15% polyester, 5% spandex

One size fits 12 months and up; Leg warmers measure approx. 12" long

Add a fun layer of warmth and fashion with these colorful and easy accessories

#TOP14

Making Believe Boys Long Colonial Costume Vest (Boys Large 10-12), Black

MAKING BELIEVE
45546-9
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one long colonial style costume vest for boys

Quality vest made from polyester with all finished seams and hems

Fun for a Halloween costumes, imaginative play, stage time and dress up

Ideal for renaissance, medieval, colonial, peasant, pioneer, pirate and other historic eras

Available in four sizes for boys - 6/8, 8/10, 10/12 and 12/14

#TOP15

Making Believe Womens Chemise Peasant Dress (One Size, White)

MAKING BELIEVE
04046
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

One size teen or women's tea length pull over medieval chemise dress ( Dimensions: Dress measures approx. 50" long, Dress circumference is approx. 62", Sleeves are 19" long and Ruffle is 7.5" wide)

Standard size fits most women with a 34 to 38-inch bust and 26 to 32-inch waist

Fun for a Halloween costume,historical and period costumes and theatrical use

Gathered sleeves have elastic for an adjustable fit; Adjustable neckline gathers with a tie to be worn around the neck or just off the shoulders

Perfect for colonial, renaissance, peasant, pioneer, pilgrim, Latin, pirate, or other theme costumes

Making Believe Girls Classic Mop Cap And Apron Set, White

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one apron and mop cap set - pioneer, colonial era, peasant or pilgrim style accessory set

Fun for a Halloween costume, parades, theatrical performances, school plays, pioneer trek and everyday dress up

Use this apron and mop hat for the home entertainer or everyday gourmet chef or cook at home, work, restaurant server or hostess, pastry shop, barista, etc.

Great value when you purchase the set, rather than individual pieces

Polyester fabric in white color

Making Believe Womens Classic Mop Cap And Apron Set, White

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one apron and mop cap set - pioneer, colonial era, peasant or pilgrim style accessory set

Fun for a Halloween costume, parades, theatrical performances, school plays, pioneer trek and everyday dress up

Use this apron and mop hat for the home entertainer or everyday gourmet chef or cook at home, work, restaurant server or hostess, pastry shop, barista, etc.

Great value when you purchase the set, rather than individual pieces

Polyester fabric in white color

#TOP18

Making Believe Girls Blue Denim Cupcake Apron

MAKING BELIEVE
DENIM OR CANVAS APRON
8.60 X 1.10 X 10.10 Inches
0.25 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Child size cotton canvas apron with cute cupcake embroidery

Apron measures approx. 21 1/2" x 20" with 19" ties, approx. 19" neck circumference

Patch pocket front

Fun for a theme birthday party favor

Your little helpers will love to help in the kitchen

Plush Little Lamb 11" | Lamb Stuffed Animal, Stuffed Lamb, Sheep Stuffed Animal, Sheep Plush, Lamb Plush, Stuffed Sheep, Stuffed Animal Baby Lamb, Stuffed Animal Lamb, Lamb Toy, Realistic Stuffed Lamb

MAKING BELIEVE
00487
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Plush little lamb is a sweet friend made with ultra-soft textured fabric; lamb's body is creamy white with taupe feet and ears

Measures approximately 10-Inches tall; sweet stuffed lamb has a soft fabric face with embroidered features and plastic eyes

Incredibly huggable, little arms will love to squeeze; surface washable, spot clean with a damp cloth

Combine with other soft toys and character blankets; designed in quiet, neutral hues perfect for your little one's bedroom

The perfect size for a little toddler hands and light enough for children to carry it everywhere. No sharp edges so it can be hugged all day long

#TOP20

Making Believe Pink Ribbon Cupcake Headband

MAKING BELIEVE
4537339
6.10 X 6.00 X 2.70 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Pink ribbon cupcake headband

Fun for Halloween, school plays, dress up, costumes

Share them with your party guests for a theme birthday party

Easy to put on and off of all your party guest.

Recommended for children age 3 and up

#TOP21

Making Believe Kids Unisex Brown Victorian Waistcoat Vest, M/L

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one faux suede victorian vest. Vest length from should to hem is approx. 19", Vest circumference is approx. 38" and Vest width from side to size is approx. 19".

Traditional vest as worn in victorian era and renaissance times is a throw back in history

Fun for a Halloween costume, theme party favor, and everyday dress up

Perfect for play time, stage time or school dress up days

Recommended for boys or girls age 8-12 years

#TOP22

Making Believe Classic Storybook Princess Dress 3 Pack Set - Blue/Yellow/Red - Size 2-4

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes 3 classic princess dresses in blue, yellow and red (SORRY, THIS ITEM CANNOT SHIP TO A PO BOX)

Great value pack to add to dress up trunks or for gifs and birthdays

Fun for Halloween costumes, theme party favors, gifts and everyday dress up

Your little princess will enjoy hours of pretend play fun with this colorful set

Recommended for girls age 2-4 years (SORRY, THIS ITEM CANNOT SHIP TO A PO BOX)

#TOP23

Making Believe Kids Outdoor Safari Adventure Vest And Straw Pith Hat

MAKING BELIEVE
SAFARI SET
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one twill khaki safari explorer vest and one straw pith hat (11.5 L x 10.5 W x 6 H)

Fun for Halloween, school plays, dress up, costumes, safari or zoo animal theme birthday party

Fun for birthday and holiday gifts

High quality vest made from sturdy twill with all finished seams and hems

Recommended for age 14 years and up

#TOP24

Hot Pink Princess Cone Hat Headband

MAKING BELIEVE
43209-8653
10.00 X 4.70 X 2.70 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Hot pink princess cone headband

Fun for Halloween, school plays, dress up, costumes

Share them with your party guests for a theme birthday party

Easy to put on and off of all your party guest

Recommended for children age 3 and up

#TOP25

Making Believe Girls Classic Storybook Wishes Cowgirl, Cheerleader, Pirate 3 Pack Dress Up Set, 4-6 Years

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes cowgirl, cheerleader, pirate 3 pack dress up set

Fun party or addition to a log costume

Ideal for groups - Value Priced

Ideal for children age 3+

#TOP26

Making Believe Classic Storybook Princess Dress 4 Pack Set - Hot Pink/Pink & Blue/Yellow - Size 6-8

MAKING BELIEVE
DRESS4PACKSET
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes 4 classic princess dresses

Great value pack to add to your dress up trunks or for gifts and birthdays

Fun for Halloween costumes, theme party favors, gifts and everyday dress up

Your little princess will enjoy hours of pretend play fun with this colorful set

Dress style may vary slightly

#TOP27

Making Believe Adult Unisex White Classic Lab Coat Size Large

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one white unisex lab coat size large for teens, women or men

Ideal for the science lab, art room, cooking or doctor Halloween Costume

Long sleeved lab coat length is approx.

Two lower patch pockets and one chest pocket

Easy button up front with lapel collar

#TOP28

Girls Cinderella Blue Princess Dress Up Accessory Set Size 3-7 Years

MAKING BELIEVE
13.70 X 11.18 X 3.70 Inches
1.40 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes cinderella's blue dress up accessory set

Great value pack to add to your outfit or for gifts and birthdays

Fun for Halloween costumes, theme party favors, giveaways, and daily dress

Your little princess will enjoy hours of playtime fun with this colorful game

Recommended for age 3 years and up

#TOP29

Girls Pink & Black Stripes Pirate Mate Costume Dress, Size 4/6

MAKING BELIEVE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

Includes one girls pastel pink and black striped Pirate Mate costume ruffled dress

Fun for a Halloween costumes, theme party favor, and everyday dress up

Perfect for play time, stage time or school dress up days

Made of soft knit interlock knit fabric with long sleeves and ruffle trim at the neckline and sleeves

Cute screen printed skull and cross bones emblem on the front

#TOP30

Soft Plush Around The World 8" Collector Dolls - Polynesian

MAKING BELIEVE
SAFARI EARS & TAIL
8.70 X 6.50 X 1.40 Inches
0.02 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Making Believe 9.85

Features

BEAUTIFUL POLYNESIAN DOLL - Aloha! She is all dressed up in the cutest fringed green hula inspired grass skirt dress, a floral lei and pink flip flop sandals resembling a Hawaiian dancer outfit. Her beautiful velvet fabric black hair has been styled with a floral headband. Her embroidered smile will brighten your day!

CUTE, SOFT AND CUDDLY - A must have gift for your little traveler aspirant, the perfect companion to many adventures around the world!

MULTICULTURAL AND ETHNIC - Our Island collectible doll is great for storytelling and will help children introduce diversity to pretend play by exploring a different culture

INTERNATIONAL PLUSH FRIEND - Your little girl will feel like she is going on a vacation trip to the Pacific Islands with her new doll

THE PERFECT PRESENT - A great addition to your keepsake doll collection, perfect for a birthday gift, Christmas present, fun for everyday play or any occasion

Making Believe on Amazon: A Comprehensive Review

As an online shopper, it's crucial to make informed decisions. This review will focus on Making Believe, a brand that has made its presence felt on Amazon. With its wide range of products in Kitchen & Dining Features, Making Believe has become a go-to for many shoppers.

Product Range

Making Believe offers a vast product count of 36 items. This diverse selection caters to a wide array of needs and preferences, making it a versatile brand for consumers.

Quality and Pricing

Quality is a defining factor for any brand. Based on customer feedback and ratings, Making Believe's products have an average rating of 6.4 out of 10, indicating a high level of customer satisfaction.

When it comes to pricing, Making Believe has products ranging from a minimum price of $5.99 to a maximum of $55.99, with an average price of $18.33. This pricing structure caters to a wide range of budgets, making Making Believe an accessible choice for many shoppers.

Customer Service

Customer service is the backbone of any successful online brand. Making Believe is sold by making believe, who are known for their commitment to customer satisfaction. They have been responsive and helpful, according to customer reviews and feedback.

Shopping Experience

The shopping experience on Amazon with Making Believe has been largely positive. The brand's wide range of products, combined with the ease of navigation on Amazon, has made shopping a breeze for many customers.

Delivery and Packaging

Delivery and packaging are yet another aspect where Making Believe shines. Items are delivered in a timely manner and the packaging ensures the products reach the customers in pristine condition.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Making Believe offers a wide range of quality products at varying price points, making it a brand worth considering for your next Amazon purchase. Their commitment to customer service, combined with a seamless shopping experience, makes Making Believe stand out in the crowded Amazon marketplace.

Overall Rating

Based on the analysis of product range, quality, pricing, customer service, shopping experience, and delivery, we rate Making Believe [6.4 out of 10 stars].