Best Plastic Baking Dishes in 2026

Daisy
Last Updated: Feb 13, 2026

At a Glance: Our Top Picks for Plastic Baking Dishes

DOWAN Ceramic Butter Dish, Extra Large Butter Keeper for Countertop or Fridge, Airtight Butter Container with Wooden Lid, Farmhouse Kitchen Decor and Accessories, Freezer Safe, White
#TOP1
Dowan Ceramic Butter Dish, Extra Large Butter Keeper
9.8
PM SCORE
DOWAN Porcelain Butter Dish, Extra Large Butter Dish with Cover, Airtight Butter Dish with Wooden Lid, Farmhouse Butter Container for East West Coast Butter, Freezer Safe, Grey
#TOP2
Dowan Porcelain Butter Dish, Extra Large Butter Dish
9.8
PM SCORE
Talisman Designs Laser Etched Vivid Beechwood & Stoneware Butter Dish with Lid Butter Me Up Solid Wooden Lid Butter Holder Fun & Functional Kitchen Supplies
#TOP3
Talisman Designs Laser Etched Vivid Beechwood & Stoneware
9.7
PM SCORE

* PickSmartly editors independently research, review, and endorse the top products through comprehensive data analysis. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through our product links.

Summary of the Best Plastic Baking Dishes of 2026

Dowan Ceramic Butter Dish, Extra Large Butter Keeper For Countertop Or Fridge, Airtight Butter Container With Wooden Lid, Farmhouse Kitchen Decor And Accessories, Freezer Safe, White

DOWAN
6.40 X 4.10 X 3.30 inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Wide Butter Container: Our butter dish measures 6.4 x 4.1 x 3.3 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover works perfectly for both West and East/European coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Unique Circle Design with Upgraded Seal: The DOWAN butter dish features unique circle pattern, which is a sleek and really pretty addition to your countertop and kitchen. The top lid with upgraded seal helps keep your butter sticks or margarine fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors. You can easily take off the ring seal for better clean.

Durable Porcelain and Wood: This butter container is made of durable porcelain and wood, lead-free, chip-resistant and more sturdy. It is also more beautiful and safer than plastic or glass butter dish. Tips: The wooden lid can be used as a small cutting board for slicing, which is convenient and practical.

Practical and Functional: It is not just a butter container, for kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Warm Tips: DOWAN butter dish is carefully packed in the box. The butter container can be easily cleaned with hot water and soap. You can also clean the butter dish without the lid in the dishwasher. The wooden lid can only be washed by hand and kept dry after cleaning to avoid mildew.

Dowan Porcelain Butter Dish, Extra Large Butter Dish With Cover, Airtight Butter Dish With Wooden Lid, Farmhouse Butter Container For East West Coast Butter, Freezer Safe, Grey

DOWAN
6.40 X 4.10 X 3.30 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Wide Butter Container: Our butter dish measures 6.4 x 4.1 x 3.3 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Unique Circle Design with Upgraded Seal: The DOWAN butter dish features unique circle pattern, which is a sleek and really pretty addition to your countertop and kitchen. The top lid with upgraded seal helps keep your butter sticks or margarine FRESH in the refrigerator WITHOUT mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors. You can easily take off the ring seal for better clean.

Durable Porcelain and Wood: This butter container is made of durable porcelain and wood, LEAD-FREE, chip-resistant and more sturdy. It is also more beautiful and safer than plastic or glass butter dish. TIPS: The wooden lid can be used as a small cutting board for slicing, which is convenient and practical.

Practical and Functional: It is not just a butter container, for kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

We Want You Happy With Us: Since we regard the product as the return of your hard-earned money, we strive to improve our quality and packaging quality to ensure that each product is delivered to you safely.

Talisman Designs Laser Etched Vivid Beechwood & Stoneware Butter Dish With Lid Butter Me Up Solid Wooden Lid Butter Holder Fun & Functional Kitchen Supplies

TALISMAN DESIGNS
6010
6.50 X 3.00 X 2.00 Inches
0.88 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68

Features

WOODEN & STONEWARE BUTTER DISH: Use this Talisman Designs’ butter dish with lid for countertop to keep your butter properly stored and your kitchen clean

BLENDS INTO KITCHEN DECOR: This farmhouse butter dish sits atop your tabletop and kitchen counter to keep your margarine at room temperature It’s simple design effortlessly blends into your home decor

ATTRACTIVE LASER ETCHED DESIGN: The loose lid of this butter container is laser etched with the phrase “Butter Me Up” for a fun and lighthearted style that adds a cute touch during meals

LOOSE NATURAL WOOD LID: Crafted from durable beechwood and stoneware materials, the wooden lid is made to stay loose and lightweight for easy removal when baking or adding butter to your bread

EASY TO CLEAN BUTTER HOLDER: Whether toast needs butter, or your recipe calls for margarine, this butter container for counter will be in easy reach and ready to use

Dowan Porcelain Butter Dish, Covered Butter Container With Wooden Lid For Countertop, Airtight Butter Keeper With Covers For East West Coast Butter, White

DOWAN
6.70 X 2.80 X 2.70 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Dowan Dinnerware 9.78

Features

Deep and Slim Design - Our covered butter dish measures 6.7 x 2.7 x 2.8 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Healthy Porcelain Material - Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won't worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body. It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The white butter dish with lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the large butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

#TOP5

Avla 2 Pack Porcelain Baking Dish, Square 9X9 Inch Brownie Dish Lasagna Pan Roasted Meat Bakeware Set For Kitchen, 62 Oz Casserole Dish With Double Handle, Vintage Red

AVLA
A-BAKINGDISHWITHHANDLE-SC-VRED-2P
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
avla 9.94

Features

Perfect Size for Various Food: AVLA set of 2 baking dish with the dimension of: 9" in diameter ( without handle ) x 3" in height, capacity: approx 62 oz ( Normal Capacity ). Perfect for brownie cake, fruit cake, Lasagna, chicken baking and more, as serving dish to serve breakfast salad and dinner.

Healthy and Durable Ceramic: AVLA square baking dishes are made of top grade eco-friendly porcelain, 100% BPA free, non-toxic, and odorless. Better than plastics or wood, porcelain dish won't absorb odor or bacteria, not be scratch easily, safe for long time use. Safe for you and your family.

Microwave Safe and Easy to Clean: Nonstick and smooth glaze resists sticking or flaking, easy to clean with dishwasher or hand wash with soap and water. It' s oven, microwave, refrigerator and dishwasher safe. Note: don' t put them straight into the oven after taking out of the freezer, you should wait for at least 30 minutes, cause ceramics can't hold up sudden changes in temperature.

Classic and Stylish Design: Designed with special anti-slip lines on double handles, the square baking pan is easier to hold or carry from oven to countertop or from kitchen to dining table. Durable and scratch-resistant, the height and thickness of the sidewalls makes crusts bake evenly.

An Impressive Gift Choice: The AVLA square baking dish features unique texture design for enjoyable baking time. A good choice to send it to your family or friends, suitable as gift for birthday, holiday, housewarming, or Valentine' s Day gifts.

Dowan Bundle-White Butter Dish And Airy Blue Butter Dish

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Dowan Dinnerware 9.79

Features

Deep and Wide Butter Container: Our butter dish measures 6.4 x 4.1 x 3.3 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Unique Circle Design with Upgraded Seal: The DOWAN butter dish features unique circle pattern, which is a sleek and really pretty addition to your countertop and kitchen. The top lid with upgraded seal helps keep your butter sticks or margarine FRESH in the refrigerator WITHOUT mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors. You can easily take off the ring seal for better clean.

Durable Porcelain and Wood: This butter container is made of durable porcelain and wood, LEAD-FREE, chip-resistant and more sturdy. It is also more beautiful and safer than plastic or glass butter dish. TIPS: The wooden lid can be used as a small cutting board for slicing, which is convenient and practical.

Practical and Functional: It is not just a butter container, for kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

We Want You Happy With Us: Since we regard the product as the return of your hard-earned money, we strive to improve our quality and packaging quality to ensure that each product is delivered to you safely.

Casafina Ceramic 16" X 10.25" Rectangular Baker With Cork Tray - Ensemble Collection, White | Oven & Dishwasher Safe Bakeware | Food Safe Glazing | Restaurant Quality Dinnerware

CASAFINA
DR391-043
16.00 X 10.25 X 3.50 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Alrossa 9.93

Features

STONEWARE BAKING DISH - Coated with a reactive glaze, this bakeware is safe to use in the microwave and dishwasher, but hand washing is advised for those larger and more delicate pieces

ELEGANT TABLEWARE - The white baking dish measures 16'' x 10.25'' and 3.5'' deep all while being scratch resistant with wonderful workmanship and great color

NATURALLY MADE - Each piece of bakeware is made from the best natural resources in Portugal and is created through a single firing system to create a special bond between the clay and glazed surface

ENSEMBLE COLLECTION - Simple and modern, this collection fuses elements of great design and sustainable accessories like Portuguese cork and oak wood to create a must-have oven-to-table collection for the contemporary home

CASAFINA - Created in 1981, these high-quality sustainable products are designed with a focus on service and standards while adhering to stringent design standards creating unique, timelessly classic and trendy collections

Dowan Bundle-Butter Dish

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Slim Design - Our covered butter dish measures 6.7 x 2.7 x 2.8 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Healthy Porcelain Material - Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won't worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body. It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The white butter dish with lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the large butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

Dowan Bundle-Butter Dish And Butter Crock

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Slim Design - Our covered butter dish measures 6.7 x 2.7 x 2.8 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Deep and Slim Design - Our covered butter dish measures 6.7 x 2.7 x 2.8 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The white butter dish with lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the large butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

Dowan 6.5" Large Butter Dish (White & Grey)

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Wide Design - Our large butter dish measures 6.5"x 4"x 3.1" which is wide and deep enough to fit a wide range of shaped sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover works perfectly for 2 sticks of East Coast butter or 1 cube of West Coast/European butter.

Healthy Porcelain Material: Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won’t worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body.It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The butter dish with a lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

Dowan 6.5" Large Butter Dish - Brown & White

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Wide Design - Our large butter dish measures 6.5"x 4"x 3.1" which is wide and deep enough to fit a wide range of shaped sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover works perfectly for 2 sticks of East Coast butter or 1 cube of West Coast/European butter.

Healthy Porcelain Material: Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won’t worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body.It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The butter dish with a lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

Dowan Large Butter Dish Haze Blue & White Extra Large Butter Dish

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Wide Design - Our large butter dish measures 6.5"x 4"x 3.1" which is wide and deep enough to fit a wide range of shaped sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover works perfectly for 2 sticks of East Coast butter or 1 cube of West Coast/European butter.

Healthy Porcelain Material: Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won’t worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body.It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The butter dish with a lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

Dowan 6.5" Large Butter Dish Brown & White Farmhouse Butter Keeper

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DOWANHOME 9.84

Features

Deep and Wide Design - Our large butter dish measures 6.5"x 4"x 3.1" which is wide and deep enough to fit a wide range of shaped sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover works perfectly for 2 sticks of East Coast butter or 1 cube of West Coast/European butter.

Healthy Porcelain Material: Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won’t worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body.It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the covered butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The butter dish with a lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Warm Tips - When you seal the lid, please adjust the silicone ring in the right place, especially two layers of the ring, one layer should be up, the other one should be down. In this way, the lid will not pop up again.

Dowan Bundle-Dowan Porcelain Butter Dish With Wooden Lid For Countertop

DOWAN
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING

Features

Deep and Slim Design - Our covered butter dish measures 6.7 x 2.7 x 2.8 inches, which is wide and deep enough to hold two sticks of butter. The butter dish with cover Works perfectly for both WEST and EAST/EUROPEAN coast butter, suitable for most brands like Kerrygold, Land O'Lakes, Plugra Butter and more.

Healthy Porcelain Material - Unlike plastic materials, ceramic butter dishes have no harmful plastics, cadmium or Lead. Chemical free so you won't worry about BPA or harmful substance getting into your body. It's as safe for your family as it is for the environment.

Upgraded Wood Lid - The white butter dish with lid helps keep your butter fresh in the refrigerator without mixing other food taste and will snap closed for odors, you can easily take off the silicone seal ring for better clean or replace.

Not Just a Butter Container - For kitchen storage, you can use the large butter dish to store sugar, salt, spices, seasoning, and cookie jars; if you are a baking lover, you can use it to bake your favorite small cake, potato gratin or other desserts.

Top 10 baking dishes Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by PM.

Brand Count
Dowan 11
Avla 1
Casafina 1
Talisman Designs 1

Top 10 baking dishes Brands Pie Chart


We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 7,901 reviews on baking dishes, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the kitchen & dining. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select baking dishes priced around $33.82, with top brands including m mcirco, pyrex, amazon basics, anchor hocking, simax, mora ceramics hit pause, kook, sweejar and libbey and warome

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 14 baking dishes for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the kitchen & dining category. These include mcirco shop, amazon.com, millvado, bargains to go, mora ceramics, kook, pukka home us, i grace and lovecasa-dinnerware and kitchen accessories and mtk1 products .

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right dishes Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which baking dishes to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.