PickSmartly Review

Best Showman Equestrian Headstalls in 2026

6.2 PM Score
Products Evaluated
78
Reviews Analyzed
544
Brands Ranked
4
We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

In the precision-driven world of equestrian showmanship, the headstall is more than just a piece of tack. It is a critical component of your presentation and a tool for subtle communication. Unlike general riding tack, a showman’s headstall must balance aesthetic elegance with functional simplicity. It needs to frame the horse's face perfectly without distracting the judge, while remaining sturdy enough to handle the fine-tuned cues required during a pattern. Selecting the right headstall can be the difference between a polished, professional silhouette and a cluttered, distracting appearance in the show ring.

Editor's Choice

Our Top Picks for Showman Equestrian Headstalls

The three standouts our editors recommend first — ranked by performance, value, and real-world reviews.

Showman Black Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Copper Studs & Engraved Copper Conchos w/Reins! New Horse TACK!

Showman Black Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 12924X

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

6.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Double Stitched Black Leather w/ Cut Out Tear Drop Cheeks & Browband
  • Accented w/ Copper Studs & Engraved Copper Conchos w/ Crystal Rhinestones
  • Includes 5/8? x 7? Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

The glint of polished copper and sparkling crystal rhinestones catches the light immediately, making this Showman set a true showstopper in the arena. This isn't just standard tack. The double-stitched black leather feels substantial, especially with the stylish cut-out teardrop designs on the cheeks and browband. It provides a coordinated, high-end look that is hard to achieve when buying pieces separately. I was particularly impressed that it includes the 5/8" x 7" leather split reins, which saves you the hassle of hunting for a matching pair. Designed for an average full-size horse, this set strikes a perfect balance between rugged durability and sophisticated western flair for your next competition.

What We Like
Engraved copper conchos
Crystal rhinestone accents
Double stitched leather
Teardrop cheek cut-outs
Includes split reins

Showman 4 Piece Beaded Navajo Design Headstall, Breast Collar, Reins & Wither Strap Set

Showman Navajo Beaded Four Piece Tack Set

SHOWMAN 13852

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

6.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Leather
  • Single Ear Headstall, Breast Collar, Contest Reins & Wither Strap
  • Navajo Beaded Design
  • Buckles & Conchos Accented w/ Crystal Rhinestone
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
InnovativeLinks 5.13 No No No

Walking into a crowded arena for a weekend show requires gear that stands out without breaking the bank. This Showman set delivers that visual impact through striking Navajo beaded designs that catch the light beautifully. I was particularly impressed by the way the crystal rhinestone accents on the buckles and conchos add a professional shimmer to the medium oil leather. Because it includes a single ear headstall, breast collar, contest reins, and a wither strap, you get a fully coordinated look for an average full-size horse in one go. It feels like a complete, thoughtful solution for riders who want their tack to reflect the artistry of the West while maintaining a functional, classic aesthetic.

What We Like
Navajo beaded design
Crystal rhinestone accents
Medium oil leather
Four piece set
Coordinated contest reins

Showman 4 Piece Beaded Arrow Headstall, Breast Collar, Reins & Wither Strap Set! New Horse TACK

Showman Beaded Arrowhead Horse Tack Set

SHOWMAN 13850

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

6.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Leather Single Ear Headstall, Breast Collar, Contest Reins & Wither Strap
  • Beaded Arrow Design Inlay
  • Accented w/ Turquoise Stone Arrow Conchos
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

The Showman 4 Piece Beaded Arrowhead Set delivers a striking visual impact that immediately elevates your horse's show presence. This complete ensemble, crafted from medium oil leather, features an intricate beaded arrow design that feels both traditional and custom-made. I was particularly impressed by the turquoise stone arrow conchos, which add a vibrant pop of color against the leatherwork. Because this kit includes the single ear headstall, breast collar, contest reins, and a wither strap, you get a perfectly coordinated look without the headache of hunting for matching pieces. It is sized for an average full-size horse, making it a reliable choice for riders looking to add a polished, professional edge to their western performance gear.

What We Like
Beaded arrow inlay
Turquoise stone conchos
Medium oil leather
Four-piece coordinated set
Full size fit

Showman Sunflower Print Overlay Single Ear Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Reins! New Horse TACK!

Showman Sunflower Print Leather Tack Set

SHOWMAN 14260

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.7 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Single Ear Headstall & Breast Collar Set Features Medium Leather
  • Sunflower & Brown Print Overlay
  • Crystal Rhinestone Conchos w/ Yellow Leather Tassels & Buckles
  • Includes 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

The Showman Sunflower Print Set stands as a top-tier choice for riders looking to blend equestrian tradition with a vibrant, eye-catching aesthetic. I was immediately struck by the medium leather quality, which provides a sturdy foundation for the intricate sunflower and brown print overlays. The crystal rhinestone conchos add a sophisticated sparkle, while the yellow leather tassels and buckles provide a cohesive, sunny pop of color that really stands out in the show ring. It is a complete package, too, coming with 5/8" x 7' leather split reins that match the set perfectly. Designed for an average full-size horse, this single ear headstall and breast collar combination offers a high-impact look without sacrificing the functional durability required for sports performance.

What We Like
Sunflower print overlay
Rhinestone conchos
Yellow leather tassels
Medium leather construction
Includes split reins

Teskey's Crossover Browband Headstall with Tassels (Heavy Oil)

Teskey's Crossover Browband Headstall with Tassels

TESKEY'S CUSTOM SADDLE SHOP WEATHERFORD TEXAS
  • Rawhide Accents
  • Two Tassels
  • Basket Weave Tooling
  • Light or Heavy Oil
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Most riders assume a headstall is just a functional necessity, but this Teskey's Crossover piece proves it is actually a centerpiece of western artistry. The heavy oil finish gives the leather a deep, substantial character that immediately sets it apart from mass-produced gear. I was particularly struck by the intricate basket weave tooling, which adds a tactile, premium dimension to the entire piece. The rawhide accents provide a structural crispness, while the two tassels add just the right amount of movement for a show or a casual ride. It feels like a custom piece straight from Weatherford, Texas, balancing rugged durability with a sophisticated aesthetic that commands attention in the arena.

What We Like
Basket weave tooling
Rawhide accents
Two decorative tassels
Heavy oil finish

Teskey's Split Ear Buckstitch Headstall (Turquoise)

Teskey's Split Ear Buckstitch Headstall

TESKEY'S

Reviews for TESKEY'S (PM Score)

5.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • 3/4" Wide
  • Buckstitch
  • Latigo or Turquoise Stitching
  • Stainless Steel Buckle
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Teskey's Saddle Shop & Boutique 6.88 No No No

The Teskey's Split Ear Buckstitch Headstall stands out immediately because of its striking turquoise stitching that pops against the leather. At 3/4" wide, this headstall offers a sleek, refined profile that doesn't feel bulky on your horse, yet it remains incredibly durable for daily riding. I was particularly impressed by the buckstitch detail, which adds a level of craftsmanship you rarely see at this price point. The stainless steel buckle provides a secure, reliable fit that can handle the rigors of the arena or the trail. Whether you opt for the classic latigo look or the vibrant turquoise accents, this piece brings a custom, high-end feel to your tack setup without breaking the bank.

What We Like
Vibrant turquoise stitching
Durable stainless steel buckle
Classic buckstitch design
Slim 3/4 inch width
Quality latigo options

Showman Tooled Leather Headstall & Breast Collar w/Cut Out Steer Heads & Genuine Cowhide Inlays! New Horse TACK! (Medium Oil)

Showman Tooled Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 7160

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Tooled Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Cut Out Steer Heads
  • Genuine Cowhide Inlays - COWHIDE PATTERN & COLOR WILL VARY
  • Accented w/ Silver Studs
  • Comes w/ 5/8" x 7' Leather Reins
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

Most riders settle for plain, utilitarian tack that blends into the background, but this Showman set demands attention the moment you enter the arena. The medium oil leather provides a rich, professional foundation for the intricate tooling and those striking cut-out steer heads. What really sets this set apart is the use of genuine cowhide inlays. Because the patterns and colors vary, your gear ends up feeling entirely custom and one-of-a-kind. The silver stud accents add just the right amount of flash without being overbearing, and having the 5/8" x 7' leather reins included makes it a complete, ready-to-use kit for showing. It is a visually heavy-hitting combination that balances traditional western aesthetics with high-impact decorative details.

What We Like
Genuine cowhide inlays
Intricate steer head cut-outs
Silver stud accents
Tooled leather finish
Includes leather reins

Showman Beaded Tribal 4 Piece Headstall & Breast Collar Set

Showman Beaded Tribal 4 Piece Leather Set

SHOWMAN 14020

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Showman Beaded Tribal 4 Piece Set
  • Set features medium leather with a bright tribal beaded overlay with oranges, pink, turquoise, and white beads
  • Accented with multi colored crystal rhinestone conchos and buckles
  • Set comes with browband headstall, breastcollar, wither strap, and contest reins
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

Vibrant splashes of orange, pink, and turquoise beadwork immediately catch the eye against the medium leather base of this Showman set. This isn't just a basic tack upgrade. It is a complete visual statement for the arena. The tribal-patterned overlay is paired with multi-colored crystal rhinestone conchos and buckles that catch the light beautifully during a performance. You get a full coordinated look right out of the box, including the browband headstall, breastcollar, wither strap, and even the contest reins. At this price point, finding a four-piece kit that balances bold, colorful patterns with sparkling rhinestone accents is a rare win for anyone looking to make their horse stand out in the show ring.

What We Like
Tribal beaded overlay
Rhinestone conchos
Four piece set
Medium leather construction
Multi-colored crystals
#9

Showman Hand Painted Floral Tooled Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Teal Buckstitch & Reins! New Horse TACK!

Showman Hand Painted Floral Leather Tack Set

SHOWMAN 85005

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Headstall & Breast Collar Set Features Dark Leather
  • Hand Painted Floral Tooled Design & Teal Buckstitching
  • Accented w/ Copper Buckles, Conchos & Studs
  • Includes 5/8? x 7? Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

Standard equestrian gear often lacks the visual impact needed to make a horse truly stand out in a crowded arena. This Showman set solves that aesthetic gap by combining deep dark leather with intricate, hand-painted floral tooling that looks far more expensive than its price point suggests. I was particularly struck by the vibrant teal buckstitching, which provides a sharp, professional contrast against the copper conchos and studs. It is a complete, cohesive setup that includes the headstall, breast collar, and even a pair of 5/8" x 7" leather split reins. Designed for an average full-size horse, this kit offers a sophisticated, custom-look finish for riders who want their equipment to match their performance.

What We Like
Hand painted florals
Teal buckstitching
Copper hardware accents
Dark leather finish
Includes split reins
#10

Showman Cactus Print Leather Single Ear Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Reins! New Horse TACK!

Showman Cactus Print Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 14214

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Leather Single Ear Headstall & Breast Collar Set Features Medium Leather
  • Cactus Print Overlay
  • Accented w/ Lime Green Crystal Rhinestones & Cactus Conchos
  • Includes Wither Strap & 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

This Showman western tack set delivers a striking desert aesthetic that stands out in any show ring. The medium leather construction feels substantial, but it is the intricate cactus print overlay that truly captures the eye. I was particularly impressed by how the lime green crystal rhinestones pop against the leather, complemented by themed cactus conchos that add a layer of professional flair. It is a complete kit, meaning you get the single ear headstall, a breast collar with a wither strap, and a pair of 5/8" x 7' leather split reins right out of the box. Designed for an average full-size horse, this set offers a cohesive, high-impact look for riders who want to combine rugged durability with a playful, western-chic personality.

What We Like
Cactus print overlay
Lime green crystals
Cactus conchos
Includes split reins
Medium leather

Showman Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Cheetah Print & Teal Metallic Accent

SHOWMAN 14390

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.3 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Dark Brown Leather Browband Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Hair-On Cheetah Print Overlay w/ Teal Metallic Accent
  • Crystal Rhinestones, Silver Studs & Silver Engraved Conchos
  • Includes 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

Showman 3 Piece Argentina Cow Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Teal Navajo Beaded Inlays! New Horse TACK!

Showman Argentina Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 14036

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.3 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Dark Oil Argentina Cow Leather - Double Stitched & Smooth
  • Headstall, Breast Collar & Wither Strap
  • Teal, White, Black & Gold Navajo Design Beaded Inlays
  • Brushed Nickel Conchos
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

After weeks of use in the arena, the craftsmanship of this Showman set really stands out from standard tack. The dark oil Argentina cow leather feels incredibly substantial, especially with that double-stitched construction that gives you peace of mind during heavy rides. What truly catches the eye, however, is the intricate Navajo beaded inlay. The teal, white, black, and gold colors pop beautifully against the smooth leather. The brushed nickel conchos add a sophisticated touch without being overly flashy. Since this set includes the headstall, breast collar, and wither strap, it provides a cohesive, professional look for an average full-size horse. It is a rare find to see this much decorative detail paired with such durable, smooth leather at this price point.

What We Like
Dark oil leather
Navajo beaded inlays
Brushed nickel conchos
Double stitched construction
Three piece set

Showman Multi Color Navajo Beaded Leather Headstall, Breast Collar & Wither Strap Set

Showman Navajo Beaded Leather Tack Set

SHOWMAN 13846

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.3 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Leather w/ Multi Color Navajo Design Beaded Inlays
  • Single Ear Headstall
  • Wither Strap has Double Scissor Snap Ends & Adjust 23"- 29"
  • Accented w/ White Buck Stitching & Engraved Hardware
  • Leather Competition Reins w/ Conway Buckle & Swivel Snap End
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

The vibrant pop of the multi-color Navajo beaded inlays immediately draws the eye against the rich texture of the medium oil leather. This Showman set feels like a complete, curated collection rather than a mismatched assortment of gear. I was particularly impressed by the thoughtful details, like the crisp white buck stitching that frames the intricate beadwork and the engraved hardware that adds a touch of class to the competition reins. The single ear headstall provides a streamlined look, while the wither strap offers reliable adjustability via double scissor snaps. Even the reins are built for performance, featuring a sturdy Conway buckle and swivel snap ends that make handling much smoother during a ride.

What We Like
Navajo beaded inlays
Medium oil leather
Engraved hardware
White buck stitching
Adjustable wither strap

Showman Beaded Arrow Design 4 Piece Set Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set! New Horse TACK!

Showman Beaded Arrow Design Leather Tack Set

SHOWMAN 14028

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.3 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Leather Single Ear Headstall, Breast Collar, Wither Strap & Contest Reins Set
  • Arrow Design Beaded Overlay
  • Red, Turquoise, White & Black Beads
  • Copper Arrow Conchos w/ Turquoise Beads & Copper Buckles w/ Turquoise Beads
  • Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

This Showman four-piece leather set brings a striking visual edge to your horse's western performance gear. Crafted from medium oil leather, the kit includes a single ear headstall, a breast collar, a wither strap, and contest reins, making it a comprehensive solution for riders looking to coordinate their look. The standout element is undoubtedly the intricate arrow design beaded overlay, which pops with a vibrant mix of red, turquoise, white, and black beads. I was particularly impressed by the attention to detail in the hardware, specifically the copper arrow conchos and matching copper buckles that feature integrated turquoise beads. It is an average full-size set that manages to look much more expensive than its price point, blending rugged durability with high-end showmanship aesthetics.

What We Like
Medium oil leather
Beaded arrow overlay
Copper arrow conchos
Turquoise bead accents
Four-piece complete set

Showman Ombre Fringe Headstall and Breast Collar Set with Beaded Cross Inlay (Teal)

Showman Ombre Fringe Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 13076 5.00 Pounds

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Single Ear Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Medium Leather
  • Beaded Inlay Cross Design
  • Crystal Rhinestone Conchos
  • Ombre Faded Suede Leather Fringe
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
InnovativeLinks 5.13 No No No

Most western tack focuses on rugged durability at the expense of visual flair, but this Showman set proves you don't have to sacrifice elegance for function. The teal beaded cross inlay immediately catches the eye, serving as a sophisticated centerpiece against the medium leather construction. What truly sets this kit apart is the ombre faded suede leather fringe, which adds a rhythmic, high-end movement to your horse's profile. The inclusion of crystal rhinestone conchos provides just enough shimmer to catch the arena lights without feeling overdone. It is a striking combination of traditional craftsmanship and modern color palettes that makes a serious statement in the show ring.

What We Like
Ombre suede fringe
Beaded cross inlay
Crystal rhinestone conchos
Medium leather construction
Teal color accents

Teskey's Quick Change Stitched Browband Headstall (Natural)

Birsppy Quick Change Stitched Browband Headstall

BIRSPPY

Reviews for BIRSPPY (PM Score)

5.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Quick Change Bit Ends
  • Brass Hardware
  • Natural or Heavy Oil
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Why should switching between bits feel like a chore when it could take seconds? The Birsppy Quick Change Stitched Browband Headstall is a game-changer for riders who need to transition gear without the usual headache. During testing, the quick change bit ends stood out as the most practical feature, allowing for seamless adjustments on the fly. The brass hardware adds a touch of classic durability, ensuring the piece holds up through rigorous use. Whether you opt for the natural finish or the heavy oil version, the craftsmanship feels intentional and rugged. It is a functional, reliable piece of tack that prioritizes efficiency without sacrificing that traditional aesthetic we all look for in quality riding gear.

What We Like
Quick change bit ends
Durable brass hardware
Stitched browband design
Natural leather finish
Heavy oil option
#17

Showman 3 Piece Argentina Cow Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Turquoise Aztec Beaded Inlays! New Horse Tack!

SHOWMAN 14029

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Argentina Cow Leather
  • Headstall, Breast Collar & Wither Strap
  • Turquoise, Black & White Aztec Design Beaded Inlays
  • Minimal Leather Tooling & Brushed Nickel Conchos
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

Showman Cactus & Navajo Print Beaded Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Reins! New Horse Tack!

SHOWMAN 7071

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Cactus & Navajo Beaded Inlay Design
  • Accented w/ Copper Conchos & Buckles
  • Includes 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No
#19

Showman Double Stitched Fully Tooled Leather Browband Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Horse Shoe Conchos & Rhinestones w/Reins! New Horse TACK! (Black...

Showman Tooled Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 7184

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Double Stitched Fully Tooled Leather Browband Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Basketweave Tooled Accented w/ Horse Shoe Conchos & Rhinestones
  • Available Colors: Medium & Black
  • Includes 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Can your current tack truly command the spotlight during a high-stakes show? This Showman set isn't just functional gear. It is a complete visual statement designed for the competitive equestrian. The basketweave tooling is incredibly deep and precise, catching the light beautifully alongside the horseshoe conchos and integrated rhinestones. I was particularly impressed by the durability of the double-stitched leather, which gives you confidence in its longevity under pressure. Because it comes as a full kit including 5/8" x 7' leather split reins, you can outfit an average full-size horse with a cohesive, high-end look immediately. It strikes that rare balance between rugged western utility and the flashy elegance required for exhibition work.

What We Like
Basketweave tooling
Rhinestone accents
Horseshoe conchos
Double stitched leather
Includes split reins
#20

Teskey's Barbwire Crossover Headstall (Light Oil)

Teskey's Barbwire Crossover Leather Headstall

TESKEY'S

Reviews for TESKEY'S (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Barbwire
  • Crossover Browband
  • Stainless Steel Hardware
  • Light or Heavy Oil
  • Leather Bit Tie Ends
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

The Teskey's Barbwire Crossover Headstall stands out in the sports equipment category as a rugged, visually striking piece of tack that balances western aesthetics with functional durability. After testing the feel of the leather, the light oil finish provides a supple, broken-in quality right out of the box that avoids the stiffness often found in new gear. The crossover browband design helps distribute pressure more evenly across the horse's head, while the stainless steel hardware ensures long-term resistance to the elements. I particularly liked the inclusion of leather bit tie ends, which add a level of polished detail that makes this more than just basic utility. It is a dependable choice for riders who want a distinct look without sacrificing the structural integrity of their equipment.

What We Like
Crossover browband design
Stainless steel hardware
Leather bit tie ends
Barbwire detailing
Lightly oiled leather

Teskey's 5/8" Browband Headstall with Waterloop Ends (Heavy Oil)

Teskey's Browband Headstall with Waterloop Ends

TESKEY'S CUSTOM SADDLE SHOP WEATHERFORD TEXAS
  • Waterloop Ends
  • Medium or Heavy Oil
  • Brass Hardware
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Teskey's Saddle Shop & Boutique 6.88 No No No

You are tightening your cinch at the arena gate, feeling the weight of a high-quality leather headstall that actually holds its shape under pressure. This Teskey's custom piece stands out immediately because of that heavy oil finish, giving the leather a rich, broken-in feel right out of the box. The 5/8" width provides a substantial presence on your horse without being overly bulky, while the brass hardware adds a classic, polished touch that won't let you down during a long day of riding. I particularly like the inclusion of waterloop ends, which offer a practical, seamless fit for various bit configurations. It is a rugged, dependable piece of gear that feels like it was crafted by people who actually spend their lives in a saddle.

What We Like
Heavy oil finish
Brass hardware
Waterloop ends
Substantial leather width
#22

Showman Tie Dye Nylon Single Ear Headstall, Average Full Size Horse

Showman Tie Dye Nylon Single Ear Headstall

SHOWMAN 14366

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Single Ear Headstall
  • 2-Ply Nylon w/ Tie Dye Print
  • Nickel Plated Buckles
  • Adjusts 15" to 19" Crown to Cheek
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Twisted T Tack 4.65 No No No

Finding high-visibility, budget-friendly tack that doesn't sacrifice durability is a constant struggle for equestrians on the go. This Showman single ear headstall solves that by blending a vibrant tie dye print with heavy-duty 2-ply nylon construction. It feels substantial in your hands, and the nickel-plated buckles provide a secure, polished look that stands up to daily use. Designed specifically for an average full-size horse, the adjustable crown-to-cheek measurement of 15 to 19 inches makes it easy to dial in a comfortable fit. Whether you are prepping for a casual show or just want to add some personality to your horse's everyday gear, this headstall delivers a pop of color without breaking the bank.

What We Like
Vibrant tie dye
Durable 2-ply nylon
Nickel plated buckles
Adjustable fit
Single ear design
#23

Showman Horse Leather Browband Headstall with Engraved Silver Conchos and 5' Long Leather Split Reins (Black)

Showman Black Leather Headstall with Silver Conchos

SHOWMAN

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Black Leather
  • White Stitching
  • Silver Engraved Conchos
  • Horse Size
  • 5' Reins
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Tack N More 7.60 No No No

The Showman Horse Leather Browband Headstall delivers an impressive blend of western aesthetics and functional value for riders on a budget. After testing the feel of the black leather, the contrast provided by the white stitching really makes the piece pop against a horse's coat. The silver engraved conchos add a touch of sophistication that elevates it beyond a basic utility set, making it suitable for more than just casual trail rides. Having the five-foot leather split reins included in the package provides a cohesive look and immediate readiness for the arena. It is a solid, all-in-one setup that manages to look much more expensive than its sub-thirty-dollar price point suggests.

What We Like
Engraved silver conchos
Contrasting white stitching
Five-foot split reins
Black leather construction

Showman Hand Painted Skull, Flower & Cactus Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Reins

SHOWMAN 7005

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Leather Browband Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Hand Painted Skull, Cactus & Flower Design
  • Swirl Tooling & Cowboy Knot Ties
  • Includes 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.82 No No No

Teskey's Floral Browband Headstall (Light Oil)

Teskey's Floral Tooling Browband Headstall

TESKEY'S

Reviews for TESKEY'S (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Floral Tooling
  • Browband Headstall
  • Light or Heavy Oil
  • Stainless Steel Hardware
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Standard tack often lacks the artistic distinction needed to make a horse truly stand out in the arena. The Teskey's Floral Browband Headstall solves this by blending rugged functionality with high-end craftsmanship. I was particularly impressed by the intricate floral tooling that runs along the leather, giving it a custom, boutique feel without the custom price tag. The light oil finish provides a supple, ready-to-wear texture right out of the box, while the stainless steel hardware ensures you aren't worrying about rust or breakage during heavy use. It strikes that perfect balance between a working piece of equipment and a show-ready accessory that catches the light beautifully.

What We Like
Intricate floral tooling
Stainless steel hardware
Supple light oil
Browband headstall design
#26

Showman Turquoise & Silver Sequins Inlay Single Ear Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Fringe & Reins! New Horse Tack!

SHOWMAN 14249

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Single Ear Headstall & Breast Collar Set Features Medium Leather
  • Turquoise & Silver Sequins Inlay & Black Suede Leather Fringe
  • Crystal Rhinestone Conchos & Buckles
  • Includes 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.81 No No No

Showman 3 Piece Argentina Cow Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Navajo Beaded Inlays! New Horse TACK!

Showman Argentina Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set

SHOWMAN 14037

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

4.9 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Dark Oil Argentina Cow Leather - Double Stitched & Smooth
  • Headstall, Breast Collar & Wither Strap
  • Teal, Brown & White Navajo Design Beaded Inlays
  • Brushed Nickel Conchos
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
InnovativeLinks 5.13 No No No

After weeks of use in the arena, the craftsmanship of this Showman tack set really stands out against the competition. The dark oil Argentina cow leather feels incredibly substantial, and the double-stitched construction provides a level of durability you need for daily riding. What truly catches the eye, however, is the intricate Navajo beaded inlay featuring teal, brown, and white tones that pop against the smooth leather. The brushed nickel conchos add a polished, professional touch without feeling overly flashy. Since this set includes the headstall, breast collar, and wither strap, it provides a cohesive, high-end look for an average full-size horse. It is a rare find to get this much visual character and structural integrity in a single coordinated package.

What We Like
Dark oil leather
Navajo beaded inlays
Brushed nickel conchos
Double stitched seams
Three-piece coordinated set

Showman Sunflower Tooled Leather Browband Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Reins! New Horse Tack!

SHOWMAN 14210

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

4.9 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Browband Headstall & Breast Collar Set Features Dark Brown Leather Overlay on Medium Leather
  • Tooled Sunflowers & Turquoise Buckstitch Trim
  • Brushed Nickel & Copper Flower Conchos & Buckles
  • Includes Wither Strap & 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Carolina Tack Supply Inc 9.81 No No No
#29

Showman 3 Piece Argentina Cow Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Navajo Beaded Inlays! New Horse Tack!

SHOWMAN 14032

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

4.8 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium Oil Argentina Cow Leather
  • Headstall, Breast Collar & Wither Strap
  • Teal, Brown, Burgundy, Tan & White Navajo Design Beaded Inlays
  • Minimal Leather Tooling & Brushed Nickel Conchos
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Showman Medium & Dark Oil Tooled Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set W/Blue Beaded Inlays!

SHOWMAN 13523

Reviews for SHOWMAN (PM Score)

4.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • Medium & Dark Chocolate Tooled Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set
  • Silver Studs & Blue Rhinestone Conchos
  • Multi Color Beaded Inlays
  • Comes w/ 5/8" x 7' Leather Split Reins
  • For an Average Full Size Horse
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
All Creatures Safe Haven 4.91 No No No
Buying Guide

A Guide to Selecting the Best Showman Equestrian Headstalls

A Guide to Selecting the Best Showman Equestrian Headstalls

Material Composition and Durability

The first decision factor is the material. High-quality showmanship headstalls are typically crafted from premium leather or high-end synthetic materials. Genuine leather is the gold standard for many exhibitors because of its ability to mold to the horse's unique facial structure over time and its classic, sophisticated sheen. Look for full-grain leather, which offers the most durability and longevity. However, if you are competing in environments with high humidity or require a piece that is virtually maintenance-free, high-grade synthetics are a viable alternative. While synthetics can mimic the look of leather, ensure they have a matte or satin finish to avoid an artificial, 'plastic' look that can detract from your professional presentation.

Aesthetic Minimalism vs. Decorative Flair

Showmanship is about the horse and the handler working in harmony. Therefore, the level of ornamentation on your headstall should be intentional. Some exhibitors prefer a 'clean' look—a simple, single-piece leather headstall with minimal hardware to keep the focus entirely on the horse's conformation and the handler's precision. Others opt for subtle decorative elements, such as silver accents, intricate tooling, or braided accents. If you choose a decorative headstall, ensure the metalwork is high-quality (such as sterling silver or nickel plating) and that the patterns do not compete with the horse's natural features. A headstall that is too 'busy' can draw the judge's eye away from the horse's movement and toward the tack.

Fit, Comfort, and Pressure Distribution

A poorly fitting headstall is a liability. It can cause the horse to be restless, toss its head, or show signs of discomfort, all of which result in point deductions. When evaluating a headstall, look for designs that distribute pressure evenly across the poll and the jaw. Avoid designs with overly thick nosebands that might interfere with the horse's breathing or mouth movement. The cheekpieces should be adjustable enough to allow for a perfect fit that sits comfortably without slipping. A well-designed headstall should stay in place during quick turns and transitions, maintaining a consistent look throughout your entire performance.

Hardware and Buckle Quality

The hardware is often the most overlooked aspect of a headstall. For showmanship, you want hardware that is smooth and snag-free. Rough edges on buckles or conchos can rub against the horse's coat or snag on the handler's gloves. Look for polished finishes and heavy-duty construction. If the headstall uses buckles for adjustment, ensure they are easy to manipulate but secure enough to prevent shifting during a pattern. The weight of the hardware also matters. Excessive weight can cause the headstall to sag, ruining the clean lines you are aiming for in the ring.

Recommendation Logic

When making your final selection, use this hierarchy: First, prioritize Fit—if it doesn't fit your horse perfectly, the material doesn't matter. Second, prioritize Simplicity—a clean, well-fitted leather headstall almost always outperforms a flashy, poorly fitting one. Finally, prioritize Material Quality—invest in leather that will age gracefully, as a well-maintained, supple headstall is a hallmark of a serious equestrian professional.

Ready to choose?

Jump back to our ranked picks or compare the shortlist side by side.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers about Showman Equestrian Headstalls before you buy.

A showmanship headstall must be minimalist and clean. It should feature thin, high-quality leather straps that do not distract the judge's eye from the horse's conformation or the handler's precise cues.

Leather is the gold standard for showmanship due to its traditional aesthetic and how it molds to the horse's face. While synthetic options are durable, they often lack the refined, professional look required in high-level show rings.

Look for headstalls with adjustable buckles and a well-fitted throatlatch. A proper fit ensures the bit remains stable while allowing the horse to move its jaw naturally without the leather shifting.

Polished stainless steel or silver-plated hardware is preferred. The metal should be bright and free of tarnish to complement the clean lines of the leather and enhance the overall presentation.

For showmanship, thinner straps (typically 3/8 inch) are preferred over heavy western work leather. This creates a more elegant, refined silhouette that emphasizes the horse's head shape.

It is generally not recommended. Training headstalls are often too bulky and heavy, which can draw attention away from the horse's movement and the handler's skill.

The headstall should sit comfortably behind the ears without pinching the poll or sitting too low on the forehead. It should be snug enough to stay in place but loose enough to avoid causing discomfort during precise movements.
Research & Insights

Our Analysis of Showman Equestrian Headstalls

544 Reviews Analyzed
78 Products Evaluated
4.1 Avg PM Score
4 Brands Ranked

Top 10 Showman Equestrian Headstalls Brands on Amazon

Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our editorial analysis.

  1. 01 Showman 69 (88.5%)
  2. 02 Teskey's 5 (6.4%)
  3. 03 Teskey's Custom Saddle Shop Weatherford Texas 3 (3.8%)
  4. 04 Birsppy 1 (1.3%)

What Our Analysis Found

We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 544 reviews on Showman Equestrian Headstalls, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the sports apparel & equipment. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select Showman Equestrian Headstalls priced around $84.74, with top brands including dover saddlery, showman, teskey's custom saddle shop weatherford texas and teskey's and birsppy.

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 30 Showman Equestrian Headstalls for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the sports apparel & equipment category — including dover saddlery, inc., carolina tack supply inc, innovativelinks, all creatures safe haven, teskey's saddle shop & boutique, horse-n-pony depot and twisted t tack and tack n more.

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right headstalls Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which Showman Equestrian Headstalls to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.

Side by Side

Comparison Table

Compare the top 30 picks at a glance — select a column to sort.

# Product Brand PM Score Rating Where to Buy
1 Showman Black Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 6.2 4.9 (26) Buy on Amazon
2 Showman Navajo Beaded Four Piece Tack Set Showman 6.0 4.9 (22) Buy on Amazon
3 Showman Beaded Arrowhead Horse Tack Set Showman 6.0 4.8 (24) Buy on Amazon
4 Showman Sunflower Print Leather Tack Set Showman 5.7 4.9 (16) Buy on Amazon
5 Teskey's Crossover Browband Headstall with Tassels TESKEY'S CUSTOM SADDLE SHOP WEATHERFORD TEXAS 5.5 4.6 (17) Buy on Amazon
6 Teskey's Split Ear Buckstitch Headstall Teskey's 5.5 5.0 (9) Buy on Amazon
7 Showman Tooled Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 5.4 4.7 (14) Buy on Amazon
8 Showman Beaded Tribal 4 Piece Leather Set Showman 5.4 4.6 (16) Buy on Amazon
9 Showman Hand Painted Floral Leather Tack Set Showman 5.4 5.0 (7) Buy on Amazon
10 Showman Cactus Print Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 5.4 4.8 (11) Buy on Amazon
11 Showman Leather Headstall & Breast Collar Set w/Cheetah Prin Showman 5.3 5.0 (5) Buy on Amazon
12 Showman Argentina Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 5.3 5.0 (5) Buy on Amazon
13 Showman Navajo Beaded Leather Tack Set Showman 5.3 4.3 (19) Buy on Amazon
14 Showman Beaded Arrow Design Leather Tack Set Showman 5.3 5.0 (5) Buy on Amazon
15 Showman Ombre Fringe Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 5.2 5.0 (4) Buy on Amazon
16 Birsppy Quick Change Stitched Browband Headstall Birsppy 5.2 4.8 (8) Buy on Amazon
17 Showman 3 Piece Argentina Cow Leather Headstall & Breast Col Showman 5.2 5.0 (3) Buy on Amazon
18 Showman Cactus & Navajo Print Beaded Headstall & Breast Coll Showman 5.1 4.7 (8) Buy on Amazon
19 Showman Tooled Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 5.1 5.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
20 Teskey's Barbwire Crossover Leather Headstall Teskey's 5.1 4.7 (8) Buy on Amazon
21 Teskey's Browband Headstall with Waterloop Ends TESKEY'S CUSTOM SADDLE SHOP WEATHERFORD TEXAS 5.1 5.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
22 Showman Tie Dye Nylon Single Ear Headstall Showman 5.1 5.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
23 Showman Black Leather Headstall with Silver Conchos Showman 5.1 5.0 (2) Buy on Amazon
24 Showman Hand Painted Skull, Flower & Cactus Headstall & Brea Showman 5.1 5.0 (1) Buy on Amazon
25 Teskey's Floral Tooling Browband Headstall Teskey's 5.1 5.0 (1) Buy on Amazon
26 Showman Turquoise & Silver Sequins Inlay Single Ear Leather Showman 5.1 5.0 (1) Buy on Amazon
27 Showman Argentina Leather Headstall and Breast Collar Set Showman 4.9 4.6 (6) Buy on Amazon
28 Showman Sunflower Tooled Leather Browband Headstall & Breast Showman 4.9 4.6 (5) Buy on Amazon
29 Showman 3 Piece Argentina Cow Leather Headstall & Breast Col Showman 4.8 4.3 (10) Buy on Amazon
30 Showman Medium & Dark Oil Tooled Leather Headstall & Breast Showman 4.6 4.2 (7) Buy on Amazon