PickSmartly Buying Guide

Best American Greetings Party Plates in 2026

9.9 PM Score
Products Compared
42
Brands Ranked
3
Our guides are compiled from product information and customer ratings. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

When planning a celebration, the smallest details often dictate the overall atmosphere and ease of hosting. American Greetings party plates are more than just disposable serving vessels. They are foundational elements of a themed environment. Whether you are hosting a whimsical toddler birthday party, a seasonal holiday gathering, or a sophisticated family brunch, these plates serve as a visual bridge between your decorations and your guest experience. Selecting the right set ensures that your table setting feels cohesive, intentional, and—most importantly—stress-free during the cleanup process.

Editor's Choice

Our Top Picks for American Greetings Party Plates

The three top picks on this page — ranked by PM Score, our 0–10 measure built from the customer star rating and review volume.

American Greetings Friends Party Supplies, Dessert Plates (36-Count)

American Greetings Friends Themed Dessert Plates

AMERICAN GREETINGS 6629989 7.00 X 1.13 X 7.00 Inches
  • 36 small round plates
  • Measures 7 in. x 7 in.
  • Made in the USA
  • Designs and iconography from the show, including the Central Perk logo
  • Perfect American Greetings party supplies for a birthday party or Friends-themed party
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Amazon.com 9.68 Yes Yes Yes

After weeks of planning a themed celebration, seeing these plates arrive felt like the final piece of the puzzle fell into place. These American Greetings dessert plates are a total win for any fan looking to bring a bit of Central Perk to their tabletop. The iconography is spot on, featuring recognizable designs from the show that immediately elevate the aesthetic of a birthday spread. At 7 inches, they are the ideal size for cakes, cookies, or small treats without being overly bulky. You get a generous 36-count pack, which is plenty for a medium-sized gathering. Plus, knowing they are made in the USA adds a nice layer of quality assurance to your party planning.

What We Like
Iconic show designs
Central Perk logo
Seven inch diameter
Thirty-six count pack
Made in USA

amscan American Greetings Minnie Mouse 1st Birthday 7" Square Plate (8 Count), Dessert Plates

American Greetings Minnie Mouse First Birthday Dessert Plates

AMERICAN GREETINGS 541834 7.00 X 7.00 X 0.60 inches 0.15 Pounds
  • 8 small party plates
  • Measures 7 in. x 7 in
  • Made in the USA
  • Small party plates feature Minnie Mouse next to a pink-striped number one and a fun confetti-style border pattern
  • Perfect American Greetings party supplies for a kid's birthday party or Minnie Mouse 1st Birthday themed party
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Notfoundanywhereelseonlyhere 5.95 Yes Yes Yes

Any parent planning a milestone first birthday celebration needs these Minnie Mouse plates to tie their entire theme together seamlessly. These American Greetings dessert plates feature a charming design where Minnie Mouse poses next to a pink-striped number one, all framed by a festive confetti-style border. At 7 inches square, they are the ideal size for serving cake, cupcakes, or small treats without the waste of a full-sized dinner plate. Since they are made in the USA, you can feel confident in the quality of your party supplies. This eight-count pack offers a coordinated, professional look that makes a toddler's big day feel extra special and photo-ready.

What We Like
Minnie Mouse design
Pink-striped number one
Confetti border pattern
Seven-inch square size
Made in USA

amscan Power Rangers Ninja Steel Dinner Plate, 8-Count Black, 9"

American Greetings Power Rangers Ninja Steel Dinner Plates

AMERICAN GREETINGS 551723 9.00 X 9.00 X 0.75 Inches 0.30 Pounds
  • 8 large party plates
  • Measures 9 in. x 9 in
  • Made in the USA
  • Power Rangers Ninja Steel dinner plates feature a fierce-looking Red Ranger on a bold blue background
  • Perfect American Greetings party supplies for a kid's birthday party or Power Rangers Ninja Steel themed party!
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Another Dream 6.98 Yes Yes Yes

The amscan Power Rangers Ninja Steel Dinner Plates turn a standard meal into a high-energy superhero event. Featuring a fierce Red Ranger set against a bold blue background, these plates instantly elevate the aesthetic of any themed birthday bash. Each 9-inch plate is sturdy enough for a kid's party spread, and the eight-count pack ensures you have enough for a small group of young fans. Since they are made in the USA, you can feel confident about the quality of these American Greetings party supplies. They are a simple, effective way to nail that Ninja Steel theme without needing elaborate decorations, making them a must-have for parents planning a superhero celebration.

What We Like
Fierce Red Ranger design
Bold blue background
Eight large plates
Made in USA
Nine inch diameter

Amscan Disney/Pixar Incredibles 2 Square Paper Plates - 7" - Multicolor - Pack of 8

American Greetings Incredibles 2 Square Snack Plates

AMERICAN GREETINGS 6107605 7.00 X 7.00 X 2.50 inches 0.15 Pounds
  • 8 small square plates
  • Measures 7 in. x 7 in.
  • Made in the USA
  • Disney Incredibles 2 snack plates feature a small square design with a beveled rim and an image of Mr. Incredible flying out from a nighttime city scene
  • Perfect American Greetings party supplies for a kid's birthday party or Incredibles-themed party
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Partytoyz Inc 9.69 Yes Yes Yes

Any parent planning a high-energy superhero birthday bash needs these Incredibles 2 snack plates to truly nail the theme. These aren't your standard round paper plates. The unique 7-inch square design with a stylish beveled rim adds a premium feel to a kid's dessert table. The artwork is particularly striking, featuring Mr. Incredible soaring through a nighttime city scene that brings the Disney/Pixar magic straight to the snack spread. Since they are made in the USA, you can feel confident in the quality of these American Greetings party supplies. They are sized perfectly for small bites, making them an essential, themed touch for any super-powered celebration.

What We Like
Square beveled design
Disney Pixar graphics
Made in USA
Seven inch size
Eight pack

amscan 540008 Disney©"Pirates Of The Caribbean" Square Plates, 7", 8 pcs, Dessert Plates

Disney Pirates of the Caribbean Square Dessert Plates

AMERICAN GREETINGS 540008 7.00 X 7.00 X 0.60 Inches 0.18 Pounds
  • 8 small party plates
  • Measures 7 in. X 7 in
  • Made in the USA
  • Pirates of the Caribbean small square party plate features the pirate Hector Barbosa
  • Perfect American Greetings party supplies for a kid's birthday party or Pirates of the Caribbean themed party
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
No No No

Any parent planning a high-seas adventure for their child's birthday needs these specific plates to nail the theme perfectly. These 7-inch square dessert plates feature Captain Hector Barbossa, adding an authentic touch of Disney magic to your snack spread. Because they are sized specifically for treats rather than full meals, they work brilliantly for cake, cookies, or small appetizers without taking up too much table space. Since they are made in the USA, you can feel confident in the quality of these American Greetings party supplies. With an eight-piece count per pack, they provide a convenient way to keep the pirate theme consistent throughout your dessert course.

What We Like
Hector Barbossa design
Square dessert shape
Made in USA
Seven inch size
Eight plate pack

Amscan 541841 Star Wars Rebels™ 7" Square Plates, 8 pcs, Party Favor

Amscan Star Wars Rebels Themed Party Plates

AMSCAN 013051508197 0.06 X 7.00 X 7.00 Inches 0.30 Pounds

PM Score for AMSCAN (PM Score)

5.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • 7" plates, 8 ct.
  • Red plates featuring Stormtroopers and the evil Inquisitor
  • Pamper yourself with dessert in these plates with thrilling design
  • Celebrate parties and fun occasions extraordinarily
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Bigsavings 9.83 No No No

Your living room transforms into a galactic battleground the moment you set these vibrant red plates on the snack table. Designed specifically for fans of the Star Wars Rebels series, these 7-inch plates feature striking imagery of Stormtroopers and the menacing Inquisitor, making them a standout choice for any themed celebration. They are the perfect size for serving desserts or small treats, allowing kids to indulge in sweets while staying fully immersed in the Star Wars universe. At a budget-friendly price point, these plates turn a standard birthday gathering into an extraordinary event that captures the thrill of the franchise. They are a simple yet effective way to add a touch of cinematic tension to your party decor.

What We Like
Star Wars Rebels design
Stormtrooper and Inquisitor graphics
Seven inch diameter
Eight pack quantity
Vibrant red color

DYLIVeS Purple Graduation Party Plates, Class of 2023 Disposable 9'' Dinner 7'' Dessert Plates Graduation Party Decorations Graduation Party Supplies...

DYLIVeS Purple Graduation Party Paper Plates

DYLIVES 3.40 X 8.70 X 8.70 inches

PM Score for DYLIVES (PM Score)

0.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • 🎓【PACKAGE】: 100 PCS including 50 pcs 9 inches dinner paper plates and 50 pcs 7 inches dessert plates.
  • 🎓【HIGH QUALITY & SAFETY】:These plates are made of high quality food grade paper, which is safe, eco-friendly, strong and durable.
  • 🎓【9 COLORS AVAILABLE】:We have designed 9 colors according to different universities. As a gift for graduation party, they are very suitable for holidays or graduation party, symbolic grad text to celebrate the happy moments on the day of the party and create an elegant graduation party atmosphere.
  • 🎓【PERFECT FOR GRADUATION】:The graduation plates are perfect for graduation party and matched the rest of your decorations perfectly. Great addition to help you plan your wonderful day.
  • 🍸【DISPOSABLE AND CONVENIENT:】:The disposable plates are perfectly matched the rest of your decorations. Great addition to help you plan your wonderful day.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
DYLIVeS 8.09 Yes Yes Yes

Setting up a graduation buffet for fifty guests can quickly turn into a cleanup nightmare without the right supplies. These DYLIVeS paper plates take the stress out of the celebration by providing a complete, coordinated set of 100 pieces. You get a generous mix of 50 large nine-inch dinner plates for the main course and 50 smaller seven-inch dessert plates for those celebratory sweets. The purple design creates an elegant, festive atmosphere that fits perfectly with school colors. Because they are made from high-quality, food-grade paper, they feel sturdy enough to handle a heavy meal without the eco-guilt of flimsy disposables. They are a practical, stylish way to keep the focus on the graduate rather than the dishes.

What We Like
Food-grade paper
Includes dessert plates
Sturdy and durable
Eco-friendly material
Elegant purple design
Buying Guide

A Guide to Selecting the Best American Greetings Party Plates

A Guide to Selecting the Best American Greetings Party Plates

Prioritize Theme and Visual Cohesion

The primary reason to choose American Greetings plates is their ability to anchor a specific theme. Unlike generic solid-colored paper plates, these designs are crafted to evoke specific moods and characters. When shopping, look beyond the initial color. Consider how the artwork on the plate complements your tablecloth, napkins, and balloon arches. If you are hosting a seasonal event, such as a spring garden party or a winter wonderland celebration, ensure the plate's motif aligns with your centerpieces. A successful table setting relies on a 'visual thread' that runs through all your supplies, and the plate is often the centerpiece of that thread.

Evaluate Material Strength and Durability

One of the biggest pitfalls in party planning is selecting plates that buckle under the weight of heavy foods. For a dessert-only event, lighter-weight paper plates may suffice. However, if you are serving substantial items like layered cake, heavy pasta, or moist appetizers, you must look for high-quality, heavy-duty paper construction. American Greetings offers various styles, so check the description for thickness. You want a plate that maintains its structural integrity from the moment the food is served until the guest finishes their meal. A flimsy plate leads to spills, which can quickly ruin the aesthetic of your themed table.

Consider Plate Size and Functionality

Not all plates are created equal, and choosing the wrong size can lead to awkward serving situations. Typically, you will encounter two main sizes: dessert plates and dinner plates. Dessert plates are ideal for cake, cookies, and small finger foods, making them perfect for tea parties or dessert bars. Dinner plates are necessary for main courses. If you are hosting a multi-course meal, it is often wise to purchase a combination of sizes to ensure guests aren't struggling to fit a slice of cake next to a serving of salad on a single small plate. Think about your menu first, then match the plate diameter to the portions you intend to serve.

Quantity and Pack Logic

When calculating how many plates to buy, always account for the 'overflow factor.' A common mistake is buying exactly enough plates for the number of guests on the RSVP list. In reality, guests often set down a plate and grab a fresh one, or you may need extra for serving snacks throughout the event. Look for packs that offer a generous count, or consider purchasing supplemental sets in a coordinating color if you need to scale up. It is much better to have a surplus of themed plates for a future event than to run out mid-celebration.

Ease of Cleanup and Environmental Impact

While the aesthetic is paramount, the practical side of hosting involves the aftermath. High-quality paper plates are designed for easy stacking and disposal, which is a significant advantage over ceramic when hosting large groups. When selecting your set, consider how easy they will be to clear away. While the focus is often on the design, a sturdy, easy-to-handle plate makes the transition from 'party mode' to 'cleanup mode' much smoother for the host.

Ready to choose?

Jump back to our ranked picks or compare the shortlist side by side.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers about American Greetings Party Plates before you buy.

Most high-quality paper party plates are designed to handle warm appetizers, but avoid serving boiling liquids to prevent the structural integrity from softening.

Check the specific product packaging. While many heavy-duty paper plates are microwave-safe, some decorative plates with metallic foil accents should never be microwaved.

For heavy main courses, look for 'premium' or 'heavy-duty' options with reinforced bases to prevent bending or leaking under the weight of food.

Many top-rated American brands now offer compostable or biodegradable options made from sugarcane bagasse or recycled paper to minimize environmental impact.

Yes, party plate sets typically offer a variety of sizes, including 7-inch plates for desserts and 10-to-12-inch plates for full meals.

High-end party plates usually feature a moisture-resistant coating that prevents oils and sauces from soaking through the paper during a party.

Yes, most designed for party use are stackable, making them ideal for self-service buffet lines and easy storage.
Rankings & Insights

Our American Greetings Party Plates Rankings

42 Products Compared
7.0 Avg PM Score
3 Brands Ranked

Top 10 American Greetings Party Plates Brands on Amazon

Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our rankings.

  1. 01 American Greetings 38 (90.5%)
  2. 02 Dylives 3 (7.1%)
  3. 03 Amscan 1 (2.4%)

How We Selected These Products

We compared American Greetings Party Plates products using product details and customer ratings to identify the best options in the health & household products..

From that comparison we shortlisted the top 7 American Greetings Party Plates for this page..

We aim to help you find the right plates products for your needs and save you time when choosing which American Greetings Party Plates to buy.