Best Maybelline New York Waterproof Eyebrow Color in 2026

Daisy
Last Updated: Jul 19, 2026

At a Glance: Our Top Picks for Maybelline New York Waterproof Eyebrow Color

essence | Baby Got Brow! Eyebrow Pencil | Long Lasting & Waterproof with Spoolie | Vegan, Cruelty Free, Formulated without Parabens, Preservatives, Oil & Alcohol (20 | Brunette)
#TOP1
Essence | Baby Got Brow! Eyebrow Pencil |
9.4
PM SCORE
Eye Embrace Warm Betty Classic: Light Gray Wooden Eyebrow Pencil – Waterproof, Double-Ended Pencil with Sharpener & Spoolie Brush, Cruelty-Free
#TOP2
Eye Embrace Warm Betty Classic: Light Gray Wooden
9.4
PM SCORE
Youngfocus Eye Makeup Brow Contour Kit, 6 Waterproof Eyebrow Powders Palette Set, 5 Eyebrow Stencils,14 Highly Pigmented Eyeshadows, 3 Highlighter Contour Powders, Spoolie/Brush Duo, Eye Brow Wax - Best Gift
#TOP3
Youngfocus Eye Makeup Brow Contour Kit, 6 Waterproof
9.2
PM SCORE

* PickSmartly editors independently research, review, and endorse the top products through comprehensive data analysis. We may earn a commission for qualifying purchases made through our product links.

Summary of the Best Maybelline New York Waterproof Eyebrow Color of 2026

Market Overview
Maybelline New York Waterproof Eyebrow Color Reviewed
  • Reviews Analyzed: 3236 Items
  • PM Avg. Rating: 6.8 / 10
14 Products Evaluated
  • Highest Price: $45.00
  • Lowest Price: $4.99
  • Avg. Price: $16.41

Essence | Baby Got Brow! Eyebrow Pencil | Long Lasting & Waterproof With Spoolie | Vegan, Cruelty Free, Formulated Without Parabens, Preservatives, Oil & Alcohol (20 | Brunette)

ESSENCE COSMETICS
932327
7.32 X 1.42 X 0.79 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
essence cosmetics 9.95

Features

BABY GOT BROW!: Give your brows the WOW factor with essence’s Baby Got Brow! Eyebrow Pencil! The triangle applicator is perfect for softly framing the eyebrows, drawing fine hair-like lines or intensifying your brow look.

WATERPROOF FORMULA: The long lasting, waterproof formula is perfect for every day use or for special occasions!

2-in-1 APPLICATOR: The triangular tip allows for precise application while the spoolie on the other end lets you blend brows seamlessly and brush the hairs into the desired shape during styling.

CLAIMS: Vegan, cruelty free, paraben free, fragrance free, oil free, fragrance free, alcohol free.

CRUELTY FREE: essence cosmetics is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand. We do not test any of our products on animals.

Eye Embrace Warm Betty Classic: Light Gray Wooden Eyebrow Pencil – Waterproof, Double-Ended Pencil With Sharpener & Spoolie Brush, Cruelty-Free

EYE EMBRACE
745809071065
7.28 X 0.79 X 0.79 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.82

Features

True light gray pencil – Warm Betty for warm undertones. Ditch the dye and embrace your natural gray hair. These gray eyebrow pencils are perfect for those with gray hair, silver hair, or salt and pepper hair. Eye Embrace's exclusive gray brow colors are formulated to blend easily with your natural coloring.

Classic Wood Pencil – with sharpener included built-in on cap. Keep your pencil sharpened for a slim eyebrow pencil. As you age, your pale gray eyebrows may make you look washed out. Define your brows with grey brow pencils to accentuate and frame your face for a more youthful look.

Waterproof and Smudgeproof Formula: for eyebrows that last all day! You're going places and your makeup should go with you. Our long-lasting eyebrow pencil will give you defined brows all day. Your eyebrow makeup will last you from day to night.

Spoolie Brush – the double-ended eyebrow pencil features a premium spoolie brush to blend and perfect your brows. Use the spoolie eyebrow wand to comb and groom your brow hairs. Then, use the pencil to fill in your brows with soft even strokes in the direction of hair growth. Finally, use the spoolie brush to blend and soften the pencil, following the natural shape of your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients – cruelty free, paraben free, gluten free, and talc free. All our products are made thoughtfully with high quality ingredients and go through extensive cruelty-free testing – Eye Embrace is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified and would never test on animals!

Youngfocus Eye Makeup Brow Contour Kit, 6 Waterproof Eyebrow Powders Palette Set, 5 Eyebrow Stencils,14 Highly Pigmented Eyeshadows, 3 Highlighter Contour Powders, Spoolie/Brush Duo, Eye Brow Wax - Best Gift

YOUNGFOCUS
MF-01
5.51 X 4.72 X 0.39 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
USABest Products 9.89

Features

EASY TO USE - The Youngfocus Brow Contour Kit empowers you to create a wide range of stunning eye makeup looks. Whether you're aiming for natural, everyday brows or bold, dramatic arches, this kit has got you covered. The carefully curated shades allow you to effortlessly customize your brow color, ensuring a flawless and personalized finish every single time. This all-inclusive kit has everything you need, making it an absolute must-have for every makeup enthusiast!

EACH KIT INCLUDES: A Step-by-Step Instructions and an Eye Makeup set Guide, 6 blendable brow powders (Taupe, Warm Gold, Soft Dark Brunette, Auburn, Dark Brunette, and Warm Brunette), 14 Highly Pigmented Eyeshadows , 3Color Concealer Contour Powders, 5 Timeless Classic Eyebrow Stencil kit, Brow Wax, and a Pro Series Double Ended Brow Brush with Spoolie.

EASY & HASSLE-FREE - Get the Stunning Eyebrows you've always desired and achieve a flawless eye makeup look! This incredible eye makeup kit is like having your own personal portable makeup artist, with a travel-friendly palette that includes all the essentials you need to define, fill , and shape your eyebrows and create the perfect Eye Makeup!

LONG-LASTING, SMUDGE-PROOF AND WATERPROOF - The long-wear formula keeps the eye makeup to stay firmly in place all day without rubbing them too hard. It is also often waterproof and smudge-proof making them great for warmer weather or active days.

BEAUTY FOR ALL & LOOK OUR BEST - This eye makeup kit is great for beginners and professionals to see results in seconds. Suitable makeup sets for all skin types and skin tones - Cruelty-free, Paraben Free & Gluten free.

#TOP4

4D Charming Tinted Eyebrow Gel, Cilrofelr Waterproof Eyebrow Gel With Spoolie Brush & Eyebrow Razor, Long Lasting, Non-Sticky, For Natural Brow Looking, Cruelty Free & Paraben Free, Soft Brown, 5.0G

CILROFELR
US-GEL-R04
0.01 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Cilrofelr Beauty 8.85

Features

【Tint & Fill Brows】Made of high pigmented and smooth formula, cilrofelr eyebrow gel instantly enhances the volume and color of the eyebrows. It’s also great for filling in sparse hairs! No clumpy, and quickly achieve a dramatic brow effect! Suitable for people of all ages!

【Mimic Natural Brows】Do you usually get troubled for messy eyebrows? This tinted brow gel separates, grooms and shapes your eyebrows while setting them in place all day. Make your eyebrows more fluffy and natural. It is great for daily makeup.

【Waterproof & Long wearing】The amazing part about cilrofelr eyebrow gel is that it is waterproof, smudge-proof, sweat-proof and won't budge in 24 hours. It is convinient to use and carry in own home and when go out. You are perfect anytime, anywhere.

【Easy to use】Apply the gel from the root of the eyebrows, and then use the spoolie brush to gently spread it. Allow 1-2 minutes for the gel to dry and blend with your eyebrows. Just a few swipes could create a life-like hair texture easily.

【What You Get】 Cilrofelr Beauty is a cruelty-free brand. You will get 1 eyebrow gel and 1 eyebrow razor. If you have any questions, please contact us directly. We have 24 hours friendly customer service and 100% refund guarantee.

4D Charming Tinted Eyebrow Gel, Cilrofelr Waterproof Eyebrow Gel With Spoolie Brush & Eyebrow Razor, Long Lasting, Non-Sticky, For Natural Brow Looking, Cruelty Free & Paraben Free, Dark Brown, 5.0G

CILROFELR
US-GEL-R01
0.79 X 0.71 X 4.65 Inches
0.01 Pounds
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING

Features

【Tint & Fill Brows】Made of high pigmented and smooth formula, cilrofelr eyebrow gel instantly enhances the volume and color of the eyebrows. It’s also great for filling in sparse hairs! No clumpy, and quickly achieve a dramatic brow effect! Suitable for people of all ages!

【Mimic Natural Brows】Do you usually get troubled for messy eyebrows? This tinted brow gel separates, grooms and shapes your eyebrows while setting them in place all day. Make your eyebrows more fluffy and natural. It is great for daily makeup.

【Waterproof & Long wearing】The amazing part about cilrofelr eyebrow gel is that it is waterproof, smudge-proof, sweat-proof and won't budge in 24 hours. It is convinient to use and carry in own home and when go out. You are perfect anytime, anywhere.

【Easy to use】Apply the gel from the root of the eyebrows, and then use the spoolie brush to gently spread it. Allow 1-2 minutes for the gel to dry and blend with your eyebrows. Just a few swipes could create a life-like hair texture easily.

【What You Get】 Cilrofelr Beauty is a cruelty-free brand. You will get 1 eyebrow gel and 1 eyebrow razor. If you have any questions, please contact us directly. We have 24 hours friendly customer service and 100% refund guarantee.

#TOP6

Heybeauty 3 Packs Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil , 2 X Fill Brow Pencil And 1 X Define Pencil With Spoolie Brush, Automatic Smudge-Proof Eye Brow Color(4# Grey)

HEYBEAUTY
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
qiankl 8.60

Features

[3 in 1 EYEBROW SET]:Include:1x1.5mm Define Pencil for Achieve Sleek lines ,2x3.5mm Brow pencil for Evenly Fills in Brows

[Special Triangular Tip]: Unique Triangular tip head helps you easily draw the contour of eyebrow and continue to color inside for create vivid and nature eyebrows.

[WATERPROOF & SMUDGE-PROOF] : Natural-looking formula, long-wearing matt hue that expertly adheres to hairs for eight hours, resisting sweat and water for flawless brows all day.

[SAFE INGREDIENTS&PRACTICES]: All our products are vegan, cruelty free, paraben free, gluten free, and recyclable. We keep your health, the safety of the planet, and the lives of animals in mind when creating and testing our products.

[OUR MISSION]: high-quality, professional grade makeup and tools to unleash your creativity. Whether you are a professional cosmetologist or an on-the-go mom, Heybeauty's makeup and tools put the artistic design in your hands.

Eye Embrace Warm Betty: Light Gray Eyebrow Powder/Hair Powder/Root Cover-Up – Waterproof, Cruelty-Free

EYE EMBRACE
745809071034
2.05 X 2.05 X 0.87 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.81

Features

True light gray eyebrow powder – Warm Betty for warm undertones. Ditch the dye and embrace your natural gray hair. These gray eyebrow powders are perfect for those with gray hair, silver hair, or salt and pepper hair. Eye Embrace's exclusive gray brow colors are formulated to blend easily with your natural coloring.

Powder creates a soft natural look. As you age, your pale gray eyebrows may make you look washed out. Define your brows with grey brow powders to accentuate and enhance your brows while maintaining a softer look.

Also great as hair powder to cover up roots. Fill in your hairline with brow powder to create the look of fuller, thicker hair. Sweep powder upwards into your part and temples, filling in spare areas along the hairline.

Best if paired with Eye Embrace Pro Grip Angled Eyebrow Brush. Use the spoolie eyebrow wand to comb and groom your brow hairs. Then, use the premium angled brush with the eyebrow powder to fill in your brows with soft even strokes in the direction of hair growth following the natural shape of your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients – cruelty free, paraben free, and gluten free. All our products are made thoughtfully with high quality ingredients and go through extensive cruelty-free testing – Eye Embrace is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified and would never test on animals!

Eye Embrace Cool Helen: Light Gray Eyebrow Powder / Hair Powder / Root Cover – Waterproof, Cruelty-Free

EYE EMBRACE
745809071041
2.05 X 2.05 X 0.87 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.82

Features

True light gray eyebrow powder – Cool Helen contains a hint of blue for those with cool undertones. Ditch the dye and embrace your natural gray hair. These gray eyebrow powders are perfect for those with gray hair, silver hair, or salt and pepper hair. Eye Embrace's exclusive gray brow colors are formulated to blend easily with your natural coloring.

Powder creates a soft natural look. As you age, your pale gray eyebrows may make you look washed out. Define your brows with grey brow powders to accentuate and enhance your brows while maintaining a softer look.

Also great as hair powder to cover up roots. Fill in your hairline with brow powder to create the look of fuller, thicker hair. Sweep powder upwards into your part and temples, filling in spare areas along the hairline.

Best if paired with Eye Embrace Pro Grip Angled Eyebrow Brush. Use the spoolie eyebrow wand to comb and groom your brow hairs. Then, use the premium angled brush with the eyebrow powder to fill in your brows with soft even strokes in the direction of hair growth following the natural shape of your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients – cruelty free, paraben free, and gluten free. All our products are made thoughtfully with high quality ingredients and go through extensive cruelty-free testing – Eye Embrace is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified and would never test on animals!

Eye Embrace Liz Classic: Warm Medium Gray Wooden Eyebrow Pencil – Waterproof, Double-Ended Pencil With Sharpener & Spoolie Brush, Cruelty-Free

EYE EMBRACE
632688077304
7.28 X 0.79 X 0.79 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.82

Features

True medium gray pencil – Liz for warm undertones. Ditch the dye and embrace your natural gray hair. These gray eyebrow pencils are perfect for those with gray hair, silver hair, or salt and pepper hair. Eye Embrace's exclusive gray brow colors are formulated to blend easily with your natural coloring.

Classic Wood Pencil – with sharpener included built-in on cap. Keep your pencil sharpened for a slim eyebrow pencil. As you age, your pale gray eyebrows may make you look washed out. Define your brows with grey brow pencils to accentuate and frame your face for a more youthful look.

Waterproof and Smudgeproof Formula: for eyebrows that last all day! You're going places and your makeup should go with you. Our long-lasting eyebrow pencil will give you defined brows all day. Your eyebrow makeup will last you from day to night.

Spoolie Brush – the double-ended eyebrow pencil features a premium spoolie brush to blend and perfect your brows. Use the spoolie eyebrow wand to comb and groom your brow hairs. Then, use the pencil to fill in your brows with soft even strokes in the direction of hair growth. Finally, use the spoolie brush to blend and soften the pencil, following the natural shape of your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients – cruelty free, paraben free, gluten free, and talc free. All our products are made thoughtfully with high quality ingredients and go through extensive cruelty-free testing – Eye Embrace is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified and would never test on animals!

Eye Embrace Grace: Medium Gray Eyebrow Powder/Hair Powder/Root Cover-Up – Waterproof, Cruelty-Free

EYE EMBRACE
632688077250
2.05 X 2.05 X 0.87 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.81

Features

True medium gray eyebrow powder – Grace for cool undertones. Ditch the dye and embrace your natural gray hair. These gray eyebrow powders are perfect for those with gray hair, silver hair, or salt and pepper hair. Eye Embrace's exclusive gray brow colors are formulated to blend easily with your natural coloring.

Powder creates a soft natural look. As you age, your pale gray eyebrows may make you look washed out. Define your brows with grey brow powders to accentuate and enhance your brows while maintaining a softer look.

Also great as hair powder to cover up roots. Fill in your hairline with brow powder to create the look of fuller, thicker hair. Sweep powder upwards into your part and temples, filling in spare areas along the hairline.

Best if paired with Eye Embrace Pro Grip Angled Eyebrow Brush. Use the spoolie eyebrow wand to comb and groom your brow hairs. Then, use the premium angled brush with the eyebrow powder to fill in your brows with soft even strokes in the direction of hair growth following the natural shape of your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients – cruelty free, paraben free, and gluten free. All our products are made thoughtfully with high quality ingredients and go through extensive cruelty-free testing – Eye Embrace is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified and would never test on animals!

Eye Embrace Classics 3-Pack Gray Wooden Eyebrow Pencils Bundle - Cool Helen, Warm Betty, And Liz (Waterproof, Double-Ended Pencil With Sharpener & Spoolie Brush, Cruelty-Free)

EYE EMBRACE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.81

Features

3 full-sized gray eyebrow pencils – Warm Betty and Cool Helen light gray. Liz medium gray. Perfect for those with gray, silver, or salt and pepper hair. Blends easily with your natural coloring.

Classic wooden pencil with sharpener included on cap.

Waterproof and smudge-proof formula for brows that last.

Spoolie brush – blend and perfect your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients: Cruelty Free, Paraben Free, Gluten Free, and Talc Free

Waterproof Eyebrow Gel By Lalastyle, Waterproof Eyebrow Gel With Brush,Stays On All Day, Non-Sticky, For Natural Brow Looking, Cruelty Free & Paraben Free (Drak Brown)

LALASTYLE
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
LALASTYLE 2.10

Features

①Natural Looking:Different from traditional eyebrow gel, our eyebrow gel contains high-quality synthetic fiber which makes easier to shape, fill and hold your brows in place.Get full, voluminous-looking brows with this buildable, Fiber-infused brow gel

②Waterproof&Fade-proof:Formulated with longwear polymers to create a waterproof film.Dries in 5 seconds and long lasting to make sure the brows look remarkable for 24 hours

③How to Brush: apply gel and start From the inner corner and follow the arch, working in upward strokes slowly.Your brows will be perfect looking in just a few minutes!

④100% cruelty-free & Vegan

⑤Quality Assurance:If you have any question about this product, or you are not satisfied with our product, please feel free to contact us and we will spare no efforts to offer you a best solution.All responses will be used to further improve the quality of our service and products

Eye Embrace Liz: Medium Gray Eyebrow Powder, Hair Powder, Root Cover-Up – Waterproof, Cruelty-Free

EYE EMBRACE
745809071041
2.05 X 2.05 X 0.87 Inches
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Burgeón Brands 9.81

Features

True medium gray eyebrow powder – Liz for warm undertones. Ditch the dye and embrace your natural gray hair. These gray eyebrow powders are perfect for those with gray hair, silver hair, or salt and pepper hair. Eye Embrace's exclusive gray brow colors are formulated to blend easily with your natural coloring.

Powder creates a soft natural look. As you age, your pale gray eyebrows may make you look washed out. Define your brows with grey brow powders to accentuate and enhance your brows while maintaining a softer look.

Also great as hair powder to cover up roots. Fill in your hairline with brow powder to create the look of fuller, thicker hair. Sweep powder upwards into your part and temples, filling in spare areas along the hairline.

Best if paired with Eye Embrace Pro Grip Angled Eyebrow Brush. Use the spoolie eyebrow wand to comb and groom your brow hairs. Then, use the premium angled brush with the eyebrow powder to fill in your brows with soft even strokes in the direction of hair growth following the natural shape of your brows.

High-Quality Ingredients – cruelty free, paraben free, and gluten free. All our products are made thoughtfully with high quality ingredients and go through extensive cruelty-free testing – Eye Embrace is proudly Leaping Bunny Certified and would never test on animals!

Chella Eyebrow Pencil Eyebrow Cream Combo, Taupe

CHELLA
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Chella 7.66

Features

TANTALIZING TAUPE: This is our #1 shade in our eyebrow! This shade compliments a variety of different people + is our most universal color. Tantalizing Taupe is ideal for lighter hair but is buildable to provide a light fill to a cooler brown.

OUR MISSION: We focus only on brows with this brow pencil and cream and create salon-quality products. At Chella, we have simplified this confusing routine into "How to Brow in 3 Easy Steps" - 1 | FILL 2 | DEFINE 3 | HIGHLIGHT

SAFE INGREDIENTS, SAFE PRACTICES: All our products are vegan, cruelty free, paraben free, gluten free, and recyclable. We keep your health, the safety of the planet, and the lives of animals in mind when creating and testing our products including our mechanical brow pencil

LONG WEARING, WATER RESISTANT - Our innovative and long wearing pomade formula is water-resistant with a rich velvety consistency for making your brows hold with color all day long

BEAUTY ON THE GO - Our convenient all-in-one eyebrow pencil and cream bundle is ideal for the modern woman on the go. The cream is stored at one end with a true airlock seal and contains an angled brush providing an effortless and precise application.

Top 10 waterproof eyebrow color Brands on Amazon

Here is the list of top-rated brands that were evaluated by PM.

Brand Count
Eye Embrace 7
Cilrofelr 2
Chella 1
Essence Cosmetics 1
Heybeauty 1
Lalastyle 1
Youngfocus 1

Top 10 waterproof eyebrow color Brands Pie Chart


We've carried out a comprehensive analysis of 3,236 reviews on waterproof eyebrow color, using our selection criteria to identify the best options in the categories. Our findings reveal that most customers typically select waterproof eyebrow color priced around $16.41, with top brands including and

Our team of expert editors reviewed these high-quality items and handpicked the top 14 waterproof eyebrow color for your consideration. We've also done extensive research on numerous sellers, identifying the best ones in the categories category. These include and .

We are dedicated to assisting our users in finding the right color Products based on their needs, saving them considerable time when choosing which waterproof eyebrow color to buy. We take pride in the number of satisfied users we've helped through our thorough and insightful reviews.